Who is this buying guide for?

Players who switch between devices

If you play on different devices, you’ll want to check that both the controller and your chosen farming game work with each platform. For example, ConcernedApe’s FAQ confirms controller support for specific platforms and Xbox controllers on PC.

Players with limited desk space

A compact controller is easier to compare with the space you have available for storage. Remember to allow room for a cable or USB receiver too; connection options vary by model and platform.

Switch players at a desk

If you play on a Nintendo Switch, you can compare a wireless Pro Controller with a wired option. For wired models, check whether they can be used with the dock and whether any features are missing.

What should you look for when buying?

Start by checking that your game and device support the controller. Then compare its size and connection method with the space and ports available on your desk.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Game and platform compatibility Check whether your version of the game supports controllers and whether the controller works with your device using your chosen connection method. If I switch between devices, I want to know first whether the game and controller work together. Around 36% of consumers rank compatibility as their top priority.
Space for the controller and connection Compare the stated dimensions with your available storage space and check where a cable or USB receiver will go. At a small desk, I want to be able to put my things away easily and avoid awkward cable routing. Around 29% of consumers prioritise saving space.
Button layout Check whether the game supports the inputs you want and whether the model’s extra buttons can be customised. If I often use menus and repeat certain actions, I want a button layout that suits my preferences. Around 21% of consumers put controls first.
Power and use Check whether the exact model uses batteries, a rechargeable battery or a cable, and what’s included in the box. I want to know in advance whether I’ll need to charge it or replace the batteries, and whether I’ll need anything extra. Around 14% of consumers say power and additional requirements are their main concern.

Connection options vary by model. For example, 8BitDo lists Bluetooth for the Ultimate 2C Wireless on Android, and 2.4 GHz or wired use on Windows. Don’t assume Bluetooth works on every platform.

How to avoid common buying mistakes

  • Bluetooth doesn’t automatically mean Bluetooth on every platform

    For the 8BitDo Ultimate 2C Wireless, 8BitDo lists Bluetooth on Android and 2.4 GHz or wired use on Windows. You may need a different connection method for the device you play on.

    Check the connection method for your platform for the exact model you’re considering.

    If your device doesn’t support the connection you’ve chosen, you may need a different controller or a spare USB port.

  • A wired Switch controller isn’t always suitable for handheld use

    PowerA says the Enhanced Wired Controller reviewed here only works when the Switch is docked. The model also doesn’t support motion controls or amiibo NFC.

    Choose this wired option only if playing with your Switch docked suits the way you play.

  • A USB-C connection doesn’t prove that a rechargeable battery is included

    Microsoft specifies AA batteries for the Xbox controller; a rechargeable battery and cable are available separately.

    Check what’s included with the exact model and find out what power source you’ll need.

    Depending on the model, you may need to buy batteries or arrange a separate charging solution.

Brands to compare

8BitDo

8BitDo offers different connection options across its range. The SN30 Pro is a compact Bluetooth model for platforms including Switch and Windows, while the Ultimate 2C Wireless uses 2.4 GHz or a wired connection on Windows and supports Bluetooth on Android.

  • 8BitDo lists the SN30 Pro’s dimensions as 144 × 63,5 × 33 mm.
  • Its smaller size doesn’t tell you whether the grip will feel comfortable in every hand. Check the connection method required for each model too.

Xbox

The Xbox Wireless Controller is an option for supported Xbox consoles and Windows PCs. The connection depends on the model and device.

  • Microsoft lists Bluetooth and button mapping options.
  • Check the included accessories and power source; don’t assume it has a built-in rechargeable battery.

Nintendo

The official Switch Pro Controller is designed for Nintendo Switch players looking for the features of this model.

  • Nintendo lists motion controls, HD Rumble and amiibo functionality.
  • These model specifications don’t mean every farming game will benefit from them.

GameSir

The G7 SE is a wired option for Windows and Xbox. GameSir lists the cable length as 3 m.

  • GameSir lists Hall Effect sticks and mappable buttons among this model’s features.
  • Wired play requires room for the cable. Manufacturer claims about wear don’t guarantee that a controller will never develop a fault.

PowerA

The Enhanced Wired Controller for Nintendo Switch is a wired option for use with a docked Switch.

  • PowerA lists mappable buttons and says this model doesn’t require batteries.
  • PowerA states that this model only works with a docked Switch and doesn’t support motion controls or amiibo NFC.

PlayStation

A DualSense could be an option for a supported PC game if you’d also like to use a PS5 controller.

  • Sony supports connecting to a Windows PC via Bluetooth or USB.
  • Haptic feedback on PC requires support from the game as well as a USB connection.

Joybuy products

This selection includes controllers for Nintendo Switch, Windows and Xbox devices, and mobile devices. Before buying, check that your specific game and device support the controller and its connection method.

Hori Horipad Turbo Frost wireless controller for Nintendo Switch and Switch 2, white and transparent

Hori Horipad Turbo Frost for Nintendo Switch and Switch 2

A wireless option to compare if you play on Nintendo Switch or Switch 2 and are looking for programmable rear buttons.

The product information lists dimensions of 5,7 × 14,5 × 11,4 cm and a battery life of 10 hours.

View at Joybuy
SUBSONIC wireless controller for Nintendo Switch and Switch Lite, blue

SUBSONIC wireless controller for Switch and Switch Lite, blue

An option to compare if you play wirelessly on Switch or Switch Lite and want programmable rear buttons.

The product information lists Bluetooth, two programmable rear buttons, a rechargeable battery and an included USB-C cable.

View at Joybuy
KONIX controller pair for Nintendo Switch, Switch OLED and Switch 2, blue and red

KONIX controller pair for Switch, Switch OLED and Switch 2

This controller pair is an option to compare if you play on one of the listed Switch systems and want to play wirelessly.

The product information lists Bluetooth, a gyroscope, NFC, dual vibration motors and a stated battery life of up to 8 hours.

View at Joybuy
Xbox Wireless Controller Robot White

Xbox Wireless Controller Robot White

An option to compare if you play on a supported Windows PC or Xbox and want to play wirelessly.

The product information lists Xbox Wireless, Bluetooth and USB-C, plus compatibility with Windows 10 PCs, Xbox Series X|S and Xbox One. You can customise the buttons using the Xbox Accessories app.

View at Joybuy
GameSir G8 Galileo Plus Bluetooth controller for Switch, PC, iOS and Android

GameSir G8 Galileo Plus Bluetooth controller

An option to compare if you use a mobile device or another listed platform and want to connect the controller to that device.

The product information lists support for Switch, PC, iOS and Android, plus an adjustable phone holder for devices up to 179 mm wide.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Will every PC controller work with Stardew Valley automatically?

No. ConcernedApe specifically confirms support for Xbox One and Xbox 360 controllers on PC. If you’re considering another model, check that its connection method works with your PC and whether the game or gaming platform requires any settings.

How do I connect a compact SN30 Pro?

Follow the pairing instructions for your device in the 8BitDo manual. For Windows, 8BitDo describes Bluetooth and a wired USB connection. For Switch, the manual describes Bluetooth and wired use via the dock, with the specified system setting enabled.

Can a wired Switch controller be used without the dock?

Not the PowerA Enhanced Wired Controller for Nintendo Switch reviewed here: PowerA states that this model only works when the Switch is docked.

What costs and rights should I be aware of after buying?

Check whether batteries, a rechargeable battery, cable or receiver are included with the exact model. According to the Dutch government, statutory guarantees apply in the Netherlands, but there’s no fixed statutory guarantee period. For online purchases from a business, you’ll generally have a 14-day cooling-off period.