Who is this choice relevant to?

Player bothered by screen reflections

Plays during the day and wants to work out first whether the problem is screen visibility or the controls. RTINGS notes that room lighting and reflections affect how clearly you can see what’s on screen.

Player using a dedicated console

Wants a controller that works with their PS5, Xbox, Switch or PC and chosen game, so checks the full model name and version.

Player considering a different control method

Compares a physical joystick with separate directional buttons, while taking hand space and the room needed for the controller into account.

What should you look for when buying?

Fight stick with joystick

Best for: players who want to enter directions and diagonals using a physical joystick.

Bear in mind: the joystick, casing and cable all take up space; this control method won’t feel more comfortable to every player.

Leverless arcade controller

Best for: players who prefer to enter directions using separate buttons.

Bear in mind: the button layout differs from a joystick and may take some getting used to.

What to consider What to look for Who is this important to?
Seeing the game in daylight Look at the screen from your usual playing position when the room is bright; check for reflections from windows and lights. If I play during the day and reflections make the picture hard to read, I want to improve visibility before switching controllers. Around 25% of consumers consider visibility the most important factor.
Compatibility with your platform Compare the full model name, version, system and game; also check which connection is required. If I want to play on my own console or PC, I want to be sure that the exact version works with my system and game. Around 25% of consumers give platform compatibility top priority.
Joystick or directional buttons Consider whether you want to enter movements with a joystick or separate buttons, and think about how you’ll hold your hands. If I’m mainly deciding between a joystick and separate directional buttons, I want to choose based on the movements I want to make. Around 20% of consumers prioritise the input method.
Positioning and connection Compare the space available and cable route with the casing and connection method of the exact version. If I use the controller on my desk or lap, I want to know there’s enough room and that the cable will reach my playing position. Around 15% of consumers focus mainly on positioning and connection.
Maintenance and customisation Check which switches, buttons and other parts can be replaced on each model. If I want to be able to replace parts or customise the controller, I want to know what options the version I choose actually offers. Around 15% of consumers prioritise maintenance and customisation.

Common buying pitfalls

  • Buying a controller to fix screen reflections

    Direct light and reflections affect how clearly you can see the screen, regardless of which controller you choose.

    Check the picture from your usual playing position in daylight, and look at where the screen and light sources are positioned before choosing a different input method.

  • Assuming the same model name means the same console version

    Product families such as NACON Daija, HORI Fighting Stick α and Victrix Pro KO have separate platform versions.

    Before buying, check the full model name and the platform version you’ve selected.

  • Assuming programmable macros are allowed at a tournament

    Rules can vary from event to event. The Evo rules consulted prohibit hardware-programmable inputs and macros, but allow macros from the game’s input menu.

    Before entering, check the rules for the specific event and the controller functions you have set up.

  • Assuming the manufacturer’s warranty covers all your legal rights

    According to ACM ConsuWijzer, your statutory rights are separate from any manufacturer’s warranty.

    Keep your proof of purchase. If a product doesn’t perform as you could reasonably expect under normal use, contact the retailer.

Brands to compare

NACON

The Daija PlayStation version reviewed is a wired fight stick for PS5, PS4 and PC.

  • According to NACON, this version has SANWA parts, a detachable cable and customisation options.
  • The Xbox version is a separate product; the Daija name alone doesn’t confirm compatibility with both Xbox and PlayStation.

HORI

The Fighting Stick α is available in separate PlayStation and Xbox versions for players who want a joystick.

  • According to the product information, the PlayStation version described has a HAYABUSA joystick, a tournament lock and a casing that opens for maintenance.
  • Check which platform version you’re selecting; the same product family name doesn’t mean the versions are compatible with the same consoles.

Razer

The Kitsune reviewed is a slim, flat leverless controller for PS5 and PC.

  • Razer lists optical switches, a detachable USB-C cable, a cable lock and adjustable lighting.
  • Xbox or Switch compatibility hasn’t been confirmed for this version. Claims about improved input aren’t proof of an advantage for every player.

8BitDo

The Arcade Controller reviewed is a leverless model for Windows and Switch; the Arcade Stick for Xbox is a separate stick version for Xbox and Windows.

  • According to 8BitDo, the Arcade Controller has replaceable switches and wired or supported wireless connections.
  • The Xbox stick has a different layout and connection. Don’t assume either product name means it works with PS5.

Turtle Beach / Victrix

The PlayStation version of the Victrix Pro KO reviewed is a customisable leverless controller for PS5, PS4 and Windows.

  • The manufacturer lists repositionable buttons, hot-swappable switches and a wired USB-C connection.
  • There’s also a separate Xbox version, so check which one you’ve selected. Lighting and customisation options aren’t proof of better gaming performance.

MAYFLASH

The F700 FLAT Elite is a leverless model which the manufacturer says supports PS5, Xbox, Switch and Windows, among other platforms.

  • MAYFLASH lists wired, Bluetooth and 2.4GHz connections, a non-slip base and adjustable SOCD modes.
  • The manufacturer limits the stated PS5 use to fighting games and warns against using it for other types of PS5 games. Don’t assume this compatibility also applies to the separate F700X.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Will an arcade controller make a reflective gaming screen easier to see?

No. If light makes the screen hard to read, look at reflections and where the screen and light sources are positioned. This is separate from choosing between a fight stick and a leverless controller.

Can I use any PS4 arcade controller with a PS5 fighting game?

Don’t assume so. PlayStation Support says officially licensed specialist peripherals, such as arcade sticks, are supported with PS5 games and supported PS4 games. Also check the exact controller version and the game.

Can I use macros at a fighting game tournament?

It depends on the event. The Evo rules consulted prohibit hardware-programmable inputs and macros, but allow macros available through the game’s input menu. Check the rules for the tournament you’re entering.

What are my rights when buying online in the Netherlands?

According to ACM ConsuWijzer, when you buy a product online you generally have up to 14 days from delivery to change your mind, subject to legal exceptions. Your statutory rights are separate from any manufacturer’s warranty. If a product doesn’t perform as you could reasonably expect under normal use, contact the retailer.