Guardian of irreplaceable family records
You want to be able to retrieve scans, photos and research notes even after an error or failure. Being able to check a second copy matters more to you than top speed.
For a family history archive that is mainly kept in one place and copied periodically, a portable HDD is a sensible option. An SSD is a better fit if you often carry the drive with you or move files between computers. In 2022, the Dutch Consumers’ Association described HDDs as more vulnerable to shocks than SSDs, but this was not a test of the models on this page. Whichever drive you choose, keep a separate copy and check that you can open your files from it.
You want to be able to retrieve scans, photos and research notes even after an error or failure. Being able to check a second copy matters more to you than top speed.
You collect image files and want to weigh up storage capacity against portability and a drive’s susceptibility to shocks.
You work on more than one computer and are particularly concerned with portability, suitable cables and access to the same files.
First, work out how much space your scans and future versions will need. An HDD can be a good fit for periodic archive copies kept in one place; consider an SSD if you regularly take the drive with you or move files between devices.
| Concern | What to check before buying | Who this matters to |
|---|---|---|
| Being able to restore files | Keep a separate copy and test whether you can restore and open your files from it. | If I can’t recreate my scans or notes, I want to know that a copy really works. About 31% of consumers put recoverability first. |
| Space for your archive | Check the size of your project folder and allow for files and versions you may want to add later. | As my collection grows, I want the drive to have room for both existing scans and new documents. About 25% of consumers make archive capacity their top priority. |
| Taking files with you and copying them | Check that the drive connects to both computers; don’t assume that quoted speeds are guaranteed transfer speeds. | If I regularly travel between school and home, portability and transferring larger files both matter. About 19% of consumers prioritise portability and copying. |
| Using it with your computers | For each computer, check the port, file system and support for the backup feature you want to use. | If I need to open or back up files on different computers, I want to know in advance what setup is needed. About 13% of consumers make compatibility their top priority. |
| Access to family information | Check whether files identify living people and who has access to the drive and its copy. | If my project contains information about living relatives, I want to think carefully about who can access it. The Dutch Data Protection Authority considers information about identifiable living people to be personal data. About 12% of consumers put restricting access first. |
If you only move your files to the new drive, it could become your only copy.
Copy the files rather than simply moving them. Test the copy by restoring and opening a few important scans and documents. The Netherlands’ National Cyber Security Centre recommends testing backups.
A maximum speed in a product specification doesn’t tell you how quickly files will copy on your computer; the connection and the conditions both make a difference.
First check your computer’s port and cable. Don’t let a speed rating make the decision on its own.
Reformatting can erase the files on the drive. Crucial specifically warns about this for the X9.
Check the file system and first make a separate copy that you can open.
A claim about the casing or drop protection doesn’t mean that files can be recovered after every kind of damage.
As well as the drive you take with you, keep a separate copy and test it independently of the casing’s protection.
The Expansion Portable range is a portable HDD option to compare for periodic archive copies. The data sheet lists the STKM2000400, among other models, with 2 TB of storage.
WD Elements Portable is an HDD range for anyone who needs local storage space for files. The variant listed is WDBU6Y0020BBK-WESN with 2 TB of storage.
The blue T7 Shield 1 TB, model MU-PE1T0R/EU, is an SSD to compare if you often carry your drive with you.
The XS1000 is a compact SSD range for transferring files between devices; Kingston lists 1 TB and 2 TB versions.
The X9 1 TB, model CT1000X9SSD9, is an SSD to compare if you need files to work across computers or backup methods.
These picks include portable HDDs for extra storage and portable SSDs for files you want to take with you or move between computers.
No image available
A portable SSD option with 1 TB of space for project files you want to take with you.
The product information lists USB-C, USB 3.2 Gen 2 and drop protection up to 2 metres.
No image available
A portable HDD option for a growing archive. Bear in mind that the Dutch Consumers’ Association says HDDs are more susceptible to shocks than SSDs.
The product information lists 6 TB, automatic backup software, password protection and 256-bit AES hardware encryption. It also mentions USB power and a weight of 210 grams.
No image available
A portable HDD option for documents, photos and other project files. Bear in mind that HDDs are more susceptible to shocks if you often take the drive with you.
The product information lists 2 TB, password protection, 256-bit AES encryption, backup software and a USB cable in the box. A downloadable NTFS compatibility driver is described for macOS.
No image available
A portable HDD option for a project archive where you need 4 TB of storage.
The product information lists USB 3.2 Gen 1, compatibility with USB 2.0 and a USB cable in the box. Reformatting is mentioned for macOS; first make a copy of any files already on the drive.
No image available
A portable SSD option for a larger archive of scans that you want to carry with you in a compact form.
The product information lists 2 TB, USB 3.2 Gen 2 and AES 256-bit encryption. The quoted maximum read and write speeds are 1.050/1.000 MB/s; USB-C-to-C and USB-C-to-A cables are also listed.
Restore a few files from the separate copy and open important scans and documents. The Netherlands’ National Cyber Security Centre recommends testing backups so you know whether recovery works.
According to Microsoft, Windows File History can copy personal folders to an external drive or network location and restore previous versions. Check that your project folder is included.
Not necessarily: first check the existing file system and the computers or backup feature you want to use. Crucial warns that with the X9, compatibility may depend on the file system and host device, and that reformatting erases data on the drive.
First consider whether the information identifies living people and who will be able to see the publication. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, information about identifiable living people is personal data; information about someone who has died can also reveal something about a living relative. The Authority says that in most cases you need permission to publish other people’s personal data; the exception for purely personal or household use has conditions.
According to ACM ConsuWijzer, the seller is responsible if a product does not meet what you could reasonably expect when used normally; a manufacturer’s warranty does not replace that legal responsibility. A warranty on the drive won’t automatically restore your files, so keep a separate copy as well.