For regular transfers of film files, an external SSD is generally the better choice. An HDD may suit you if you mainly need plenty of archive space and don't mind longer copy times. Choose a capacity and connection that work with your files and computers, and don't rely on either drive as your only backup.
Who is this choice relevant to?
Editing team with frequent transfers
If you regularly move large video files between computers or work directly from external storage, check the connection on both the SSD and the computer. ID.nl discusses SSDs as an option for frequent copying and working from external storage.
Film archive manager
If you want to keep source footage and different versions, capacity, separate copies and recovery tests may matter more than the speed of everyday transfers. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends making and testing backups.
Production team sharing equipment
If you exchange files between, for example, Mac and Windows computers and want to manage access to recordings carefully, check the file system and connection for the computers you use. Privacy rules may also apply if people can be identified in the footage.
What should you look for when choosing?
Start by deciding whether you’ll be transferring files frequently or keeping lots of versions. Whatever type of drive you choose, plan separate, verifiable backups too.
| What to consider |
What to look for when buying |
Who should pay particular attention? |
| Transfer time |
Check the USB specification of both the drive and the computer. Maximum advertised speeds don’t guarantee how quickly a film file will copy. |
As an editing team, we want to move large files frequently without unnecessary delays. Around 28% of consumers put transfer time first. |
| Space for recordings and versions |
Add up the size of the source footage and the versions you want to keep, then check the capacity of the exact model. |
For a film archive, we want enough room for recordings and earlier versions, even if copying takes longer. Around 22% of consumers choose with archive space in mind. |
| Recoverable backup |
Decide which copies will be stored on separate media or in different locations, and plan a test by opening or restoring files. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends the 3-2-1 approach; this is backup advice, not a product specification. |
If I want to be able to recover the project after data loss, I look beyond a single extra drive. Around 22% of consumers prioritise recoverability. |
| Sharing files between computers |
Check the operating systems and ports. Apple lists exFAT as a Windows-compatible option for data drives larger than 32 GB that are also used with a Mac. Formatting erases files. |
When using shared work computers, we want to exchange files without running into problems with the wrong connection or file system. Around 17% of consumers put compatibility first. |
| Transport and controlled access |
Check the protection offered by the exact model. If an organisation films identifiable people, also assess the applicable legal basis and security measures; the Dutch Data Protection Authority highlights the GDPR in this context. |
If the drive is often taken on the go or recordings show identifiable people, we want to handle transport and access carefully. Around 11% of consumers consider this the most important factor. |
Common pitfalls
-
Assuming your working drive is a complete backup
If the original and its only copy are lost at the same time, or a copy won’t open, a single external drive won’t help you recover your files. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends backing up important data using the 3-2-1 approach.
Before buying, decide what role each drive will play in your backup plan and test that you can restore important files.
-
Assuming the maximum MB/s figure is the speed of every film file transfer
The computer’s connection and other parts of the transfer process can limit the actual speed. A higher maximum speed doesn’t necessarily make a noticeable difference with every copy.
Check the connections at both ends and, where possible, compare test results for large files rather than relying only on manufacturers’ maximum figures.
-
Formatting a shared drive without securing your files first
Formatting erases the files on the drive. This could delete film and project files that haven’t been saved elsewhere.
First check which computers need to use the drive, and make a copy elsewhere before changing the file system.
Brands to consider
Samsung
The T7 Shield and T9 are portable SSD ranges with different connections and advertised speeds.
- Samsung lists maximum speeds of 1.050/1.000 MB/s, an IP65 rating and drop resistance up to 3 metres for the T7 Shield 2 TB. For the T9 2 TB, Samsung lists speeds of up to 2.000 MB/s via USB 3.2 Gen 2x2.
- These are model specifications and manufacturer claims, not guaranteed speeds or protection with every transfer. To achieve the stated Gen 2x2 speed, you’ll need a compatible host connection.
Seagate
The Expansion Portable range includes portable HDDs for storage and archiving.
- Seagate lists models in the range with capacities of up to 5 TB; the 5 TB model reviewed comes with a USB 3.0 Type-A cable.
- Check the capacity and connection of the exact model. A large storage capacity doesn’t tell you how quickly files will transfer.
Kingston
The XS1000 is a compact external SSD range available in 1 TB and 2 TB models.
- Kingston lists speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s for reading and 1.000 MB/s for writing, and specifies a USB-C connection on the drive, with a USB-A host cable and adapter.
- These are manufacturer claims. Check that the exact capacity and connections suit the computers you plan to use the drive with.
Crucial
The X9 Pro is a portable SSD range for files and backups.
- For the X9 Pro, Crucial lists read and write speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s and says it comes formatted as exFAT.
- Crucial notes that measured maximum speeds may vary by system. Reformatting erases data on the drive.
Joybuy products for file transfers
This selection features portable external SSDs for regular file transfers and extra storage. Choose a capacity and connection to suit the files and computers you use.
No image available
SanDisk Portable SSD 1 TB
A portable SSD to take with you regularly and use as an extra storage copy; one drive is not a complete backup plan.
View at Joybuy
No image available
SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1 TB
For large files and frequent transfers, provided your computer supports the connection.
The product information lists read speeds of up to 2.000 MB/s via USB 3.2 Gen 2x2. Your host device must be compatible, and actual transfer speeds may vary.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Portable SSD 1 TB, 1.000 MB/s
The product information lists large creative files and use across multiple systems as potential applications.
USB 3.2 Gen 2 and read speeds of up to 1.000 MB/s are listed; check that the connection is compatible with your computer.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Samsung Portable SSD T7 2 TB USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2 Blue
A 2 TB portable SSD for storing and transferring large files. The product information lists USB-C-to-C and USB-C-to-A cables and compatibility with Windows and macOS.
Advertised read and write speeds are up to 1.050/1.000 MB/s. Actual speeds also depend on the host connection.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Samsung Portable SSD T7 1 TB USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2 Blue
A 1 TB portable SSD for file transfers and extra storage. The product information lists USB-C-to-C and USB-C-to-A cables and compatibility with Windows and macOS.
Advertised read and write speeds are up to 1.050/1.000 MB/s; your computer must support the connection to achieve the intended performance.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is one external drive enough to back up a theatre production?
No, not as your only recovery option. For important data, the National Cyber Security Centre recommends the 3-2-1 approach: keep the original and two backups on different media, with one copy stored elsewhere. This is security advice, not a general legal requirement when buying a drive.
How can you check that a backup will work?
Open relevant film and project files from the backup and, if necessary, test that you can restore them. The National Cyber Security Centre lists opening files as a way to check a backup. Agree who will carry out the test and when.
Which file system works for a drive used with both Mac and Windows?
Apple lists exFAT as a Windows-compatible file system for a data drive larger than 32 GB that is also used with a Mac. Formatting erases files, so first make a copy elsewhere and check the requirements of your recording or editing equipment too.
What should you consider when it comes to costs and included accessories?
Compare the current cost of all the storage you need, including separate backup copies, and check which cables are included with each model. A warranty is no substitute for a copy that lets you recover your files.
Do Dutch privacy rules apply to recordings of identifiable people?
If an organisation films identifiable people at an event, the Dutch Data Protection Authority says it must take the GDPR into account, including having a legal basis and appropriate security measures for personal data. The right legal basis and measures depend on the specific production and processing; a limited exception may apply to private use. This does not mean that a particular SSD model or encryption feature is automatically required by law.