Who is this advice for?

Choir archive manager

Wants to be able to find original takes and later versions, and restore files from a separate copy. VeiligInternetten explains that a backup is a copy of files.

Frequent file transfer user

Often moves recording sessions between the recording computer and a computer used for editing or sharing. The connection and the time needed to transfer large files both matter.

Manager of a growing recording collection

Stores multiple sessions, exports and project versions, and wants to estimate in advance how much storage space the archive will need.

What should you consider when choosing?

First decide whether recoverability, transfer time, archive space, compatibility or access security matters most for your choir recordings.

Consideration What should you check? Who is this important for?
An archive you can restore Check that original recordings, project files and exports are stored in a separate copy. Regularly open or restore a file from that copy. If I want to be able to find a take when one device fails, a separate copy is my top priority. Around 31% of consumers in this choir-recording scenario put recoverability first.
Time spent on frequent copying Check the ports and cables on both computers. Treat stated model speeds as maximums, not as guaranteed transfer speeds for your files. Anyone who often moves sessions between computers will want to give transfer time as much consideration as possible. Around 25% of consumers make transfer speed their top priority.
Space for multiple takes Count the folders and versions you want to keep, then compare the total with the capacity of the exact model. If my collection contains multiple takes and exports, I want enough space to store them together. Around 19% of consumers put archive capacity first.
Using the drive with your computers Check which USB-A and USB-C ports, cables and operating systems you have. Also check that the file system is suitable for the sharing or backup function you want. Anyone who wants to open recordings on different computers will benefit from a connection and file system that work with those devices. Around 13% of consumers put compatibility first.
Access to identifiable recordings Decide who should be able to open the files and what level of security suits the way you use them. If the drive has a password feature, check how to set it up; don’t assume it is activated automatically. If identifiable choir members can be heard in the recordings, restricting access may be my main concern. Around 12% of consumers give access security the highest priority.

Common pitfalls

  • Thinking an external drive is a complete backup

    If the only copy of a take is on that drive, it won’t protect you if the drive itself is lost or fails.

    Keep a separate copy and regularly try restoring a file from it.

    A separate copy requires extra storage space and time for recovery checks.

  • Confusing the stated speed with the actual transfer speed

    A maximum sequential SSD speed or USB interface specification doesn’t tell you how quickly your entire folder will transfer. Seagate states that a USB 3.0 port is required for transfer over that interface.

    Compare the whole setup—drive, cable, port and source computer—instead of relying on a single speed figure.

  • Reformatting a drive before securing your files

    Apple warns that reformatting a drive for Time Machine can permanently erase existing data.

    Copy any files you want to keep to another location before changing the file system.

  • Confusing impact protection with access security

    Protection against physical damage, a restorable copy and protection against unauthorised access are three different things.

    Consider these needs separately, especially if people in the recordings are identifiable.

Brands to compare

Samsung

The T7 and T7 Shield ranges include portable SSD models worth comparing for frequent copying.

  • For the blue T7 Shield 1 TB, MU-PE1T0R/EU, Samsung lists USB 3.2 Gen 2, maximum sequential read and write speeds of 1.050 and 1.000 MB/s, and IP65 and drop-resistance claims.
  • These are Samsung’s specifications and claims for that model, not measured copy speeds for choir files or a guarantee that files can be recovered. Check that the model and connection are suitable for your computers.

Western Digital

WD Elements Portable USB-C is a portable HDD range to consider if capacity and a USB-C connection are important.

  • The manufacturer lists a 4 TB model, USB 3.2 Gen 1, a USB-C to USB-C cable included in the box, and exFAT as the supplied file system.
  • The usable capacity may be lower, and compatibility depends on your system configuration. The USB interface specification is not a measured HDD write speed.

Seagate

Expansion Portable is a portable HDD range that includes a 2 TB model for storage and file transfers.

  • According to Seagate, the drive is powered via USB; a USB 3.0 port is required for transfers over USB 3.0.
  • Check the model you choose and where you plan to use it. Reformatting may be needed for Time Machine, and Seagate’s data recovery service is not available in every country.

LaCie

Rugged Mini is an HDD range worth comparing if you regularly take the drive between recording locations.

  • Seagate describes the Rugged Mini range as offering protection against knocks and drops, with transfer speeds of up to 130 MB/s.
  • These are manufacturer claims; they don’t prove that a damaged recording can be recovered. Check the exact model and the cable supplied.

Joybuy products for choir recordings

These product picks focus on portable external SSDs for frequent transfers and HDDs for storing a larger archive.

SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB

SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB

A portable SSD option for consumers who want to transfer recordings regularly.

SSD storage; capacity: 1 TB.

View at Joybuy
Portable SSD 1TB 1000MB/s

Portable SSD 1TB 1000MB/s

A portable SSD option for consumers who regularly transfer large files.

Capacity: 1 TB; the product name lists 1.000 MB/s.

View at Joybuy
Samsung Portable SSD T7 2TB USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2 Blue

Samsung Portable SSD T7 2TB USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2 (3.1 Gen 2) Blue

A portable SSD option for consumers who want to transfer session files and carry an archive copy with them.

Capacity: 2 TB; USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2 (3.1 Gen 2).

View at Joybuy
My Passport for Mac 2TB Blue Portable Hard Drive

My Passport for Mac 2TB Blue Portable Hard Drive

A portable HDD option for consumers who prioritise storage space for an archive.

Capacity: 2 TB; Mac version.

View at Joybuy
My Passport USB-C 5TB Black

My Passport USB-C 5TB Black

A portable HDD option for consumers looking for space for a growing recording collection.

Capacity: 5 TB; USB-C.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I delete the recordings from my computer once they’re on the external drive?

Don’t delete the source files until you’ve made a separate copy and checked that you can open or restore a recording from it. Using an external drive as your only storage location won’t protect you if that drive is lost or fails.

Can the same drive be used for file sharing and Time Machine?

A file system for sharing files isn’t automatically suitable as a Time Machine destination. Apple recommends APFS or APFS Encrypted for a new Time Machine drive and warns that reformatting can erase existing data. So decide in advance what you’ll use the drive for, and secure your files before changing the file system.

What can you do if the drive fails, and is a manufacturer’s warranty the same as your statutory rights?

No. According to the Government of the Netherlands, a manufacturer’s warranty is in addition to your statutory rights. If a product is faulty, the retailer is your point of contact; there is no single fixed statutory warranty period for all products in the Netherlands.

Can the choir keep or share recordings in which people are identifiable?

An audio recording in which someone is identifiable may be personal data, according to the Dutch Data Protection Authority. If the choir processes personal data, it must decide on appropriate security measures. Whether a particular recording can be shared or published depends on its purpose, the people involved and the applicable legal basis; copyright-protected work cannot simply be distributed without permission either.