Who is this buying guide for?

Housemates with a Switch

Want to know whether one Joy-Con per player is enough or whether their game requires full controllers. Nintendo says the supported play style varies by game; also check whether you have a Switch or Switch 2.

Living-room gamers with a PS5 or Xbox

Are looking for an extra controller for their existing console and want to check before buying whether their chosen game supports local multiplayer. Sony and Xbox describe controllers for their respective systems.

PC gamers sharing a living room

Want to connect controllers without the connection, cables or game support getting in the way of playing together. Sony describes how to connect a DualSense to a PC; Xbox notes that Bluetooth reliability on PC also depends on the adapter.

What should you look for in an extra controller?

First check your console and the game’s local multiplayer options. Then compare the controller layout and connection with where you’ll be sitting and the controllers you already have.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
System compatibility Check the exact console generation or PC platform, and which connections are supported. If I’m looking for a controller for the system I already have at home, I want to be sure it’s compatible. Around 33% of consumers prioritise compatibility with their existing system.
Player positions Check how many local players the game supports and which controller layout it requires. If housemates want to play an adventure together, it matters whether everyone has a supported player position. Around 27% of consumers focus mainly on having enough suitable player positions for the game.
Connection and seating distance Weigh up wireless use against the connection and power available. For wired play, check the cable length and console setup. If the console isn’t right next to the seating area, I want to know whether a cable will reach comfortably or whether a wireless connection suits my setup. Around 20% of consumers focus mainly on freedom of movement and connection.
What you’ll need Count the controllers you already have and check whether your chosen console needs any additional charging or connection equipment. I want to check in advance what I’ll need to play with my existing controllers and the new one, so I don’t put together a set with unnecessary extras. Around 20% of consumers focus mainly on the complete co-op setup they need.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming a pair of Joy-Cons automatically counts as two full controllers

    Whether one Joy-Con per player works depends on the play style supported by the specific game. Nintendo explains that this varies from game to game.

    Check the controller requirements for the adventure you want to play together before counting the set as two player positions.

  • Treating Joy-Con and Joy-Con 2 as interchangeable

    Nintendo says Joy-Con 2 only works with Switch 2. Original Joy-Cons can be used wirelessly with Switch 2, but can’t be attached to the console for charging.

    Check your console generation and how you plan to charge the controllers before choosing a set.

  • Overlooking the setup and features of a wired Switch controller

    PowerA lists a detachable 3 m cable for the Wired Controller reviewed here, and says it can be used while the Switch is docked. According to PowerA, it doesn’t include motion controls, HD Rumble, NFC or a C Button.

    Check which features your game needs and whether the cable will reach from the docked console to your seats.

Relevant brands

Nintendo

Joy-Con and Joy-Con 2 are relevant options for supported Switch and Switch 2 games.

  • Nintendo explains that using Joy-Cons individually depends on the game.
  • Joy-Con 2 doesn’t work with the original Switch. Original Joy-Cons work with Switch 2 wirelessly only, so check how you can charge them.

Sony PlayStation

DualSense is an option as an extra controller for PS5 and can also connect to supported PC devices.

  • Sony lists connection to a PC via USB-C or Bluetooth.
  • The benefits of haptic feedback and adaptive triggers depend on support from the game. Also check whether the PC game supports local multiplayer.

Xbox

The Xbox Wireless Controller is suitable for Xbox consoles and Windows PCs.

  • Microsoft lists Xbox Wireless, Bluetooth and the option to remap buttons.
  • Xbox Support says Bluetooth reliability on a PC also depends on the Bluetooth adapter.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2 Bluetooth and Ultimate 2C Wireless are models designed for different platform combinations.

  • 8BitDo lists Switch and Windows support for the Ultimate 2 Bluetooth; according to the brand, Switch 2 support is available after a firmware update.
  • According to 8BitDo, the differently named Ultimate 2C Wireless supports Windows and Android. Check the full model name and connection type for your devices.

PowerA

The Wired Controller reviewed here is a wired option for a docked Switch.

  • PowerA lists a detachable 3 m cable and Switch 2 compatibility for this model.
  • According to PowerA, the controller can only be used when the Switch is docked. It doesn’t include motion controls, HD Rumble, NFC or a C Button.

Joybuy product picks

These Joybuy product picks are intended as extra controllers for Xbox, Windows PC, PS5 and Nintendo Switch or Switch 2 setups. For each game, check how many local players it supports and which controller layout is required.

Xbox Wireless Controller, Ice Breaker Special Edition, for Xbox Series and PC

Xbox Wireless Controller, Ice Breaker Special Edition (Xbox Series/PC)

An option if you’re looking for an extra controller for Xbox or a Windows PC. Check whether your chosen game supports local co-op.

The product description lists Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows PC.

Listed connections: Xbox Wireless and Bluetooth. According to the description, two AA batteries are included.

Joybuy
PlayStation 5 DualSense controller in Starlight Blue

PlayStation 5 DualSense Controller, Starlight Blue

A good fit if you’re looking for an extra DualSense for PS5. The game determines whether local multiplayer and the features you want are supported.

The product description lists PS5 compatibility, Bluetooth, haptic feedback and adaptive triggers. Sony also describes connecting to a PC via USB-C or Bluetooth; check support for each PC game.

Joybuy
Nintendo Switch Joy-Con pair in Neon Purple and Neon Orange

Nintendo Switch Joy-Con pair, Neon Purple/Neon Orange

Can provide two player positions if your Switch game supports using Joy-Cons individually.

The product description lists individual use, motion sensors, HD Rumble and a wireless connection. Nintendo says the suitable play style varies by game.

Joybuy
Nintendo Switch Pro Controller in black

Nintendo Switch Pro Controller, black

An extra controller option for Nintendo Switch. Check your game’s local multiplayer and controller requirements.

The product description lists a wireless connection, motion controls and HD Rumble.

Joybuy
Nintendo Switch 2 Joy-Con 2 pair in Light Blue and Light Red

Nintendo Switch 2 Joy-Con 2 pair, Light Blue/Light Red

An option for an extra player position or set on Switch 2, provided the game supports the chosen Joy-Con layout.

Nintendo says Joy-Con 2 only works with Switch 2. The product description lists a left and right controller, motion controls, HD Rumble 2 and wireless use.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is one Joy-Con per housemate enough?

Only if the specific game supports using Joy-Cons individually, held horizontally. Nintendo says the available player positions vary by game, so check your game’s requirements.

Do original Joy-Cons work with Switch 2?

Yes. Nintendo says original Joy-Cons can be used wirelessly with Switch 2. You can’t attach them to Switch 2 to charge them; Nintendo recommends using an original Switch or a suitable licensed charging accessory. Joy-Con 2 doesn’t work with the original Switch.

How do I connect a DualSense to a PC?

Sony describes connecting via a USB-C cable or Bluetooth. Also check whether your chosen PC game supports multiple controllers and local players.

Can I return a controller bought online if it isn’t right for our setup?

For online purchases, ACM ConsuWijzer generally refers to a statutory cooling-off period of up to 14 days after delivery. Before returning an item, check which terms and exceptions apply to your purchase.

What can I do if a controller doesn’t work properly under normal use?

According to the Dutch government, you can contact the seller to find a solution. The Netherlands doesn’t have a fixed statutory two-year guarantee period; what you can expect from a product depends, among other things, on the product itself and the information you were given when you bought it.