Which controller is right for you?

Farming gamer on the sofa

Wants to play on a television with a suitable gamepad and is mainly interested in whether it connects to their console or PC and is supported by the game.

Farming simulator player

Mostly plays Farming Simulator 25 and may want more dedicated controls for vehicles and tools than a standard gamepad can offer.

Practical PC or Xbox player

Wants a tidy setup and weighs up the distance from their seat against using a cable or managing batteries.

What should you look for when choosing?

Start with your console or PC and the exact game; the big screen itself doesn’t determine which controller will work. The Steam listing for Farming Simulator 25 specifies USB-only DualSense support, while Microsoft lists the Xbox Wireless Controller for Xbox consoles and Windows PCs.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Compatibility Make a note of your console or PC and the exact game, then check which platform and connection method the game supports. I want to avoid buying a controller that won’t work with my device or game. Around 36% of consumers say compatibility is their main concern.
Wireless play Check whether your device and game support a wireless connection, and how the controller is powered. I want to move freely from the sofa without a cable running to my seat. Around 29% of consumers prioritise wireless sofa gaming.
Machine controls Check that your game and platform version are supported, and find out whether any additional equipment is needed. When controlling vehicles and tools, I want more dedicated buttons than a standard gamepad offers. Around 21% of consumers prioritise machine controls.
No battery management Measure a safe cable route to your seat, or check which type of battery or charging solution the controller uses. I want a simple setup and would rather not replace or recharge batteries. Around 14% of consumers give this their highest priority.

Things to watch out for when buying

  • Bluetooth pairing with a PC doesn’t automatically mean you can play wirelessly in every game

    Sony describes how to pair the DualSense with Windows over Bluetooth, but the Steam listing for Farming Simulator 25 specifies USB-only support for DualSense.

    Check the game’s support separately from the controller’s connection options. For this combination, make sure you can use USB.

  • A FarmStick isn’t a universal standalone console controller

    Thrustmaster links the stated console support to Farming Simulator 25 and sets additional requirements for each console version.

    Choose the X or P version to match your platform, and check in advance that the game and version are compatible.

    To use it with Farming Simulator 25 on Xbox Series X|S or PS5, you’ll also need a compatible steering wheel. The FarmStick alone isn’t a complete setup for these consoles.

  • Choosing between wired and wireless without measuring the distance to your seat

    A cable may be too short to reach from your seat to your gaming device. Wireless play, on the other hand, means you need to consider the connection and power supply.

    Measure the route to your seat and check the cable length or battery type for the exact version.

Brands and controller ranges to compare

The features listed below apply to the specific controller ranges and situations described; mentioning a brand isn’t a recommendation of its entire range.

Xbox

Microsoft says the Xbox Wireless Controller is designed for Xbox consoles and Windows PCs, including sofa gaming with a supported game.

  • Microsoft lists Bluetooth connectivity and button mapping.
  • Wireless use requires AA batteries or a separate charging solution; check support for each game.

PlayStation

Sony describes the DualSense as a controller for PS5 that can also connect to supported Windows PCs via USB or Bluetooth.

  • USB and Bluetooth connection options are available with compatible devices.
  • For Farming Simulator 25, Steam lists USB-only DualSense support; features may vary by game.

Nintendo

The original Switch Pro Controller and the Switch 2 Pro Controller are different options for Nintendo console players.

  • Nintendo confirms that the original Switch Pro Controller can be paired wirelessly with Switch 2.
  • Nintendo says the Switch 2 Pro Controller is designed exclusively for Switch 2, so check which console generation you have.

Thrustmaster

The SimTask FarmStick X and the separate P version are designed for machine controls in supported simulation games, rather than as a universal replacement for a gamepad.

  • Thrustmaster lists 33 buttons and a hand throttle for the X version.
  • According to Thrustmaster, you’ll also need a steering wheel to use it with Farming Simulator 25 on Xbox Series X|S or PS5; make sure you choose the right version.

PowerA

According to PowerA, the Enhanced Wired Controller is a wired option for the Xbox consoles and Windows listed.

  • PowerA lists a detachable 3 m cable and two assignable buttons.
  • Check that the cable reaches your seat and can be routed safely away from walkways; a model listing doesn’t guarantee support in every game.

Joybuy products

These product picks are aimed at wireless gaming with an Xbox or Windows PC controller, and playing with a standalone controller on Nintendo Switch or Switch 2.

Xbox Wireless Controller for Xbox Series/PC - Ice Breaker Special Edition

Xbox Wireless Controller – Ice Breaker Special Edition

A good fit if you want to play wirelessly from the sofa on a supported Xbox or Windows PC.

The product description lists Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows PC, Xbox Wireless, Bluetooth, USB-C and button mapping. 2 AA batteries are included, with a stated battery life of up to 40 hours.

Xbox Support says rechargeable AA batteries aren’t charged inside the controller; charge them according to the battery manufacturer’s instructions.

View product at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch Pro Controller - Black

Nintendo Switch Pro Controller – Black

An option if you want to play on Nintendo Switch with a standalone controller, without having to manage AA batteries.

The product description lists wireless controls, a built-in rechargeable battery and motion controls. Nintendo confirms that the original Switch Pro Controller can also be paired wirelessly with Switch 2.

View product at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch 2 - Official Pro Controller - Black

Nintendo Switch 2 Official Pro Controller – Black

A good fit if you want to play on Nintendo Switch 2 with a standalone wireless controller.

The product description lists a rechargeable battery, motion controls and HD Rumble. Nintendo says this controller is designed exclusively for Nintendo Switch 2.

View product at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I use any Bluetooth controller for Farming Simulator 25 on PC?

No. Pairing a controller with your PC over Bluetooth doesn’t guarantee that the game supports it wirelessly. The Steam listing states that the game has full controller support, but lists DualSense and DualShock as USB-only. Check which connection methods are supported for your game version and controller.

What can I try if my controller isn’t responding in Stardew Valley through Steam?

Stardew Valley’s official troubleshooting guide recommends enabling Steam Input for the game. If that doesn’t help, the guide advises restoring the default controller configuration.

Do I need a steering wheel as well as a SimTask FarmStick?

Yes, for the console combinations mentioned. According to Thrustmaster, the X version requires a steering wheel to play Farming Simulator 25 on Xbox Series X|S; the P version also requires a steering wheel on PS5. Check that you have the right version, and for the X version on Xbox, follow Thrustmaster’s guidance on the game version and firmware too.

Will rechargeable AA batteries charge inside an Xbox Wireless Controller via USB?

No. Xbox Support says rechargeable AA batteries aren’t charged inside the controller; charge them according to the battery manufacturer’s instructions. A compatible Xbox rechargeable battery pack is an alternative.

What are my rights in the Netherlands if I’m unhappy with a controller I bought online or it breaks too soon?

According to ACM ConsuWijzer, online product purchases usually come with a statutory cooling-off period of up to 14 days after delivery; check which exceptions and return conditions apply. Your statutory rights are separate from any manufacturer’s warranty. If a product doesn’t meet what you could reasonably expect under normal use, contact the seller. Dutch law doesn’t simply set a fixed two-year period for this.