Which scanner is right for you?

35mm photographer who wants to edit scans

If you want to adjust and finish your black-and-white scans yourself before your portfolio review, check which file format and software are compatible with your computer. Plustek describes the OpticFilm 8200i SE as suitable for 35mm black-and-white film and lists SilverFast SE Plus as included.

Photographer with 35mm and 120 negatives

If you want to scan both film formats, compare the exact model’s stated format support and the holders included. reflecta says that the x66-Scan supports type 120 and 135 black-and-white film.

Photographer short on preparation time

If you want to select images without a computer first, or have lots of 35mm shots on strips, compare saving to an SD card with scanning using film-strip transport. Kodak Photo Plus describes the Slide N SCAN as offering a standalone workflow; reflecta describes strip transport for the RPS 10S.

What should you look for when choosing?

Computer-connected scanner for 35mm

Choose this option: if you only have 35mm film and scan settings and editing matter to you. Plustek lists support for black-and-white film and SilverFast SE Plus as included.

Bear in mind: the OpticFilm 8200i SE isn’t specified as a 120 scanner. Also check that the software is compatible with your computer.

Standalone scanning for 35mm and 120

Choose this option: if you have both formats and want to select images without a computer. reflecta lists JPEG storage on an SD card and holders for 35mm and 120 film for the x66-Scan.

Bear in mind: reflecta lists a 14 MP sensor and an interpolated 22 MP output mode. The latter figure does not represent a higher optical sensor resolution.

Standalone scanner for smaller film formats

Choose this option: if you want to transfer black-and-white negatives in 135, 110 or 126 format to an SD card quickly. Kodak Photo Plus’s European product page lists a built-in screen.

Bear in mind: 120 film isn’t on the listed format list, and the manufacturer says an SD card is required but not included.

Computer-connected scanner with film-strip transport

Choose this option: if you have lots of 35mm shots on strips and automatic transport matters to you. reflecta lists support for strips with 3 to 40 frames and DNG output for the RPS 10S.

Bear in mind: the RPS 10S isn’t specified as a 120 scanner and requires a computer-connected workflow.

What to consider What to look for Who is it for?
Adjustable final scan Check the exact model’s film format, scan settings, software compatibility and output file. If you want to adjust and edit scans carefully before your review, control over the final scan should be your top priority. Around 36% of consumers making this choice put this first.
Both 35mm and 120 film Compare the list of supported formats and check that the right film holders are included. If you want to scan negatives in both formats, the scanner must explicitly support both. Around 29% of consumers prioritise this combination.
Selecting images without a computer Check the output format, supported film formats, screen and required SD card storage. If you want to select images on your own first, a computer-free workflow may matter more than extensive settings. Around 21% of consumers prioritise this way of working.
Processing lots of 35mm shots Check whether your film strips are compatible, how many frames the model transports and which software you’ll need. If you want to scan a batch of 35mm shots before your review, strip transport may suit the way you work. Remember to allow time to check the scans too. Around 14% of consumers prioritise this processing volume.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming infrared correction works on all black-and-white film

    Infrared correction won’t remove dust and scratches from traditional silver-based black-and-white film. LaserSoft Imaging explains that the silver-based emulsion reflects infrared light.

    So don’t base your choice on an infrared feature alone. Set aside time to check your selected scans for dust and scratches.

    Allow time to clean negatives, check scans and edit them if necessary.

  • Choosing a 35mm scanner when you also have 120 negatives

    The scanners listed support different film formats. A model specified for 35mm isn’t automatically suitable for 120 film.

    Make a note of your formats and compare them with the exact model’s list of supported formats and holders.

    You may need a different scanning option for negatives that aren’t supported by your chosen scanner.

  • Mistaking an interpolated megapixel figure for sensor resolution

    reflecta lists a 14 MP sensor and an interpolated 22 MP output mode for the x66-Scan. These figures don’t describe the same thing.

    Compare the sensor and output figures separately, and check that the file will suit your intended portfolio.

  • Assuming a standalone scanner is ready to use straight away

    Kodak Photo Plus’s European product page says the Slide N SCAN requires an SD card, which isn’t included.

    Before buying, check what storage and accessories you’ll need and what’s included in the box.

    You’ll need a suitable SD card if one isn’t included.

Relevant film scanner brands

Plustek

The OpticFilm 8200i SE is a computer-connected option for 35mm negatives and slides.

  • Plustek lists support for black-and-white film and SilverFast SE Plus as included; these are the manufacturer’s specifications.
  • The model isn’t specified as a 120 scanner. Infrared correction won’t help with traditional silver-based black-and-white film.

reflecta

The x66-Scan is a standalone option for 35mm and 120 film, among other formats; the RPS 10S is a computer-connected option for 35mm film strips.

  • According to reflecta, the x66-Scan supports black-and-white film and saves JPEGs to an SD card. reflecta lists strip transport and DNG output for the RPS 10S.
  • The x66-Scan’s listed 22 MP is interpolated from a 14 MP sensor. The RPS 10S isn’t specified as a 120 scanner; claims about quality and speed aren’t independent test results.

Kodak Photo Plus

The European Slide N SCAN product page describes a standalone scanner for black-and-white negatives in 135, 110 and 126 formats.

  • A built-in screen and SD card storage are useful if you want to select images on your own.
  • The manufacturer says an SD card is required but not included. 120 film isn’t on the listed format list.

Joybuy products for this topic

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

Does automatic infrared dust removal work on my black-and-white negatives?

Not with traditional silver-based black-and-white film: software developer LaserSoft Imaging says that the emulsion reflects infrared light. So check your scans for dust and scratches, and find out what software correction is available with your setup.

What should I have ready before scanning without a computer?

First, check that the included holders fit your film. Kodak Photo Plus’s European product page says the Slide N SCAN requires an SD card, which isn’t included. reflecta lists holders for 35mm and 120 film for the x66-Scan.

How can I stop dust from delaying my portfolio images?

Allow time to check your negatives and scans before your review. Infrared correction isn’t a solution for traditional silver-based black-and-white film. LaserSoft Imaging describes SRDx as software correction that’s also designed for black-and-white film; check the results on the scan itself.

Which purchase terms and rights should I check?

Check whether the storage and software you need are included with the exact package; the SD card isn’t included with the Kodak Photo Plus scanner mentioned here. According to the Dutch government, consumers in the Netherlands who buy online from a business have a 14-day cooling-off period in many cases. Consumers also have a legal guarantee, according to ACM ConsuWijzer, if a product doesn’t meet reasonable expectations during normal use. This doesn’t mean there’s a fixed guarantee period for every film scanner.

Can I publish someone else’s scanned photos in my portfolio?

Not just because you can scan the negative. According to the Dutch government, you can generally only use someone else’s copyright-protected photos with the creator’s permission. You can’t distribute or make a private copy available to the public; this isn’t an extra scanner requirement for your own photos.