Student who works from the drive
You regularly open or edit a music project from external storage and want quick access to sessions and audio files. ID.nl recommends an SSD if you often copy files or work directly from the drive.
If you regularly work directly from the drive or often move music projects between computers, an external SSD is usually the better choice. An HDD may be enough for projects you mainly want to store or keep as a separate copy. Check the storage capacity, connections and file system on both your school computer and your home computer. And keep a separate backup: one external drive containing your only copy of a project is not a backup.
You regularly open or edit a music project from external storage and want quick access to sessions and audio files. ID.nl recommends an SSD if you often copy files or work directly from the drive.
You want to keep recordings and finished versions safe, even if your laptop or working drive fails. Consumentenbond recommends keeping a separate copy to reduce the risk of losing data if something goes wrong with a computer or laptop.
You take projects between, for example, home and school. Check not only the connections and file system, but also whether your music software can still find the audio files after you move them. Apple Support points out that project links to files may continue to refer to their original location.
First decide whether you’ll mainly use the drive for working, backups or storage. Then choose a capacity and connections suited to the computers and projects you actually use.
| What to consider | What should you check? | Who is this most important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Working directly from the drive | Check whether you regularly open files directly from the drive and which USB port your computer has. A quoted maximum speed is no guarantee of the speed you’ll get on your computer. | If I often open and move sessions or audio files, I want a drive that suits the job. Around 33% of consumers say working directly from the drive is their main requirement. |
| Separate backup | Allow space for an extra copy and check that you can open it. Disconnect a drive used only for backups once you’ve finished copying. | I want to be able to restore sessions and recordings if something happens to my working copy. Around 27% of consumers prioritise keeping a separate project copy. |
| Sharing between computers | Check the ports, supplied cable or adapter, and file system on both computers. Also test whether your music software can find the audio files in the copied project. | If I work on the same project at home and at school, it needs to work on both computers. For around 20% of consumers, sharing between computers is the main requirement. |
| Storage capacity | Add up the existing project folders and versions you want to keep, then compare the total with the capacity of the exact model. | I want room for existing and future project versions, rather than choosing on speed alone. Around 20% of consumers give storage capacity top priority. |
An SSD is the more suitable choice if you regularly work directly from the drive or often transfer files. A portable HDD may suit projects you mainly store or keep as a separate copy. Consumentenbond explains the importance of having a backup. It also warns that ransomware can affect an external drive if it stays connected.
Manufacturers’ quoted maximum read speeds depend on factors including the computer and connection. For example, Crucial quotes up to 1,050 MB/s for the X9 under its own test conditions. This is not a measurement of the speed you’ll get on your school computer.
If your project is only on that drive, you won’t have a separate copy if the drive or files become damaged. A connected drive can also be affected by ransomware.
Keep a second copy separately, check that you can open it and disconnect the backup drive after use.
Manufacturers quote speeds under specific test conditions. Your computer and USB connection affect how close you can get to those speeds.
Check your computer’s USB standard and treat the quoted speed as a maximum under the stated conditions.
Music software may keep links to audio files in their original location. As a result, a moved project folder may be missing files.
Gather the files used by the project according to your music software’s instructions, then open the copied version to test it.
If files can’t be found, you may need extra time to relink them.
Having the right plug doesn’t guarantee that both computers will support the file system. Some applications may also require you to reformat the drive.
Check which ports and file system you need at home and at school. Make a copy before reformatting a drive.
Depending on your computers, you may need an extra cable or adapter.
The X9 is a compact external SSD for taking project files with you regularly. The model reviewed, CT1000X9SSD9, has 1 TB of storage.
The XS1000 range may be worth considering if you use computers with USB-A and USB-C ports.
WD Elements Portable is a range of portable HDDs for storage or keeping a separate copy. The model reviewed, WDBU6Y0020BBK-WESN, has 2 TB of storage.
Expansion Portable is a range of portable HDDs for files you don’t use constantly as working files.
The Portable SSD T7 range may be suitable for active use. The specification consulted relates to the US 1 TB model MU-PC1T0T/AM.
The products below are portable SSDs for taking music projects with you and working on them. For each model, check that the storage capacity, connection and supplied cables suit the computers you use.
Image unavailable
May suit taking project files with you and transferring them regularly.
1 TB; USB 3.2 Gen 2; quoted read speed of up to 1,000 MB/s. A USB-C-to-USB-A adapter may be needed for a USB-A port.
Image unavailable
A portable SSD option for taking project files with you. Check that the USB-C connection suits your computers.
1 TB; USB-C; USB 3.2 Gen 2x2. The product information quotes read speeds of up to 2,000 MB/s and write speeds of up to 1,800 MB/s. These are product specifications, not measurements from your computer. A suitable adapter is needed for USB-A.
Image unavailable
May suit you if you’re looking for a portable SSD for project work and extra storage.
2 TB; USB 3.2 Gen 2; quoted speeds of up to 1,050 MB/s read and 1,000 MB/s write. The product information lists USB-C-to-C and USB-C-to-A cables.
Image unavailable
May suit taking music projects with you and opening or moving them regularly.
1 TB; USB 3.2 Gen 2; quoted speeds of up to 1,050 MB/s read and 1,000 MB/s write. The product information lists AES 256-bit encryption and USB-C-to-C and USB-C-to-A cables.
Image unavailable
May suit you if you want to take several projects or versions with you and need 2 TB of storage.
USB 3.2 Gen 2x2; the product information lists hardware encryption and read speeds of up to 2,000 MB/s. USB-C-to-C and USB-C-to-A cables are listed. The quoted speed is not a measurement from your computer.
Yes, if your computer, drive and music software support it. An SSD is generally a better choice than an HDD for regular work directly from the drive. Check the connection and test that the whole project opens, including its associated audio files.
No, one copy is not a separate backup. Keep an extra copy and check that you can open it. Disconnect a drive used only for backups once you’ve finished copying.
Apple lists ExFAT as a file system that’s compatible with Windows on a Mac. Check which file system your school computer accepts, and keep a copy first. Don’t reformat a drive without preparation if it contains your only version of a project.
According to the Dutch Government, you’re entitled to a product that’s fit for purpose in the Netherlands. There’s no fixed statutory warranty period, and the seller must provide a solution if something goes wrong. For many purchases made online from a business, you have a 14-day cooling-off period. Keep your project copy separately: a warranty on the device is no substitute for a backup.