Which scanning option is right for you?

Contact sheet creator with lots of film strips

Wants to make growing piles of negative strips quick to browse and easy to search, ideally without selecting every frame individually. The Consumers’ Association discusses the amount of material and the time involved as factors to consider; Epson Netherlands describes the film holders for the V850.

Collector with several film formats

May have 120 film as well as 35mm, so should first check which formats the scanner and its holders actually support. Epson Netherlands lists 120/220 support for the V850 and V600 Photo.

35mm photographer who selects individual frames

Wants to process lots of 35mm frames, create contact sheets from individual files and perhaps scan interesting frames separately later. Plustek and reflecta describe batch or automatic processing of 35mm frames; Adobe explains how to lay out a contact sheet in Lightroom Classic.

What should you look for in a scanner for contact sheets?

Flatbed scanner with a transparency unit

Choose this option: if you want to capture complete negative strips in a single overview, or if you also have 120 film. Epson Netherlands lists 35mm and 120/220 holders for the V850; the scanning workflow described by Emerson College Technology & Media uses this model.

Bear in mind: scanning an overview and scanning selected frames in detail are two different steps. Epson Netherlands marks the V600 Photo and V850 Pro as discontinued.

Film scanner with batch or strip feeding

Choose this option: if you want to scan lots of individual 35mm frames and then arrange the files into contact sheets yourself. Plustek says the OpticFilm 135i Ai can scan up to six frames in a single pass with the strip holder; reflecta specifies automatic transport for strips containing three to forty frames for the RPS 10S.

Bear in mind: the holders and feed systems mentioned are for 35mm film. Batch processing does not necessarily mean that a whole strip is captured as a single contact sheet.

Simple scanner with a screen and memory card storage

Choose this option: if you want to view and save individual frames from 135, 110 or 126 film, then create the contact sheet digitally later. The European product information for the KODAK Slide N Scan lists these formats.

Bear in mind: the KODAK product page does not describe exporting a complete strip as a contact sheet, and says an SD card is required but not included. The Consumers’ Association places simple scanners below good film scanners as a category for image quality.

Have your films digitised

Consider this option: if your collection is large and you would rather not spend time scanning, correcting and managing the files yourself. The Consumers’ Association lists the amount of material and the time you want to spend on it as factors when choosing.

Agree in advance: whether you will receive contact sheets, how the strips and frames will be named, and which resolution and file formats will be supplied.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Create an easy-to-search contact sheet quickly Check whether you can capture complete strips under a transparency unit, or whether you need to scan individual frames and use contact sheet software. I want to keep lots of negatives in order and easily find a frame later. Around 36% of consumers prioritise creating and processing contact sheets.
Work with different film formats Make a list of your formats and check that the model’s holder and scanning area are suitable for them. I have different film formats and want to avoid finding that some of them do not fit the scanner or holder. Around 29% of consumers prioritise format compatibility.
Scan selected frames individually Check whether you can rescan a selected frame and which settings and file formats are available. After creating an overview, I want to save some frames separately for further use later. Around 21% of consumers prioritise individual scans of selected frames.
Get started easily Check which memory card is required, whether it is included and how you can organise the saved images later. I want to view and save images straight away without setting up a complex scanning system. Around 14% of consumers prioritise ease of use.

Common mistakes when choosing

  • Confusing batch scanning with scanning a complete strip as a contact sheet

    Batch features can process several individual 35mm frames, whereas the flatbed workflow described captures an overview of negatives in strip order. These produce different results.

    Decide in advance whether you want a single overview of a complete strip or a grid that you put together afterwards from individual scans. If necessary, ask to see an example of the output.

    Individual files may take extra time and software work to arrange into a contact sheet.

  • Choosing based on resolution alone

    A stated resolution is not, by itself, a comparative measure of image quality. The Consumers’ Association distinguishes between simple scanners and good film scanners.

    Think of a quick overview for selecting frames and a separate final scan as two different things. Assess the output against what you want to use the images for.

    If the first round of scanning is not enough for your needs, you may have to do extra scanning and correction work.

  • Buying a discontinued flatbed model without checking the whole setup

    Epson Netherlands marks the V600 Photo and V850 Pro as discontinued. For a film workflow, you also need the right holders, a transparency unit and software that works.

    If you are considering a used model, check the condition and presence of the holders and transparency unit, and make sure the software works on your computer.

    You may need to find a suitable film holder or work out how to use software that does not run on your computer.

  • Mistaking a scanner with a screen for a complete contact sheet system

    The European product information for the KODAK Slide N Scan describes viewing and saving individual frames, not arranging a whole strip into a contact sheet.

    Check which memory card is required and plan how you will name the files and arrange them in order on a contact sheet afterwards.

    The European version described requires an SD card, which is not included.

Relevant brands to consider

Epson

The Dutch information on the Perfection V850 Pro and V600 Photo describes flatbed scanners with a transparency unit and film holders.

  • For the V850, Epson lists holders for three strips of six 35mm frames and support for 120/220 film; for the V600, it lists two strips of six and support for 120/220 film.
  • Epson Netherlands marks both models covered here as discontinued. This applies to these models and is not a judgement on every scanner from the brand.

Plustek

According to Plustek Europe, the OpticFilm 135i Ai is designed for individual scans of 35mm film strips, with batch processing using a holder.

  • Plustek says it can scan up to six frames from one strip in a single pass with the holder, as well as four mounted slides.
  • The product information describes no support for 120 film or direct capture of a complete strip as a single contact sheet.

reflecta

The RPS 10S is a 35mm film scanner with automatic transport for strips containing multiple frames.

  • reflecta specifies automatic transport for three to forty frames and a holder for mounted slides.
  • The product information cited does not support 120 film or direct output of a complete strip as a contact sheet.

KODAK Photo Plus

The European product page describes the KODAK Slide N Scan as a scanner with a screen and memory card storage for individual frames from 135, 110 and 126 film.

  • The product information describes viewing and saving individual frames.
  • An SD card is required but not included. The product page does not describe automatic contact sheet output; the Consumers’ Association places simple scanners below good film scanners as a category for image quality.

Products related to this topic

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can any flatbed scanner create a contact sheet from negatives?

No. You need a transparency unit and a suitable film holder. The published workflow from Emerson College Technology & Media is specifically for the Epson V850; for another model, check the manual and available accessories.

How do I make a contact sheet if my scanner only saves individual frames?

Save the frames in the right order and give them recognisable file names. You can then arrange them into a contact sheet using suitable software. Adobe explains how to create a contact sheet layout in the Print module of Lightroom Classic.

How can I tell whether my film formats will fit in the scanner?

Compare each format with the specifications for the exact scanner model and its holder. The holders Plustek describes for the OpticFilm 135i Ai are for 35mm film; Epson lists support for 35mm and 120/220 film for the V850 covered here.

What should I look out for with software and setup?

Before buying, check that the software works on your computer and that the correct film holders are included. The Consumers’ Association points out that removing dust, correcting colour and organising files all take time. Check the software requirements for the specific model and your computer.

How can I compare scanning films myself with having them digitised?

Weigh up the time needed for scanning, correcting and managing files against the output you want. If you use a digitising service, agree in advance whether you will receive contact sheets, how the frames will be named, and which resolution and file formats will be supplied.