Who is this choice relevant to?

A home for irreplaceable family records

You want to be able to find and restore scans, photos and research notes in the future. A clear folder structure and separate copies matter more than top speed. The Dutch National Archives describes digital archiving as selecting, organising and making information accessible; the Library of Congress recommends keeping multiple copies on different media and in different locations.

Collector with large project folders

You store lots of completed research projects and want to choose a capacity that suits your current collection and expected growth. To do this, compare the size of your folders with the capacity of the exact drive model.

Active family history researcher

You regularly open and move scans and photos, possibly between different workspaces. Connectivity, portability and working speed may then matter more than maximum storage capacity alone.

What should you look for in an external drive for family history folders?

Consideration What should you check? Who should pay particular attention?
Preservation and recovery Plan a separate copy on another storage medium and keep it in a different location. Check that important files open. If I don’t want to lose family records, I look beyond a single archive drive. An estimated 31% of consumers prioritise preservation and recovery.
Space for project folders Add up the size of your existing folders and compare the total with the capacity of the exact model. Also allow for future growth. If I want to store lots of completed projects and new scans, having enough space is my first concern. An estimated 25% of consumers prioritise capacity.
Working speed and portability Check your computer’s port and cable. Look at the basis for speed claims: sequential figures don’t automatically show how quickly a drive will handle all your project folders. If I often open or move files and take the drive between workspaces, active use is part of my decision. An estimated 19% of consumers prioritise this kind of use.
Computers and backup software Check the file system, connection and requirements of your backup software before copying files or formatting the drive. If you want to use the drive with different computers or backup methods, check in advance that its format is suitable. An estimated 13% of consumers prioritise this kind of compatibility.
Privacy Think about who will have access and whether you’ll take the drive with you. Check the encryption options available on your computer or the exact drive model. If I want to keep family information private, I consider who can access it and what identifiable images I share. An estimated 12% of consumers prioritise privacy.

What to consider when buying and using a drive

  • Mistaking a fast or rugged SSD for a completely safe archive

    An SSD won’t protect your files if it’s the only copy. The Library of Congress recommends keeping copies on at least two different storage media and in separate physical locations.

    First decide where the extra copy will be stored and how you’ll check that important files still open. Then choose an HDD or SSD based on capacity and how you’ll use it.

  • Formatting for Time Machine before securing the existing contents

    Apple recommends APFS or APFS Encrypted for a Time Machine drive. Reformatting erases the existing data on the drive.

    Check the format before use and first move any files you want to keep to another safe location.

  • Assuming that a large capacity will automatically make files easy to find

    Storage space won’t organise your project folders for you. The Dutch National Archives distinguishes between preserving, organising and describing information to keep it accessible.

    Use clear folder and file names, and check important scans from time to time. This takes time for organising and checking.

  • Confusing the manufacturer’s warranty with your statutory rights in the Netherlands

    According to the Dutch Government, there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands; your right to a product that meets reasonable expectations is separate from any manufacturer’s warranty.

    Keep your proof of purchase and contact the retailer if a product is faulty. A warranty on the drive itself doesn’t mean lost archive files can be recovered.

Brands and product ranges to consider

Seagate

Expansion Portable is a range of portable HDDs; the Expansion desktop range is designed for a fixed workspace and larger storage needs.

  • Seagate confirms that the Expansion Portable model STKM4000400 has a capacity of 4 TB.
  • The Expansion desktop range requires a power adapter. Manufacturer claims about reliability or data recovery don’t guarantee that lost files can be restored.

Toshiba

Canvio Basics is a range of portable HDDs; model HDTB540EK3CA has a capacity of 4 TB.

  • Toshiba states that the model reviewed works without a separate power supply and is pre-formatted as NTFS for Windows.
  • For the macOS versions mentioned, Toshiba says reformatting is required. First make sure any files you want to keep are safely stored elsewhere.

Samsung

The T7 Shield MU-PE2T0S/EU is a 2 TB portable SSD for anyone who takes their drive with them or regularly uses its files.

  • For this model, Samsung lists USB 3.2 Gen 2 and sequential read and write speeds of 1.050/1.000 MB/s.
  • These are the manufacturer’s figures for sequential transfers, not a measure of how the drive handles mixed project folders or a guarantee of an archive’s lifespan.

SanDisk

Portable SSD SDSSDE30-2T00-G26 is a 2 TB portable SSD model.

  • SanDisk lists a sequential read speed of 800 MB/s for this model.
  • This quoted speed doesn’t show how quickly the drive handles mixed project folders, nor does it prove that the SSD is sufficient as your only archive copy.

Joybuy products for archiving and active use

This Joybuy selection includes portable HDDs for project folders, a desktop HDD for a fixed workspace and a portable SSD for anyone who uses their files regularly.

WD Elements Desktop external hard drive, 6 TB

WD Elements Desktop 6 TB

Suited to large project folders that are mainly stored in one fixed workspace.

6 TB; USB 3.0; NTFS for Windows according to the product description. The desktop model uses a mains adapter.

Reformatting may be required for use with a Mac; first make sure any existing files are safely stored elsewhere.

Joybuy
WD Elements Portable external hard drive, USB-C, 6 TB

WD Elements Portable 6 TB USB-C

A portable HDD for anyone who wants to take large project folders between workspaces.

6 TB; 2.5-inch model; USB-C. The product description lists a weight of 240 g.

The product description warns that physical shocks and moisture can cause damage; take care when carrying and using the drive.

Joybuy
My Passport portable external hard drive, USB-C, 5 TB

My Passport USB-C 5 TB

A portable HDD for large project folders; the product description says it works with Windows and Mac computers.

5 TB; USB-C; exFAT. The product description lists password protection with hardware encryption.

Joybuy
Toshiba Canvio Basics portable external hard drive, 4 TB

Toshiba Canvio Basics 4 TB

A portable HDD for archive files and project folders.

4 TB; USB 3.2 Gen 1; powered via USB. The product description lists plug-and-play use and formatting for Windows.

The product description says reformatting is required for macOS. First make a separate copy of any files you want to keep.

Joybuy
Samsung Portable SSD T7, 2 TB, USB Type-C

Samsung Portable SSD T7 2 TB

A portable SSD for anyone who regularly opens project files or takes their drive with them.

2 TB; USB 3.2 Gen 2. Samsung lists sequential read and write speeds of up to 1.050/1.000 MB/s.

The quoted sequential figures don’t predict how quickly your complete project folders will be processed. This drive is no substitute for a separate copy either.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is one external drive enough to store my family history research for years?

No, don’t rely on a single copy. The Library of Congress recommends keeping copies on at least two different storage media and in separate physical locations. Also plan how you’ll store your files on up-to-date media in the future.

Can I back up my entire project folder using Windows File History?

Yes, if you add the folder to a library that File History backs up. Microsoft explains that folders outside existing libraries can be added to a library; afterwards, check that you can restore a file.

Can I use a drive formatted for Windows with Time Machine straight away?

Not in its existing Windows format. Apple recommends APFS or APFS Encrypted for a Time Machine drive; reformatting removes the existing data, so make sure it’s safely stored elsewhere first.

What does the warranty cover if my external drive breaks?

In the Netherlands, you’re entitled to a product that meets reasonable expectations, but according to the Dutch Government there is no fixed statutory warranty period. Contact the retailer if a product is faulty. A hardware warranty doesn’t guarantee that lost archive files can be recovered.

Does the GDPR apply to a private family history archive?

The Dutch Data Protection Authority describes an exemption for personal or household use. For identifiable photos, that exemption may no longer apply if you share them more widely or publish them publicly. So consider sharing or publishing separately from keeping your drive for private use.