Who is this relevant to?

Player with a dedicated console

You’re looking for an extra controller that works with your Switch, Switch 2, PS5, Xbox or PC, as well as the local play mode. Nintendo, PlayStation, Xbox and 8BitDo publish compatibility information for each platform and variant.

Organiser of group battles

You count the active players, check which controllers are already available, and find out how many players and what type of controls the game supports. Nintendo Support and PlayStation Support make it clear that connecting controllers doesn’t automatically mean there are the same number of player slots.

Player in a shared living room

You want to avoid running a cable through an area shared by players and spectators, or you might choose a wired connection if you can set it up safely. Microsoft and PowerA describe wireless and wired connection options for specific controllers.

What to consider when choosing

First, check the game mode and the controls you already have. Nintendo Support and PlayStation Support distinguish between the number of connected controllers and the number of players a game supports.

What to consider What to look for Who is this important for?
Compatibility Check the full model variant, platform and local play mode. Also check whether a particular system version is required. If I want to make sure the controller works with both my platform and the game I’ve chosen, I check both before buying. Around 36% of consumers put compatibility first.
Active players Count the players who’ll be playing at the same time and the controllers available. Check whether the game requires individual Joy-Cons or complete controllers. When several people are playing at once, I want to know how many suitable controls are actually needed. Around 29% of consumers put the number of usable controls first.
Cables and space Check whether wireless play is supported, whether the cable is long enough and whether it can be placed safely out of the way. If spectators and players are moving around the same screen, I don’t want a cable crossing their path. Around 21% of consumers prioritise the setup and room to move.
Power and essentials Check the power source, charging options and whether cables or batteries are included with the exact version. If you want to know straight away which batteries, cables or charging equipment you’ll need, it’s important to check what comes with the version you’ve chosen. Around 14% of consumers start by checking these essentials.

Common buying mistakes

  • Confusing the connection limit with the player limit

    A console can connect to several controllers, but the game and play mode determine how many people can actually join in.

    Check the specific game, mode and supported controls. Then count the active players and the controllers you already have.

  • Treating the two 8BitDo Ultimate 2C variants as the same product

    8BitDo lists different platforms and connections for the Ultimate 2C Bluetooth and Ultimate 2C Wireless.

    Compare the full variant name with the official platform information. For the Bluetooth variant, also check the system version specified for Switch 2.

  • Choosing a wired Switch controller without checking the game’s controls

    The PowerA Enhanced Wired Controller - Heroic Link reviewed here is designed for use when the Switch is docked. This version doesn’t support motion controls and isn’t suitable for games that use Joy-Cons exclusively.

    Check which controls your game requires and plan a cable route that stays out of the way.

  • Assuming the manufacturer’s warranty is your only protection

    ACM ConsuWijzer distinguishes between a commercial warranty and your legal rights if a product is faulty.

    Keep your proof of purchase and contact the retailer if you think a product is faulty.

Relevant brands to consider

Nintendo

Joy-Con and Pro controllers for local Switch games. For Switch 2, check which generation of controller you’re choosing.

  • Nintendo says Joy-Con 2 can be used individually in compatible play styles. The original Switch Pro Controller can also connect wirelessly to Switch 2.
  • Joy-Con 2 doesn’t work with the original Switch. Older Joy-Cons can work wirelessly with Switch 2, but won’t charge when attached to the Switch 2 console.

PlayStation

DualSense as an extra controller for PS5 and, where applicable, for supported PC games.

  • Sony explains how to pair a second DualSense wirelessly and says PS5 supports up to four controllers at once.
  • On PC, Sony says haptic feedback requires support from the game and a USB connection. This doesn’t mean every game supports the feature.

Xbox

Xbox Wireless Controller for supported Xbox consoles and Windows PCs.

  • Microsoft lists Xbox Wireless for consoles, and Bluetooth or USB-C for supported PCs.
  • Check the power source and what’s included with the version you choose. Microsoft’s published battery tests are based on AA batteries.

PowerA

Includes a wired extra controller for Switch setups where the console is docked.

  • PowerA lists a detachable 3-metre cable and Switch 2 compatibility for the Enhanced Wired Controller - Heroic Link.
  • This version is for use with a docked console only and doesn’t support motion controls, HD Rumble or amiibo NFC. It isn’t suitable for games that only work with Joy-Cons.

