Start by choosing based on film format and workflow: a computer-connected film scanner is a good fit for scanning 35 mm film and managing files on your workstation, while a standalone scanner with SD storage leaves the computer free while you scan. Medium-format film needs compatible holders; infrared dust correction is not a reliable solution for conventional silver-based black-and-white film. If the scanner will be shared, agree where files will be stored and who can view them.
Who is this choice relevant to?
Team with one scanning computer
You share a computer and want to avoid scan files ending up between users or projects. So think carefully about whether you want to control the scanner from the computer or scan independently, and agree where files will be stored and who can access them.
Manager of a mixed-format film archive
You also have roll film or formats other than 35 mm. Before buying, check which film formats and holders the exact model supports.
35 mm photographer who edits scans
You mainly scan black-and-white 35 mm film and want to manage settings and output on a computer. Bear in mind that infrared dust correction does not work reliably with conventional silver-based black-and-white film.
What should you look for when buying?
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important to? |
| Workflow on a shared workstation |
Check the connection and driver for the operating system in use, as well as the storage location, user permissions and transfer process from SD. |
If I share the computer with others, I want to know when it will be in use and where scans will be stored. Around 31% of consumers cite a shared workflow as their main reason for buying. |
| Film format and holder |
List your 135/35 mm, 110, 126, 127, 120 and any larger film formats; check that each model supports the relevant holder. |
If my archive contains different formats, I don’t want to end up with film that won’t fit in the scanner. For around 25% of consumers, format compatibility is the main reason for buying. |
| Output and editing |
Compare the sensor specification with any interpolated resolution, the output format and the software you’ll need. A stated resolution alone does not tell you how much detail the scanner actually captures. |
If I want to edit scans later, I look at the file format and the settings I can manage on the workstation. Around 25% of consumers choose mainly based on output and editing flexibility. |
| Dust and scratches |
Check how the software handles dust correction; take care to keep conventional silver-based black-and-white film free of dust. |
When scanning black-and-white film, I want to know in advance how to deal with dust and scratches without relying on an unsuitable infrared function. Dust control is the main reason for buying for around 19% of consumers. |
Common pitfalls
-
Assuming infrared correction works on all black-and-white film
According to LaserSoft Imaging, the silver-based emulsion in conventional black-and-white film blocks infrared light. As a result, standard infrared correction cannot solve the dust problem with this type of film.
Treat dust removal as a separate step and check which software-based correction options are available on the shared workstation.
Allow time for careful dust removal or editing.
-
Confusing interpolated pixel count with sensor resolution
Reflecta lists a 14 MP sensor for the x66-Scan, along with an interpolated 22 MP output mode. That higher output figure does not mean the sensor itself is 22 MP.
Compare the native sensor specification and output format, rather than looking only at the highest MP figure.
-
Choosing a 35 mm scanner for a mixed-format film archive
The Plustek OpticFilm 8200i SE is specified for 35 mm film; the reflecta x66-Scan also supports certain 120 formats. Support varies by model.
Make a list of your film formats and check the holder for the exact model. You may need a different scanning setup for film that isn’t supported.
A second suitable scanning setup could mean extra time and steps.
-
Treating an old product page as confirmation of current availability
Epson marks the Perfection V600 Photo and V850 Pro as discontinued and no longer available on its product pages.
Use these models as examples of the flatbed approach at most, and check the film holders, support and specification of any alternative.
Brands and models to consider
Plustek
The OpticFilm 8200i SE is a computer-connected option for 35 mm negatives and slides, including black-and-white film.
- Plustek gives the OpticFilm 8200i SE a stated optical resolution of 7200 dpi and includes SilverFast SE Plus.
- LaserSoft Imaging explains that infrared correction does not work as intended with conventional silver-based black-and-white film. Also check that the film holders suit your formats; 120 film is not listed for this model.
reflecta
The x66-Scan lets you scan independently to SD, while the RPS 10S is a computer-connected model for 35 mm film strips.
- According to reflecta, the x66-Scan saves JPEG files to SD and also supports 120 film. The RPS 10S has automatic feeding for 35 mm strips containing 3 to 40 frames.
- The x66-Scan’s 22 MP mode is interpolated from a 14 MP sensor. The RPS 10S’s infrared function does not solve the dust correction problem with conventional silver-based black-and-white film.
KODAK Photo Plus
The Slide N Scan RODFS50 is a standalone scanner for a range of formats, including 135, 110 and 126 black-and-white negatives.
- The EU product page lists a 14 MP sensor and SD storage.
- According to the product page, an SD card is required for use but is not included. The listed formats do not include 120 film.
Epson
The Perfection V600 Photo and V850 Pro illustrate the flatbed approach with film holders, including holders for medium format.
- For the V850 Pro, Epson lists formats including 35 mm, 120/220 and larger film. The V600 Photo is also listed as supporting 35 mm and 120/220.
- Epson marks both models as discontinued and no longer available. These specifications therefore do not confirm that the models are currently available to buy new.
Joybuy products
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Will infrared dust correction work on my black-and-white negatives?
Not with conventional silver-based black-and-white film: according to LaserSoft Imaging, the emulsion blocks infrared light. Software correction such as SRDx is a different technique; check which version is available on the workstation.
What should I arrange before several people use the same scanner?
Check the driver and software on the workstation’s operating system, and agree on a procedure for storing and transferring files. If an organisation processes scans that show identifiable people, those images are personal data. The Dutch Data Protection Authority states that organisations must protect personal data appropriately and manage access rights properly. Simply sharing a computer does not, in itself, mean that the GDPR applies to every private use.
Can I start straight away with a standalone scanner?
Not always. The EU product page for the KODAK Slide N Scan says an SD card is required but not included; the reflecta x66-Scan also saves files to SD. Check which card and film holders you need for the model you choose.