First, choose a controller that works with the system and version of the basketball game you’re playing. PlayStation says PS5 games require a DualSense, while Xbox, PC and Switch models each have their own compatibility requirements. Then count how many complete controllers you need and weigh the convenience of wireless play against cable length and power requirements. A familiar button layout alone doesn’t make a controller suitable for another platform.
Who is this guide for?
Flatmates sharing one console
You want to get extra players involved on the same console. So check the console generation and how many complete controllers the game requires. PlayStation and NBA 2K Support explain the relevant game and platform options.
Basketball players sharing a PC
You’re looking for a controller that works with your Windows PC and the game you’re playing. If players are sitting in different places, available USB ports and the connection type also matter. PlayStation, Xbox and PowerA describe PC support for their respective models.
Budget-conscious organiser
You want to check which controllers you already have at home and how many more player slots you need. A wired controller or existing Switch controllers may be worth considering if they suit the game and seating arrangement. Nintendo and PowerA provide product information about the relevant accessories.
What should you look for when buying?
When buying extra controllers for local basketball games in a shared student house, take a practical approach: first check the system and game, then count the player slots you need, and finally compare the connection and power options.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who should pay particular attention? |
| Compatibility |
Note the console or PC and the game version. PlayStation says PS5 games require a DualSense; also check whether the game supports your chosen connection. |
If I buy an extra controller, it needs to work with our console or PC and the game. Around 33% of consumers prioritise compatibility with the shared system. |
| Complete player slots |
Count the usable controllers and check how many local players the game and mode allow. Nintendo warns that the required Joy-Con layout depends on the game. |
I want to know how many flatmates can actually play at once and what controls the game requires. Around 27% of consumers focus mainly on having enough complete controllers for everyone taking part. |
| Total running costs |
Check which controllers are already available and what the chosen model requires for power or charging. Microsoft says the standard Xbox Wireless Controller uses batteries or a separate charging solution. |
If we want to fill several player slots, I’ll first check what we already have at home and what else we need to power the controllers. Around 20% of consumers prioritise the cost of several usable controllers. |
| Seating and connection |
If needed, measure the distance to the console or PC and check the available USB ports and supported connection type. PowerA lists a 3 m cable for the wired model mentioned here. |
I want to play from our seats without a cable getting in the way or a wireless connection dropping out. Around 20% of consumers prioritise freedom of movement and a suitable connection. |
Common mistakes
-
Choosing a controller because the connection or buttons look familiar
A DUALSHOCK 4 won’t replace a DualSense for PS5 games. 8BitDo describes the Ultimate 2C Wired as being for Windows and Android, not Xbox consoles.
Before buying, check the console, game version and platform listing for the exact model.
-
Assuming a pair of Joy-Con automatically counts as two suitable basketball controllers
The number of connected controllers doesn’t automatically tell you how many players the chosen game supports with that layout.
Check the required controls and the number of local players in the game before counting extra player slots.
-
Only considering the wireless model
The standard Xbox Wireless Controller uses batteries; you may need a separate battery pack for a rechargeable option.
Compare what comes with the model against a wired option that can reach your seats.
Allow for batteries or a separate charging solution. Microsoft describes both options for the Xbox controller.
Brands to consider
Sony PlayStation
A relevant choice if you’re playing the PS5 version of the game. PlayStation also describes use with compatible PC games via USB or Bluetooth.
- PlayStation lists haptic feedback and adaptive triggers as DualSense features.
- On PC, features depend on the game; haptic feedback requires USB. A DUALSHOCK 4 won’t replace a controller for PS5 games.
Microsoft Xbox
For supported Xbox consoles and Windows PCs.
- Microsoft lists Bluetooth, a hybrid D-pad and button mapping for the Xbox Wireless Controller.
- Allow for batteries or a separate charging solution.
Nintendo
For households playing on a Nintendo Switch or Switch 2.
- Nintendo confirms that the original Switch Pro Controller can connect wirelessly to Switch 2.
- The game determines which controller layout you need. Older Joy-Con do not charge when attached to the Switch 2 system.
PowerA
A wired option for supported Xbox systems and Windows, if using a cable works for your living room.
- PowerA lists a detachable 3 m USB cable and two mappable extra buttons for the Enhanced Wired Controller.
- The cable limits how far you can sit from the system.
8BitDo
The Ultimate 2C Wired and Wireless are models to consider for Windows. Check the connection and platform support for each one.
- 8BitDo lists Hall Effect sticks on both models mentioned here.
- For Windows, the Wireless model uses 2.4 GHz or a cable, and Bluetooth for Android. 8BitDo does not list Xbox console support for these 2C models.
Joybuy products
These Joybuy products are for Xbox and Windows, PS5 and Nintendo Switch systems. For your specific game, always check that it supports the model mentioned and the controller layout you want to use.
No image available
Xbox Wireless Controller for Xbox Series/PC – Ice Breaker Special Edition
An option to consider if you’re looking for a wireless Xbox controller for Xbox Series or PC.
The product name lists Xbox Series/PC and the Ice Breaker Special Edition model.
View at Joybuy
No image available
KONIX JoyPad Controller Pair for Nintendo Switch and Switch OLED, suitable for Switch 2
A pair of controllers to consider if you’re looking for extra controls for a Switch system; check that the game supports this layout.
The product name lists Nintendo Switch, Switch OLED and compatibility with Switch 2, as well as an 8-hour battery life.
View at Joybuy
No image available
PlayStation DualSense Wireless Controller – Grand Theft Auto VI White Limited Edition
A DualSense option for flatmates playing the PS5 version; PlayStation lists DualSense as required for PS5 games.
The product name lists PS5, PC, Mac and mobile devices. PlayStation says PC features depend on the game.
View at Joybuy
No image available
BEITONG KP70 Haptic Feedback Elite Wireless Controller
A model to compare if you’re looking for a controller whose product name lists PC and NS2; check that your game supports it.
The product name lists six programmable buttons and PC/NS/NS2/iOS/Android.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Nintendo Switch 2 Official Pro Controller – Black
A Pro Controller to consider if you’re playing on Nintendo Switch 2; check the basketball game’s controller requirements.
The product name lists Nintendo Switch 2 and the colour Black.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Can an existing PS4 controller be used by a second player in a PS5 game?
No. PlayStation says PS5 games require a DualSense. Check which version of the game you’re starting: supported PS4 games on PS5 have different controller options.
Can every flatmate play basketball on Switch with a single Joy-Con?
That depends on the game and mode you choose. Nintendo counts the left and right Joy-Con as separately connected controllers, but the software also determines how many players can join in and which controls they need.
How can you avoid power problems during a game?
Check the battery level or charge the controller before you play. Microsoft explains how to check the battery level of an Xbox controller; older Joy-Con cannot be charged from the Switch 2 system itself.
What if a controller bought online isn’t suitable or breaks too soon during normal use?
In the Netherlands, online purchases generally come with a cooling-off period of up to 14 days after delivery, subject to exceptions that you should check. You’re also covered by the statutory guarantee if a product doesn’t perform as you could reasonably expect during normal use; the seller is responsible for this.