8BitDo

Ultimate 2C variants for different platforms. The full variant name tells you which one is right for your setup.

  • 8BitDo lists Switch and, subject to certain conditions, Switch 2 for the Ultimate 2C Bluetooth; the Ultimate 2C Wireless is listed for Windows and Android.
  • Check the system version for Switch 2 and don’t confuse the two variants. The Hall-effect sticks listed by 8BitDo are not, on their own, proof of a particular lifespan or that stick drift won’t occur.

Controllers for local group gaming

This selection includes extra controllers for Xbox and Windows setups, and for Switch and Switch 2 setups, with both wireless and wired options. Check that each model’s connection, play mode and power requirements suit your setup.

Xbox Wireless Controller for Xbox Series/PC - Ice Breaker Special Edition

Xbox Wireless Controller for Xbox Series/PC - Ice Breaker Special Edition

An option for an Xbox or Windows setup if you want to play wirelessly.

The product description lists Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows 10/11, with Xbox Wireless and Bluetooth.

The description says two AA batteries are included. Check the contents of this version’s box.

Joybuy
Hori Wired Controller Horipad Turbo for Switch and Switch 2 - Pokemon Eevee Cottage Core Edition

Hori Wired Controller Horipad Turbo for Switch and Switch 2 - Pokemon Eevee Cottage Core Edition

A wired option for a Switch or Switch 2 setup if you can position the cable safely.

The product title lists Switch and Switch 2. The description mentions USB and programmable rear buttons.

The controller is wired, and the USB cable isn’t included, according to the product description.

Joybuy
HORI Super Mario Galaxy Horipad Turbo - Wireless Controller for Nintendo Switch and Switch 2

HORI Super Mario Galaxy Horipad Turbo - Wireless Controller for Nintendo Switch and Switch 2

A wireless option for a Switch or Switch 2 setup if a cable would get in the way of your shared playing area.

The product description lists Bluetooth, motion sensors and programmable buttons. The product title mentions a C Button and a 10-hour battery life.

Joybuy
Turtle Beach Rematch Super Mario Jump Wireless Controller - Nintendo Switch 2 and Switch OLED

Turtle Beach Rematch Super Mario Jump Wireless Controller - Nintendo Switch 2 and Switch OLED

A wireless option if you want to keep a cable out of the playing or walking area.

The product description lists Nintendo Switch, a built-in rechargeable battery and a USB charging cable. The product title lists Switch 2 and Switch OLED.

The title mentions a 40-hour battery life, a TMR joystick, a C Button for GameChat and two programmable buttons.

Joybuy
SUBSONIC Wireless Controller for Switch and Switch Lite with LED, blue

SUBSONIC Wireless Controller for Switch and Switch Lite, blue

A wireless option for a Switch or Switch Lite setup if a cable would be inconvenient in a shared space.

The product description lists Bluetooth, motion sensors, three vibration levels and two programmable rear buttons.

The description mentions a rechargeable battery and an included USB-C charging cable.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does every spectator need a controller?

No, only people playing at the same time need a controller. Check how many players and what controller setup the game and play mode support. Nintendo lists up to eight players for the Smash mode in Super Smash Bros. Ultimate, but that doesn’t automatically apply to other games.

Can I charge older Joy-Cons on a Switch 2?

No, older Joy-Cons don’t charge when attached to the Switch 2 console. Nintendo says they can work wirelessly with Switch 2; to charge them, you’ll need an original Switch or a compatible charging accessory.

How do I pair a second DualSense with a PS5?

Sony explains how to pair one wirelessly using a controller that’s already connected: open Settings, go to Accessories, then General and Bluetooth Accessories. On the second controller, press and hold the create and PS buttons, then select the controller on screen. Sony lists support for up to four controllers at once on PS5.

What can I do if a controller breaks too soon during normal use?

In the Netherlands, statutory warranty rights are separate from any manufacturer’s warranty. According to ACM ConsuWijzer, the retailer may have to repair or replace a faulty product free of charge under the applicable conditions. There isn’t one fixed statutory warranty period for every controller.