Choir archive manager
You want to be able to find and restore original takes and project files. Check how much space the files need, and keep a separate backup too.
First, work out how much space your original files and planned new recordings will need. Then check that the SSD and cable are compatible with the computers the choir will use to access the files. A portable or physically rugged drive can be useful when you’re travelling, but it won’t replace a separate backup. Manufacturer speed figures are maximums; the host device and connection also affect performance.
You want to be able to find and restore original takes and project files. Check how much space the files need, and keep a separate backup too.
You transfer source files between recording and editing computers. Check which USB ports are available and whether the cable is compatible. A stated maximum speed doesn’t, by itself, tell you how quickly a transfer will finish.
You take files to rehearsal or editing locations. A manufacturer may specify protection against dust, water or drops, but physical protection is not a backup.
Start by working out how much space all the files you want to keep will need. Then check the connection and plan to keep a separate copy.
| What to consider | What to look for when buying | Who this matters to |
|---|---|---|
| Restorable archive copy | Keep the source files in a separate storage location too, and try restoring files from it. | If I want to be able to restore the original take if one drive fails, I also keep a separate copy. Around 36% of consumers prioritise being able to restore recordings. |
| Space for new takes | Check the size of the project folder and decide which versions to keep. Allow for usable capacity and future recordings. | When I want to keep both source files and future choir recordings, I base my capacity choice on the whole project folder. Around 29% of consumers prioritise storage space for current and future files. |
| Sharing files between computers | Check the USB ports, included cable and host specifications. Test that the files open on the devices you need to use. | If I need to transfer files between recording and editing computers, I want to be sure the connection works with both. Around 21% of consumers prioritise sharing files between computers. |
| Transport and access | Check the protection specified by the manufacturer for the particular model, and decide who should be able to access the recording files. | When I take the drive between locations and want to restrict access to recordings, I look at physical protection and access controls. Around 14% of consumers prioritise safe transport and restricted access. |
A fast or rugged drive won’t stop your only copy from being lost or damaged.
Keep the original files in a separate storage location too, and check that you can open them from there.
A separate copy requires extra storage space and time for regular recovery checks.
Actual speeds also depend on the host device, hardware, software and how you use it. For example, Kingston says a USB 3.2 Gen 2 host is needed for optimal XS1000 speeds.
Check the host port and cable before factoring in a speed rating, and don’t treat the stated maximum as a guarantee for transferring a whole session.
The original recordings and any project files may also need to be part of your archive. If you don’t account for them, you may need extra storage later.
Check the size of the whole project folder and decide which versions and future takes you want to keep before choosing a capacity.
ACM ConsuWijzer explains that the statutory guarantee covers a product that, under normal use, doesn’t do what the consumer is entitled to expect. It won’t preserve your choir files.
Consider the service terms and your plan for a separate backup independently.
The T7 Shield range is worth considering if you’ll be taking the drive between locations. The product specifications below are for the black 1TB version, MU-PE1T0S/EU.
The XS1000 range is worth a look if you share files between devices with USB-A and USB-C connections. Kingston offers 1 TB and 2 TB versions.
The ESD310 range is worth considering if built-in USB-A and USB-C connections are important to you and you’d rather not use a separate cable. The range includes 1 TB and 2 TB versions, among others.
These Joybuy products are portable external SSDs for local storage of choir files and, depending on the model, sharing files between computers or taking them between locations. You’ll still need a separate backup to make sure your files can be restored.
No image available
A good fit if you’re looking for a portable 1 TB SSD for local choir files.
Capacity: 1 TB.
Keep a separate copy too, so you can restore your files if needed.
No image available
A good fit if you’re looking for local storage and want to factor the stated speed into your comparison.
Capacity: 1 TB. The product name states 1,000 MB/s.
Check that the connection is compatible with the computers you use, and keep a separate backup too.
No image available
A good fit if your measured archive folder needs more space than a 1 TB version offers.
Capacity: 2 TB. Connection according to the product name: USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2 (3.1 Gen 2).
Check that the connection works with the choir’s computers, and keep important files in a separate storage location too.
No image available
A good fit if you’re looking for a 1 TB Samsung T7 for local storage of source files.
Capacity: 1 TB. Connection according to the product name: USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2 (3.1 Gen 2).
Check that the connection works with the computers you need to use, and keep a separate backup too.
No image available
A good fit if you’re taking a 1 TB drive with you and value the physical protection specified by Samsung.
For the black 1 TB version, MU-PE1T0S/EU, Samsung specifies IP65, drop resistance from heights of up to 3 metres, and speeds of up to 1,050 MB/s read and 1,000 MB/s write. IP65 doesn’t protect against immersion.
Physical protection isn’t a backup; keep a separate copy of your recordings too.
Not if you want to be able to restore it: keep a separate copy as well as the SSD, and try restoring files from it. Seagate’s 3-2-1 approach is backup advice, not a legal minimum requirement for a choir.
Not necessarily for copying files, but check that the drive is recognised by the computers you need to use. If you want to use the password feature on the Samsung T7 Shield, check Samsung’s software information and test unlocking the drive on the computers that need access.
You can’t tell from the SSD specifications alone. Kingston says a USB 3.2 Gen 2 host is needed for optimal XS1000 speeds, and notes that speeds can vary depending on hardware, software and use.
For a consumer purchase, the seller is responsible if a product, under normal use, doesn’t do what the consumer is entitled to expect; this is the statutory guarantee. Online consumer purchases usually come with a 14-day cooling-off period after delivery, subject to applicable exceptions. Check separately which rules apply if the choir is buying as an organisation.
A sound recording in which someone can be identified may count as personal data. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says organisations must protect personal data properly; processing it requires an applicable lawful basis under the GDPR. Consent is one possible lawful basis, but it isn’t automatically the only one or the right one in every situation. The specific arrangements for this recording and any sharing require separate consideration.