Which controller is right for you?

Player with a crowded desk

Wants to play fighting games without placing a large controller beside their keyboard and mouse, so is comparing a handheld pad with a compact stick.

Player looking to change control style

Wants to choose between a physical arcade joystick and separate directional buttons, and is prepared to get used to a new layout.

Player using multiple systems

For example, uses a PC and a console, or switches between consoles. It’s important to check the exact platform version and connection mode.

What should you look for?

First choose the control layout you want to use. Then check platform and game support, the space available and the connection.

Handheld fight pad

A good fit if: you’d rather hold the controller or keep your desk clear.

Trade-off: it doesn’t have the joystick-and-button layout of an arcade stick.

Arcade stick

A good fit if: you want to use a physical joystick and separate action buttons.

Trade-off: you’ll need space for the casing, your hands and the cable.

Leverless controller

A good fit if: you want to enter movement using separate directional buttons instead of a joystick.

Trade-off: the different layout takes some getting used to. If necessary, check the SOCD mode selected and the rules of any event you’re entering.

What to consider What to look for Who this matters to
Control style Compare a D-pad, joystick or four directional buttons, as well as the position of the action buttons. If I want to know which layout suits the way I play, I compare the controls themselves; the preferred control style is the main consideration for around 28% of consumers.
Platform and game Check the full model name, the platform mode and whether your game is supported. If I play on PC or console, I want to know in advance that both the controller and the game will work; platform compatibility is the main consideration for around 22% of consumers.
Desk space Measure the available space and allow for your hands and the cable. If my keyboard and mouse are also on my desk, I consider how much room the controller takes up; available space is the main consideration for around 22% of consumers.
Connection Check which cable or receiver is included and which mode works with your platform. If I don’t want a cable across my desk, I check whether the wireless mode is suitable for my system; connection type is the main consideration for around 17% of consumers.
Purchase and aftercare Check what’s included and who the seller is. If I want to be able to customise parts or need help after buying, I check what’s included and who the seller is; purchase and aftercare are the main consideration for around 11% of consumers.

Avoiding common buying mistakes

  • Confusing product versions with the same range name

    The standard 8BitDo Arcade Stick and the Arcade Stick for Xbox have different platform support.

    Before buying, compare the full model name and the manufacturer’s compatibility information with your system.

  • Buying a compact stick without measuring your playing space

    According to HORI, the HORI Fighting Stick Mini has a casing measuring around 8 × 6 inches; your hands and the cable need space too.

    Measure the space available and consider whether you’d rather hold the controller.

  • Assuming a leverless controller guarantees better performance

    The Razer Kitsune uses directional buttons instead of a joystick. Razer’s claim that it reduces input errors is no guarantee of better performance in games.

    Choose the input style you want to learn to use and, if necessary, check the SOCD setting for your needs.

  • Confusing a commercial warranty with all your consumer rights

    For online purchases, statutory consumer rights and how the seller handles issues can be separate matters.

    Keep your proof of purchase and check who is listed as the seller and who handles returns and faults.

Brands to compare

HORI

Compare the handheld Fighting Commander OCTA, wireless OCTA Pro and compact Fighting Stick Mini by their exact versions.

  • According to HORI, the wired OCTA has six front-facing action buttons. The Fighting Stick Mini has a physical joystick and a casing measuring around 8 × 6 inches.
  • According to HORI, the wireless OCTA Pro must be used in wired mode on PS4. These features don’t automatically apply to all HORI controllers.

Nacon

The PlayStation version of the Daija is a wired arcade stick for anyone looking for customisable parts for PS5, PS4 or PC.

  • Nacon specifies interchangeable joystick heads and configurable buttons.
  • According to Nacon’s support information, PC use requires the correct platform mode and an XInput-compatible game. Analogue triggers and vibration aren’t available.

Razer

The Kitsune is a leverless option for PS5 and PC, designed for players who want to use separate directional buttons.

  • Razer specifies a detachable USB-C cable and adjustable SOCD modes.
  • Razer’s claim that it reduces input errors isn’t an independent guarantee of better performance in games.

8BitDo

The Arcade Stick for Xbox is designed for an Xbox or Windows set-up; don’t confuse this version with the standard Arcade Stick.

  • According to 8BitDo, the Xbox version supports 2.4 GHz and wired USB-C.
  • 8BitDo excludes PS4, PS5 and Xbox from support for the standard Arcade Stick, so don’t confuse the versions based on the range name alone.

Qanba

The Drone 2 is an arcade stick to compare for PS5, PS4 and PC.

  • Qanba specifies a platform switch and 30mm buttons for the Drone 2.
  • These product specifications don’t prove a performance advantage over other sticks.

Joybuy product picks

The products below are handheld controllers for PS5 and PC set-ups, and for Switch and Switch 2 set-ups.

HORI Wireless Fighting Commander OCTA Pro for PS5 and PC, black

HORI Wireless Fighting Commander OCTA Pro (PS5/PC)

A handheld controller for a PS5 or PC set-up. According to HORI, this OCTA Pro must be used in wired mode on PS4.

Joybuy
HORI Wired Controller HORIPAD Turbo, Pokemon Eevee Cottage Core Edition for Switch and Switch 2

HORI Wired Controller HORIPAD Turbo, Pokemon Eevee Cottage Core Edition (Switch/Switch 2)

A wired option for a Switch or Switch 2 set-up. The product information says that a USB cable isn’t included, so check whether you already have one.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does every controller for fighting games work on PS5?

No, support varies by version. According to 8BitDo, the standard Arcade Stick doesn’t support PS5, while Razer specifies the Kitsune for PS5 and PC. Check that your game supports the controller too.

How do you connect the PlayStation version of the Nacon Daija to a PC?

According to Nacon, set the platform switch to PC and connect the cable. Nacon specifies support for XInput-compatible PC games; this doesn’t mean that other input protocols are supported.

Can the HORI Wireless Fighting Commander OCTA Pro be used wirelessly on PS4?

No. HORI specifies wired mode for PS4; the manufacturer lists wireless support for PS5 and Windows 11/10.

What are your rights when you buy a controller online in the Netherlands?

For online purchases from a business, the Dutch government says you’ll often have a 14-day cooling-off period. The seller must provide information about the purchase and the cooling-off period, so check who the seller is and who handles returns. A manufacturer’s warranty doesn’t replace your statutory rights if a product is faulty.