Which option is right for you?

A family with mixed film formats

You have negatives in various formats and want to check in advance that the scanner and supplied holders suit your collection. Epson lists holders for 35mm and 120/220 film for the Perfection V600 Photo; Rollei lists inserts for formats including 110 film for the DF-S 310 SE.

A careful 35mm film archivist

You want to view 35mm images on a computer and possibly edit them, even if it takes longer to process each image. Plustek describes the OpticFilm 8200i SE as a computer-connected option for 35mm film.

A family sharing one computer

You want a process the whole family can follow, with clear file transfer and copies stored away from the shared computer. Rollei says the DF-S 310 SE can save images to internal memory or an SD/SDHC card. The Library of Congress advises keeping archive copies on different storage media and in separate locations.

What should you look for when choosing?

Dedicated film scanner

Choose this option: if you mainly want to view and edit 35mm negatives on a computer.

Bear in mind: supported film formats and software vary by model; check compatibility with the shared computer.

Flatbed scanner with a transparency unit

Choose this option: if your collection includes supported 35mm strips and medium-format film, and you want to work on a computer.

Bear in mind: check the film holders and the condition of the specific unit. Epson lists the V600 Photo as discontinued on its Dutch product page.

Standalone scanner with a memory card

Choose this option: if family members want to scan without installing a scanner on the shared computer.

Bear in mind: according to the Dutch Consumers’ Association, basic scanners generally produce less detail and poorer colours than a good film scanner.

What to consider What should you check? Who does this matter most to?
Film formats and holders List the formats in your collection and check that the correct holders are included with the exact model. If our collection includes different film formats, I want to know first whether the holders will fit. Around 33% of consumers give format compatibility top priority.
Image review and archive files Check the file formats and software. Assess a test scan for detail, colour and dust rather than comparing the stated resolution alone. If I want to review scans and perhaps edit them later, image control matters more to me than simply creating files quickly. Around 27% of consumers give image review top priority.
Scanning speed Find out whether film is fed in manually or advanced automatically, and allow for preparation and editing time too. When I have a large batch, I want to minimise manual feeding. Around 20% of consumers give continuous scanning top priority.
Transferring and storing files Agree on a folder structure and naming system; if you choose a standalone scanner, check which memory card it needs too. If several family members are scanning, I want to find files easily and keep copies in separate locations. Around 20% of consumers give a shared archiving workflow top priority.

Common pitfalls

  • Focusing only on the highest dpi or megapixel figure

    Resolution isn’t the only factor to consider. According to Rollei, the 24MP setting on the DF-S 310 SE is interpolated, not the sensor’s native resolution.

    Also compare the file formats and film holder. If possible, assess a test scan for the level of detail you need for your family archive.

    A higher stated figure won’t eliminate the need for editing, so allow time to review and correct your scans.

  • Choosing a flatbed scanner without checking the holders

    Support for multiple film formats is only useful if the correct holders are included with the unit on offer. Epson lists the V600 Photo as discontinued on its Dutch product page.

    Check that the specific unit includes everything it should and that the software works on your computer.

  • Using a memory card or shared computer as your only archive

    Files stored on a single device or in one location could be lost if that device fails or goes missing.

    The Library of Congress advises keeping copies on at least two different storage media and in separate physical locations.

    You’ll need additional storage media to keep separate copies.

  • Assuming that scanning your own films is always quicker or cheaper

    Feeding in the film, checking scans, correcting colours and storing files all add to the workload. The Dutch Consumers’ Association points out that your choice also depends on the size of your collection, the quality you want and the time you have available.

    Compare the entire scanning process with a quote, and ask a digitisation service which formats it accepts, what files it supplies and which corrections are included.

Brands as examples of different scanner options

Plustek

The OpticFilm 8200i SE is a computer-connected model for 35mm negatives and slides.

  • Plustek lists an infrared channel for detecting dust and scratches, as well as scanning and SilverFast software included in the box.
  • The stated 7200 dpi is a Plustek specification, not an independent measurement. Check the software works with your computer; the listed film formats don’t include medium format.

reflecta

The RPS 10S is designed for processing 35mm film strips on a computer.

  • reflecta lists automatic transport for film strips containing 3 to 40 frames, infrared correction and DNG output.
  • These are specifications for this model, not general features of the brand. The RPS 10S isn’t suitable for medium format.

Rollei

The DF-S 310 SE is a standalone scanner with a screen and a memory card option.

  • Rollei lists inserts for formats including 110 film, along with an SD/SDHC slot.
  • According to Rollei, the 24MP setting is interpolated, not the sensor’s native resolution. Consider whether this process gives you enough control over the images for your intended archive.

Epson

The Perfection V600 Photo is a flatbed scanner with film holders for supported formats.

  • Epson lists holders for 35mm and 120/220 film, TIFF output and DIGITAL ICE for this model.
  • Epson Netherlands lists the V600 Photo as discontinued and no longer available through its product page. If you find one elsewhere, check the holders and software.

Kodak Photo Plus

The SCANZA offers a standalone JPEG option for several older film formats listed on the European product page.

  • The manufacturer lists inserts and storage on an SD card.
  • The European product page says “Currently Unavailable”. If you find one for sale, check the exact model and what’s included.

Related products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Does the scanner need to be connected to the shared computer?

Not always. According to Rollei, a standalone scanner such as the DF-S 310 SE can save files to internal memory or a suitable SD/SDHC card. If you choose a computer-connected scanner, check that its connection and software are compatible with your operating system.

How can you make sure scans aren’t stored only on the shared computer?

Use a consistent folder structure and clear file names. The Library of Congress advises keeping copies on at least two different storage media and in separate physical locations. This is archiving advice, not a legal requirement.

What can you do if a scanner bought in the Netherlands doesn’t work properly?

When you buy as a consumer, the seller must offer a solution if the product doesn’t meet your reasonable expectations. According to the Dutch government, the Netherlands has no fixed statutory warranty period; what you can reasonably expect also depends on the product and the circumstances.

Can you share scans showing identifiable family members?

According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, the exception for personal or household use applies when images remain private or are shared with only a very limited group. This exception doesn’t apply to wider sharing, such as posting publicly on social media, so consider that use separately.

Where can you take an old scanner when replacing it?

According to the Dutch government, when buying a new appliance, individuals can hand in an old, similar electrical appliance through the take-back scheme. There are also collection points and local authority facilities.