Manager of a growing data archive
If you mainly store large project folders and don’t edit them constantly, capacity and a backup setup that lets you restore your files are important considerations.
For a large archive that you rarely edit, an external HDD is a sensible choice. If you regularly copy files and take your drive to field locations, a portable SSD is a better fit. Then compare the capacity with the size and growth of your project folders, check the connections and formatting for your computers, and arrange separate backups: one external drive is not a complete backup strategy.
If you mainly store large project folders and don’t edit them constantly, capacity and a backup setup that lets you restore your files are important considerations.
If you regularly take your working drive with you and copy large files, consider transfer speeds, connections and how well the casing is protected.
If you share project folders between Windows and macOS, check the formatting and connections on the computers you use before transferring files.
Best for: a large archive of project folders that you access relatively infrequently.
Trade-off: Western Digital says HDDs generally offer a lower cost per GB than SSDs. Their moving parts make them less suitable for frequent travel.
Best for: regularly copying large files or taking your working drive to field locations.
Trade-off: the stated maximum speed also depends on your computer and connection. According to Western Digital, SSDs generally offer less capacity per GB for your money than HDDs.
| Consideration | What to look for | Who it matters to |
|---|---|---|
| Archive capacity | Compare your current dataset and expected growth with the capacity of the exact model you’re considering. Remember to allow for separate versions, too. | If you’re storing new rounds of measurements and large project folders, you’ll want enough room for your growing archive. Around 33% of consumers say capacity is their top priority. |
| Restorable backups | Plan storage for separate copies and test whether you can actually restore a project folder. The NCSC recommends keeping the original files and two backups for important business data. | If you don’t want to lose research files if your working drive fails or goes missing, you’ll need copies that you can restore. Around 27% of consumers prioritise recoverability. |
| Fieldwork | Check your computer’s USB port and cable, and look at the specifications for the exact model. Samsung’s stated maximum sequential speeds for the T7 Shield aren’t guaranteed for every computer or project folder. | If you take your drive with you and regularly transfer large files, the connection, speed and casing all matter. Around 20% of consumers choose with mobile working in mind. |
| Windows and macOS | Check the file system and connections on both computers. Toshiba lists NTFS for the Canvio Basics models mentioned here; Apple warns that reformatting erases files. | If you share project folders between Windows and Mac computers, you’ll want to know in advance whether reformatting is needed. Around 20% of consumers prioritise use across different systems. |
If the only drive holding a separate copy fails or goes missing, you won’t have another copy to restore from. The NCSC recommends keeping the original files and two backups for important business data.
Plan copies on another type of media or in another location, and test that you can restore your project folders.
A backup plan requires storage for extra copies and time to carry out restore tests.
Manufacturers quote maximum sequential speeds. Samsung states that the T7 Shield reaches maximum speeds of 1.050/1.000 MB/s; the connection and computer also affect the speeds you’ll get in practice.
Check your computer’s port and cable, and don’t buy based only on the highest MB/s figure.
Apple warns that formatting erases the files on the selected volume. Toshiba says the Canvio Basics models mentioned here are formatted as NTFS and need to be reformatted for the listed macOS versions.
Decide in advance which file system you need and make a separate copy of your data first.
Before formatting, you’ll need enough space and time to make a separate copy and restore it afterwards.
The Canvio Basics is a range of portable HDDs for large project folders. Toshiba lists a 4 TB model with the model code HDTB440EK3CA.
The portable T7 Shield is an SSD range for active use. The Dutch model described here is the 2 TB version in black, MU-PE2T0S/EU.
The X9 Pro is a portable SSD option for active use. The model described here has the model code CT2000X9PROSSD9.
Worth considering when comparing HDD capacity for archives with SSDs for active use.
Seagate describes its external HDDs as suitable for storing large files and backups.
This selection of Joybuy products includes portable SSDs for working on the go and external HDDs for project archives, for both mobile use and a permanent workstation.
No image available
A portable SSD option for anyone who needs storage on the go.
1 TB storage; read speeds of up to 800 MB/s and drop protection up to 2 metres, according to the product description.
No image available
A portable HDD option for large project folders that you take between work locations.
5 TB storage; USB-C connection and USB 3.2 Gen 1, according to the product description. The portable model described weighs 240 g.
No image available
An HDD offering plenty of project storage for a fixed workstation.
6 TB storage, USB 3.0 and a mains adapter included, according to the product description. This is a desktop model with an external power supply.
No image available
A portable HDD option for project folders you want to take with you.
4 TB storage; the product description lists AES 256-bit hardware encryption and password protection.
No image available
An external drive for project files you want to use across computers.
1 TB storage; formatted as exFAT, with a USB-C connection and compatibility with Windows, macOS, Android and iOS, according to the product description.
No, not if that drive is the only separate copy. For important business data, the NCSC recommends the 3-2-1 approach: keep the original and two backups on different types of media, with one copy in another location. Decide how often you’ll make copies and test that you can restore your project folders.
It depends on the model and its formatting. Toshiba says the Canvio Basics models mentioned here are formatted as NTFS and need to be reformatted for the listed macOS versions. Apple recommends exFAT for a drive larger than 32 GB that you want to use with both Windows and Mac. Make a copy before formatting, as formatting erases files.
No. Samsung lists an IP65 rating for the T7 Shield casing, but this doesn’t replace separate copies that you can restore. Also check the usage conditions for the exact model.
If an organisation processes personal data, the GDPR requires appropriate security measures based on the risks of that processing, according to the Dutch Data Protection Authority. First establish whether the files contain personal data and which measures are appropriate following a risk assessment. This doesn’t mean that one specific type of external drive or one standard encryption method is required for every dataset.