Who is a NAS archive suitable for?

Keeper of irreplaceable source files

You keep original scans and research files and want to be able to restore them after an error or hardware failure. A separate backup is more important for this than drive redundancy alone; the National Cyber Security Centre advises keeping important files backed up separately.

Researcher with files on multiple devices

You want to open local source folders from, for example, a desktop computer and a laptop without losing the links between your notes and sources. Centralised file storage can help; check that the setup suits your devices and folder structure.

Family archivist who shares selectively

You want to share some documents with family while keeping private files and information about living people secure. The Dutch Data Protection Authority distinguishes between personal or household use and publication, so consider carefully who gets access.

What should you look for when choosing?

First, work out how you would restore a lost or changed source file. Then consider organisation, access, drive configuration and the storage capacity your archive needs.

Consideration What should you check? Who should give this greater weight?
Restoring irreplaceable data Check whether you can make a separate copy and how to run restore tests. RAID is no substitute for a backup. If I want to be able to restore original scans after a fault or error, recoverability comes first. Around 33% of consumers choosing a NAS for local family tree sources give recoverability their highest priority.
Central organisation and access Check access from your own devices, and whether you can keep your preferred folder structure and file names. If I want to use source folders across multiple devices without separating notes and documents, central organisation matters. Around 27% of consumers put this first.
Access to family information Check user and folder permissions, and decide who can see which files. Don’t expose your NAS to the internet unless necessary. If I want to share certain documents with family while keeping private sources secure, access permissions matter. Around 20% of consumers give restricted sharing their highest priority.
Capacity and overall setup Measure your current files, estimate how they’ll grow and check which drives are compatible, whether they’re included, and how much usable space your chosen configuration will provide. If I want enough space for scans and future additions without losing sight of the overall setup, I consider capacity and the components required. Around 20% of consumers put this trade-off first.

Common buying mistakes

  • Mistaking two drives for two independent backups

    RAID can help keep your files available if one drive fails, but it does not replace a backup. Otherwise, deletions or unwanted changes can affect the files on the NAS too.

    Before you buy, decide where you’ll keep a separate, restorable copy and test it regularly.

    Allow for a separate backup destination and the work involved in managing it.

  • Mistaking raw capacity for available archive space

    Usable storage capacity can vary depending on the number of drives used and the RAID configuration. The total advertised drive capacity is therefore not necessarily the space available for your files.

    Compare the setup with or without drives, and calculate how much space will be left with your chosen configuration.

    Suitable drives and possibly extra storage for a separate backup are part of the complete setup.

  • Making a private archive widely accessible for convenience

    Remote access can increase security risks. A shared archive may also contain information you don’t want visible to every visitor or family group.

    Start with restricted user permissions, and assess internet access and any publication separately.

Brands to compare

Synology

The DiskStation DS223 and DS223j are two-bay models for central storage of documents and photos.

  • Synology lists Btrfs and snapshots for the DS223.
  • For the DS223j, Synology lists this feature as available from DSM 7.2.
  • Check the software version, drive choice and snapshot settings for each model. Snapshots on the NAS are no substitute for a separate backup.

QNAP

QNAP positions the TS-233 for beginners and home use.

  • QNAP’s official specifications list two drive bays, one gigabit network port and 2 GB of non-expandable memory.
  • First decide how you’ll back up and restore your files; these hardware specifications alone won’t tell you whether the workflow suits your archive.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 AS1102T is an alternative for local file storage.

  • ASUSTOR lists two bays for 3.5-inch SATA HDDs and a 2.5-gigabit network port.
  • The manufacturer lists internal EXT4 storage and RAID 1 as an option.
  • Check which drives and restore method suit your setup; a faster network port alone doesn’t prove that an archive workflow will be faster.

Joybuy products for central storage

This Joybuy selection focuses on Synology NAS models for central storage and management of local family history documents. Check which drives and storage configuration suit your archive, and plan a separate, restorable backup as well.

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS

Suited to anyone who wants to manage and share family tree documents centrally.

Compatible hard drives are not included; choose a separate backup destination too, and test the restore process.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Suited to anyone who wants to manage research files centrally and be able to expand their storage setup.

Check which compatible hard drives and any expansion components you’ll need for your preferred setup; plan a separate backup too.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

Synology DiskStation DS925+, without hard drives

Suited to anyone looking for central file storage for a growing family tree archive.

This version is supplied without hard drives; choose these separately and keep an independent backup as well.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID 1 enough to back up your family tree archive?

No, RAID 1 is no substitute for a separate backup. The National Cyber Security Centre points out that RAID can help a NAS keep running if a drive fails, but it is not a backup copy. Keep a separate copy and test that you can restore your source files from it.

What should you set up first after installation?

First, set up access permissions and a separate backup, then decide whether remote access is really necessary. The National Cyber Security Centre advises changing default passwords and, ideally, not making a NAS directly accessible over the internet.

How can you check that you can restore older versions of source files?

Set an appropriate retention period for backups or, on a model and software version that support them, snapshots. Test the restore process with a non-critical file; the National Cyber Security Centre lists automation and restore tests as part of a backup strategy.

What components and service terms should you check before buying?

Check whether the offer includes drives, which drives are compatible and how much usable space your chosen configuration will provide. Also consider which separate backup destination you’ll need, and read the warranty terms for the specific product on offer.

Can you share information about living family members through your NAS?

That depends on how you use and share the information. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, processing purely for personal or household purposes falls outside the GDPR; private publication has its own conditions, including a limited audience and not being publicly searchable. Assess public publication separately before sharing information about other people.