Which controller is right for you?

Player sharing a room with someone who’s resting

Your main concern is avoiding disturbing the other person with button presses, movement or in-game sound. QANBA describes its individual Gravity KS buttons as noise-dampening, but that doesn’t tell us how quiet a complete controller is in a bedroom.

Player with limited bedroom space

You want a controller that’s easy to put away after playing. 8BitDo describes its Arcade Controller as slim and compact; the M30 is a handheld controller.

Player who wants to choose the input layout

You’re deciding between a fight pad with six action buttons, a leverless controller with buttons for movement directions, and a joystick. HORI, 8BitDo and QANBA describe models with these different layouts.

What should you look for when choosing?

The percentages give a broad indication of the main purchase concern for consumers sharing a bedroom; each row represents one primary concern.

Concern What to look for Who is this most relevant to?
Noise for the other person Consider the buttons, contact with the surface you play on and in-game sound; if possible, try the complete setup. If someone is resting next to you, you’ll want to know whether your gaming will disturb them. Around 33% of consumers say noise is their main concern.
Platform compatibility Check the full model name and the stated compatibility with your console or PC. If you play on a specific console or PC, you’ll want to check in advance that the exact model variant works with it. Around 27% of consumers prioritise platform compatibility.
Button layout Choose between a handheld controller, movement buttons or a joystick. If possible, try the layout with a game you play. If the way you input directions and action commands matters most, you’ll want a layout that suits your playing style. This is the main concern for around 20% of consumers.
Space and storage Measure the available space and take the controller and cable route into account. If space is limited, you’ll want room for the controller while you play and an easy way to put it away afterwards. Space is the main concern for around 20% of consumers.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming quiet switches guarantee a quiet bedroom

    A claim about individual buttons doesn’t tell you how loud the complete controller is; the joystick, the surface you play on and in-game sound all matter too.

    Check whether replacement buttons are compatible with your controller and, if possible, assess the complete setup where you play.

    Replacement buttons can add to the cost, so check their fit and installation requirements first.

  • Choosing a controller by its shape rather than its platform compatibility

    Models with similar all-button layouts may be intended for different platforms. Razer lists the Kitsune for PS5 and PC; 8BitDo lists Switch and Windows for the standard Arcade Controller.

    Before ordering, check the full model name and stated platform compatibility.

  • Confusing an extended warranty with your legal rights

    A commercial warranty doesn’t replace your legal rights if a product doesn’t meet the standard you’re entitled to expect.

    Check what an extended warranty covers, and keep your purchase details in case you need to contact the seller.

Brands to compare

HORI

The Fighting Commander OCTA Pro is a fight pad for PS5 and Windows.

  • HORI lists six action buttons, microswitches and programmable rear buttons for this model.
  • These specifications aren’t an independent assessment of noise or gaming performance.

8BitDo

The range includes the M30 Bluetooth handheld controller and the flat Arcade Controller.

  • 8BitDo lists Switch and Windows compatibility for the models mentioned; the M30 has six action buttons, while the Arcade Controller has an all-button layout.
  • The standard Arcade Controller and the M30 version mentioned aren’t listed as direct PS5 controllers. Check the exact variant.

Razer

Razer lists the Kitsune as a leverless controller for PS5 and PC.

  • Razer highlights its slim design and optical switches.
  • These features alone don’t provide a comparative measure of noise levels or gaming performance.

QANBA

The Drone 2 has a joystick layout and is listed as compatible with PS5, PS4 and PC.

  • QANBA also sells individual Gravity KS buttons; the manufacturer says they include components designed to reduce button noise.
  • This isn’t a noise measurement of a complete, unmodified Drone 2, nor does it confirm that the individual buttons fit that controller.

PlayStation

PlayStation describes the FlexStrike as a fightstick for PS5 and PC, with wired and wireless PlayStation Link connections.

  • PlayStation lists interchangeable restrictor gates and a non-slip base.
  • The stated features don’t provide a comparative noise measurement for bedroom use.

Joybuy product selection

This selection focuses on a fight pad for fighting games, with a six-button layout and compatibility with PS5 or PC.

HORI Wireless Controller Fighting Commander OCTA Pro for PS5/PC - Black

HORI Fighting Commander OCTA Pro Wireless Controller for PS5/PC - Black

A fight pad for players who want to use a handheld controller with six action buttons for fighting games.

The product description lists six microswitch buttons, an analogue stick and three interchangeable D-pad options. It also mentions wireless use, a wired USB-C connection and programmable rear buttons. HORI lists the OCTA Pro as compatible with PS5 and Windows 11/10.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is a leverless controller quieter than an arcade stick?

You can’t tell from the product specifications listed. QANBA describes its individual Gravity KS buttons as noise-dampening, but without comparable measurements of complete controllers, there’s no evidence-based overall winner. If possible, try the controller where you play.

Can I use any controller with my PS5?

No. Check compatibility for the exact model. Razer lists the Kitsune for PS5 and PC, while QANBA lists the Drone 2 for PS5, PS4 and PC. For the standard Arcade Controller, 8BitDo lists Switch and Windows, but not PS5.

What should I consider when connecting and maintaining my controller?

Check the stated connection type and allow for cable routing or charging. If you’re replacing switches or buttons, follow the instructions for the exact model and check that replacement parts are compatible before buying.

Do I need an extended warranty for legal protection?

An extended warranty doesn’t replace your legal guarantee. ACM ConsuWijzer explains that you’re legally protected if, under normal use, a product doesn’t do what you’re entitled to expect; the seller is then responsible for providing an appropriate solution.

Can I return a controller bought online?

For most distance purchases made online from a business, the Dutch Government says you have a 14-day cooling-off period; check the applicable terms and exceptions. This is separate from your legal rights if the product is faulty.