Players with limited desk space
If you don’t want a large arcade cabinet between your keyboard and screen, you could compare a handheld fightpad with a flat or compact controller.
If you’re short on desk space and prefer holding a controller, a fightpad is a natural option to compare. If you want a physical joystick, consider a compact stick. A leverless controller replaces the joystick with directional buttons, so it requires a different way of playing. Always check the dimensions, the full model name and compatibility with your platform: products with similar names aren’t always interchangeable.
If you don’t want a large arcade cabinet between your keyboard and screen, you could compare a handheld fightpad with a flat or compact controller.
If you use more than one system, it’s important to check platform compatibility for the exact version. Similar product names can refer to different versions.
If you want to try directional buttons or prefer to keep a physical arcade joystick, weigh up that control style against the space you have available.
First choose the control style you find comfortable, then check the size and platform compatibility against your own setup.
Best for: playing with a controller in your hands, without putting a casing on your desk.
Trade-off: you don’t get the joystick-and-button layout of an arcade stick. According to HORI, the wired HORI Fighting Commander OCTA has six front action buttons and an adjustable D-pad.
Best for: players who value a physical joystick and have a dedicated spot on their desk.
Trade-off: even a mini stick takes up space for the casing, your hands and the cable. HORI gives the Fighting Stick Mini’s dimensions as approximately 8 × 6 inches, or around 20,3 × 15,2 cm.
Best for: players who want to use directional buttons instead of a joystick.
Trade-off: the button layout calls for a different way of playing. Razer lists the Kitsune for PS5 and PC; 8BitDo lists the Arcade Controller reviewed here for Switch and Windows, not PS5.
| What to consider | What should you check? | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Available desk space | Compare the width and depth with the space available, and leave room for your hands, joystick movement and cable. | If my desk is already full, I want to know how much space the controller takes up while I’m playing. Around 36% of consumers give free workspace top priority. |
| Platform compatibility | Check the full model name, the list of supported platforms and the required connection mode. | I want to be sure the version I choose works with my system, not just that the product name sounds familiar. Around 29% of consumers prioritise platform compatibility. |
| Directional buttons | Look at the button layout and check whether the exact version supports your platform. | If I’d rather input directions using buttons than a joystick, I want to know which layout I’ll get before buying. Around 21% of consumers give this input style top priority. |
| Physical joystick | Check both the footprint and the extra space needed to move the joystick. | I want to keep using a physical arcade joystick, but I’ll need enough space to do so. Around 14% of consumers prioritise joystick controls. |
These are different versions, each with its own connection and platform requirements. According to HORI, the wireless OCTA Pro only works on PS4 when wired.
Compare the full model name and check the platform and connection requirements for the version you want to buy.
A controller’s stated dimensions don’t tell you how much space your hands, a joystick and a connected cable will take up during use.
Measure the available space on your desk and compare it with the dimensions of the exact model. Also allow room for operating and connecting it.
MAYFLASH states that the F300’s PS5 support requires firmware V1.28 and a MagicBoots-S5 adapter.
Before buying, check which firmware and adapter are required for the setup you want to use.
A separate adapter may be needed for the PS5 setup described.
The product ranges reviewed include a handheld fightpad and a compact stick for PS5, PS4 and Windows. The OCTA Pro is a separate wireless version.
The Kitsune reviewed is a leverless controller that Razer lists for PS5 and PC.
According to 8BitDo, the flat Arcade Controller reviewed is designed for Windows and Switch. A separate Xbox version is also available.
The F300 is a customisable arcade stick for anyone who wants a physical joystick and has enough desk space.
These Joybuy products include controllers for different platforms. Check each model to make sure its controls and platform compatibility suit your fighting game and setup.
No image available
A wireless controller for Nintendo Switch; check whether its controls suit the fighting game you play.
The product name lists Bluetooth, TMR sticks, 40-hour battery life, four RGB modes and two programmable buttons.
No image available
A fightpad version for anyone looking for a handheld controller; check the connection mode for the system you play on.
The product name lists wireless use for PS5 and PC. According to HORI, this OCTA Pro only works on PS4 when wired.
No image available
A set of controllers for Nintendo Switch systems; check the button layout and suitability for your fighting game.
The product name lists compatibility with Nintendo Switch 2, 8-hour battery life and vibration.
No image available
A wireless controller for PS5; check whether its controls suit the way you play fighting games.
The product information lists haptic feedback, adaptive triggers and USB-C.
No image available
A mobile controller; check that the device you want to play on is included in the stated compatibility list.
The product name lists Switch, iOS, Android, tablet and PC. The product description mentions an extendable design and adjustable phone holder.
No. Check the full version name and the list of supported platforms. HORI lists PS5, PS4 and Windows for the wired OCTA; according to HORI, the wireless OCTA Pro only works on PS4 when wired. For the Arcade Controller reviewed, 8BitDo lists Windows and Switch.
Measure the available width and depth, and leave extra room for your hands, the joystick and the cable. HORI lists the Fighting Stick Mini at approximately 8 × 6 inches, or around 20,3 × 15,2 cm; you may need more room while playing.
MAYFLASH describes PS5 support for the F300 with firmware V1.28 and a MagicBoots-S5 adapter. Check that combination before buying, and don’t assume it’s compatible directly without an adapter.
According to ACM ConsuWijzer, online consumer purchases generally come with a statutory cooling-off period of up to 14 days after delivery, subject to exceptions. You’re also entitled to a statutory guarantee if, under normal use, the product doesn’t meet what you could reasonably expect; the retailer is your point of contact.