Which type of controller is right for you?

Players who want to hold a controller on the sofa

A fightpad is worth considering if you don’t want to set up an arcade stick. Check that the model works with your console or PC, and think about how any cable will reach your seat.

Players looking for arcade-style controls

Compare a stick with a lever and a controller with separate directional buttons. Each layout calls for different movements, so decide which controls you want to use and how much space you have for them.

Players who use more than one system

Check whether the exact model and version work with the console or PC you have in mind. Look out for any receiver, converter or firmware requirements too; similar model names don’t automatically mean the same systems are supported.

What should you look for when choosing?

What to consider What to check before buying Who is this important for?
Compatibility Compare the full model name with the list of supported platforms, and check whether you need a receiver, converter or firmware. I want to be sure the controller works with my console or PC before choosing a version. Around 29% of consumers say compatibility is their top consideration.
Handheld controls Compare the directional controls and button layout with what feels comfortable to you. For a wired controller, check the cable route. If I want to hold a controller on the sofa instead of using an arcade stick, handheld controls matter most. Around 24% of consumers give this priority.
Lever or directional buttons First choose between a physical joystick and separate directional buttons, then check whether your system is supported. I want to choose how I enter directions: with a lever or separate buttons. Around 18% of consumers put this layout first.
Space and cable route Allow room for your hands and the controller, and consider how far it needs to reach your system if it’s wired. If I play on the sofa, I want to know whether the controller and cable will suit my seating area. Around 17% of consumers say their setup is the most important factor.
Connection Check which receiver is included, the available connection, how the controller charges and whether the exact version can be used with a cable. I want a connection that suits the distance to my system, but first I need to check that my platform is supported. Around 12% of consumers prioritise the connection type.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming platform support based on the product range

    Different versions with similar names may support different platforms. For example, 8BitDo lists support for Switch and Windows for its standard Arcade Stick, but not for PS5 or Xbox. The separate Xbox version has a different list of supported platforms.

    Before buying, compare the full model name and the platform list for the exact version you’re choosing.

  • Blaming all lag on the controller

    Your TV settings can play a part too. Samsung describes a game mode for supported TVs, but notes that support and performance can vary between consoles.

    Before replacing your controller because you suspect lag, check whether your TV has a game mode and whether it’s enabled for the input you’re using.

  • Choosing a wired controller without considering where you sit

    You need to be able to connect a wired fightpad, stick or button-only controller from your usual playing position. An arcade stick also needs a suitable place on your lap or on a surface.

    Check the cable route in advance, as well as where the controller and your hands will be while you play.

  • Assuming a button-only controller will automatically improve your game

    Manufacturers’ claims about fast or error-free inputs aren’t proof that every player will benefit.

    Choose based on the layout you want to use and whether your platform is supported, not on a promise of better performance.

Brands to compare

HORI

HORI offers handheld controllers and arcade sticks, among other products. The PlayStation versions mentioned here don’t prove that versions with similar names for other platforms offer the same support.

  • HORI lists six action buttons and an adjustable D-pad for the wired Fighting Commander OCTA SPF-023U.
  • According to HORI, the Fighting Stick α can be opened for maintenance. For both models, check that you have enough space and a suitable cable route for your setup.

8BitDo

8BitDo offers arcade sticks with different platform support, as well as a button-only controller for Xbox.

  • According to 8BitDo, the Arcade Stick for Xbox connects to Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows via 2.4 GHz or cable.
  • The standard Arcade Stick doesn’t support PS5 or Xbox, according to the FAQ. The Arcade Controller for Xbox has a different layout from a stick with a lever.

Razer

Razer describes the Kitsune as a wired button-only controller for PS5 and PC.

  • Razer lists four directional buttons, optical switches and a detachable USB-C cable.
  • Razer’s claims about reducing input errors don’t demonstrate an advantage for every player. Xbox support isn’t included on the platform list provided.

Turtle Beach / Victrix

The European product page describes the Victrix Pro KO as a customisable button-only controller, with separate PlayStation and Xbox versions.

  • For the PlayStation version, Turtle Beach lists up to 16 remappable buttons, interchangeable switches and a 3 m USB-C cable.
  • Before buying, check which platform version you’re selecting. Claims about speed and comfort are made by the manufacturer.

MAYFLASH

The F500 FLAT is a button-only controller. According to MAYFLASH, using it with PS5 depends on having a suitable converter and meeting firmware requirements.

  • MAYFLASH lists the MagicBoots-S5 for the F500 FLAT.
  • Check whether you need the converter and whether compatible devices require the latest firmware.

Controllers at Joybuy

These Joybuy picks are handheld controllers for players who want to play fighting games from the sofa. Check the listed systems, connection and included accessories for each model.

Hori wireless Fighting Commander Octa Pro controller for PS5/PC - black

Hori Fighting Commander OCTA Pro for PS5/PC - black

A handheld controller for fighting games; the product information lists support for PS5 and PC.

The product information lists six action buttons, an analogue stick with an 8-gate layout, three interchangeable D-pad options and programmable rear buttons. Both wireless and wired use are listed. Install the latest firmware before first use.

Joybuy
Hori wired Horipad Turbo controller for Switch and Switch 2 - Pokémon Eevee Cottage Core Edition

Hori Horipad Turbo for Switch and Switch 2 - Pokémon Eevee Cottage Core Edition

A wired handheld controller for players using the listed Switch systems.

The product information lists analogue joysticks, programmable rear buttons and a turbo function. The USB cable isn’t included.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does the controller need to be compatible with my TV?

The main thing is to check that the controller works with the console or PC you play on; your TV displays the picture from that system. Check the platform list for the exact controller version, as a big screen doesn’t make controllers for different consoles interchangeable.

What can I change on my TV if a game feels sluggish?

Check whether your TV has a game mode and whether it’s enabled for the input you’re using. Samsung describes a game mode for supported TVs, but also notes that support and performance can vary between consoles. This doesn’t establish how your TV and controller will perform together.

Do I need extra equipment to use the MAYFLASH F500 FLAT with PS5?

According to MAYFLASH, the F500 FLAT works with the MagicBoots-S5 converter. Check the firmware on compatible devices too. Allow for this converter and any setup needed for this specific combination; other controllers won’t necessarily need them.

What if a controller I’ve bought online isn’t right for me or develops a fault?

When you buy online from a business, you’ll often have a 14-day cooling-off period, according to the Dutch Government. Check which terms apply to your purchase. If a product develops a fault sooner than you could reasonably expect with normal use, you have statutory warranty rights against the seller, as explained by ACM ConsuWijzer. The cooling-off period and warranty are separate rights.