Start by taking stock of the film formats you have, then decide whether you need editable archive files or mainly quick-to-access viewing copies. A computer-connected 35mm scanner works differently from a standalone scanner that saves JPEG files to an SD card. Mixed formats, fragile originals or a large collection may make a suitable flatbed scanner or outsourcing worth considering. Make test scans and check the holders, file output and total processing time before you decide.
Who is this choice relevant to?
Collection manager with mixed-format negatives
You want to avoid finding that strips of 35mm, 120 or other formats won’t fit in the holder. So, start by sorting a representative part of the collection by format. Plustek, reflecta and KODAK Photo Plus list different supported film formats.
Volunteer creating archive files
You want to be able to assess, describe and, if necessary, edit the scans later. The National Archives describes quality control and file management as part of digitisation and archiving, so agree the required output format with the archive manager.
Coordinator of a large scanning project
You need to weigh up the time needed to scan, check and organise the files against scanning in-house or outsourcing. The Consumers’ Association lists the amount of material, the quality required and the time available as factors in making that choice.
What should you look for when buying?
First, take stock of the formats you have, then choose the file types you need and test the entire process on a representative strip. This will also help you estimate how many volunteer hours the collection will require.
| Consideration |
What should you check? |
Which consumers is this important for? |
| Archive files |
Check the output formats for the exact model and make test scans. Decide how files will be linked to the originals and checked. |
I want to be able to assess and manage scans later, not just view them quickly. Around 33% of consumers give archive files top priority. |
| Film formats and holders |
Note the film types and image dimensions of representative strips. Then check the list of supported formats and which holders are included. |
I want to avoid finding that some of my mixed-format collection won’t fit in the scanner. Around 33% of consumers prioritise compatible formats and holders. |
| Throughput and volunteer time |
Test a representative strip and include loading, scanning, file checking and organising in your time estimate. The stated scan time is not the same as the total processing time. |
I need to match the scale of a scanning project to the volunteer time available. Around 20% of consumers give throughput top priority. |
| Total cost |
Compare the purchase price and your own time with a quote for outsourcing. Agree the file format and image-checking process in advance. |
I want to weigh up whether scanning in-house is practical, given other costs and the time available. Around 14% of consumers prioritise total cost. |
Common pitfalls
-
Mistaking an interpolated megapixel figure for sensor detail
The reflecta x66-Scan has a stated sensor resolution of 14 MP; the quoted 22 MP is interpolated. These figures therefore do not describe the same thing.
Compare test files from representative negatives for your intended use, rather than looking only at the highest stated output resolution.
If the test files aren’t suitable, rescanning could mean extra work.
-
Choosing a 35mm scanner without sorting your collection
The Plustek OpticFilm 8300i SE is designed for 35mm film; the other models mentioned support different formats. Having a suitable holder determines which strips you can scan.
First sort a representative part of your negatives, then check the formats and included holders for the exact model.
You may need a different holder, an additional scanner or an outsourcing service for originals that don’t fit.
-
Treating a quick JPEG copy as a finished archive
The National Archives describes digital archiving as selecting, organising and describing material; digitisation also involves quality control. A scan file alone doesn’t take care of these steps.
Before scanning, decide how you’ll organise the originals, file names, quality checks, and viewing and preservation files.
Organising and checking the files takes time in addition to scanning.
-
Assuming a discontinued model is readily available new
Epson marks the Perfection V600 Photo as discontinued on its Dutch product page. The product information therefore doesn’t prove that the model is currently available new.
For a specific unit, check its condition, whether all the holders are included and whether it’s compatible with the software you want to use.
With a used unit, finding suitable software or sourcing missing holders may take extra time.
Brands to compare
Plustek
The OpticFilm 8300i SE is a computer-connected film scanner for 35mm negatives and slides, designed for anyone who wants to manage scan settings and output on a computer.
- According to Plustek’s EU specifications: 7200 dpi hardware resolution, 24/48-bit colour output and an infrared channel.
- The scan area is for 35mm film and the workflow requires a computer. The stated specifications are not an independent assessment of image quality.
reflecta
The x66-Scan is a standalone option for certain collections of 135, 127 and 120 negatives.
- According to reflecta, JPEG files are saved directly to an SD card, and holders for 35mm and 120 film are included.
- The sensor is 14 MP; the stated 22 MP is interpolated. reflecta lists an optional holder for 126 film.
KODAK Photo Plus
The European SLIDE N SCAN is a standalone scanner with adapters for 135, 110 and 126 film.
- The product page lists a 14MP sensor, a screen and SD card storage.
- An SD card is required but not included. The listed formats don’t include 120 film, so check test files before choosing this workflow for archive masters.
Epson
The Perfection V600 Photo offers a flatbed option for 35mm and 120 film and prints, if you can find a suitable unit with the holders you need.
- Epson lists film holders and TIFF output for this model.
- Epson Netherlands marks the exact model as discontinued. If you find a unit, check the holders and software compatibility.
Products at Joybuy
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Does a community archive need permission to put photos of identifiable people online?
Publishing online and digitising negatives are two different activities. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, permission is required in most cases to publish online. Decide which legal basis and access arrangements apply to your collection.
Can the archive make family photos taken by someone else available to the public without permission?
Not simply because the archive owns the negatives. According to the Dutch Government, permission from the photographer is needed to use and publish someone else’s copyright-protected photos. Check the rights for the images in question before publishing them.
How should you handle negatives while scanning?
Touch the image area as little as possible and, where you can, handle the material by the edges or the holder. The Library of Congress recommends this approach to avoid contact with the image surface.
Do all scans for this community archive need to be TIFF files?
Not necessarily: the National Archives’ preferred file format standard is intended for government information and doesn’t automatically apply to a community archive. The National Archives lists TIFF as its preferred format; check with the archive manager which preservation and viewing files the collection needs.
How do you compare scanning in-house with outsourcing?
Compare the number of negatives and the volunteer time available with the service provider’s process and the agreed result. If you scan in-house, allow time for checking and organising too. For a used or discontinued model, check that the holders and required software are still usable.