Who is this choice relevant to?

Manager of a growing club archive

Needs space for large project folders and older versions. The Digital Trust Center points out that keeping a longer history requires more storage.

Volunteer responsible for backups

Wants to check that all the intended folders are copied and that files can be restored. Microsoft Support and the Digital Trust Center explain why folder selection and regular recovery tests matter.

Project worker who takes folders with them

Regularly moves large files between computers and needs to consider the connection. If the files contain personal data, appropriate security is also a consideration, according to the Dutch Data Protection Authority.

What should you consider when choosing?

Portable external HDD

A good fit if: you mainly want to store a large archive and older versions periodically.

Bear in mind: a USB rating doesn’t tell you the actual copying speed. Also check that the formatting is compatible with your computer. Toshiba states that the Canvio Basics uses NTFS and needs reformatting for macOS.

Portable external SSD

A good fit if: you often move large project folders between work locations and transfer time matters to you.

Bear in mind: Samsung and Crucial quote maximum speeds under specific conditions. Your port, cable and computer will affect whether those speeds apply to your connection.

What to consider What should you look for? Who should pay particular attention?
Space for folders and versions Measure the folders you want to keep and decide how many older versions you need. The Digital Trust Center notes that keeping files for longer requires more storage. If I’m keeping a growing club archive, I want enough space for the folders and older versions. Around 33% of consumers give space for archives and versions their highest priority.
Restorable backup Check which folders are selected and how often backups are made, and periodically restore a test file. Keep a copy somewhere else too; the Digital Trust Center advises against relying on a single storage location. If I’m responsible for backups, I want to know that the right files have been included and can be restored. Around 27% of consumers give verifiable recovery their highest priority.
Access to club data Establish whether the drive contains personal data and who needs access. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says that appropriate measures depend on the processing involved and the risks. If the drive contains personal data, I want to manage access properly without making recovery impossible for authorised volunteers. Around 20% of consumers give controlled access their highest priority.
Time needed for large transfers Check your computer’s port and cable, and whether quoted speeds are maximum figures under certain conditions. If I regularly move large folders between work locations, I want copying to be fast enough for my connection. Around 20% of consumers give transfer time their highest priority.

Pitfalls when choosing a backup drive

  • Using the external drive as your only backup

    If an incident also affects the place where the drive is kept, you could lose your backup. The Digital Trust Center advises against relying on a single storage location and recommends testing recovery.

    Keep a separate copy somewhere else and try restoring files before you need them.

  • Assuming every project folder is backed up automatically

    Microsoft Support says that File History uses libraries by default; folders in other locations need to be added to the selection.

    Check which folders you’ve selected and restore a test file from a location outside the default libraries.

  • Expecting maximum SSD speeds on every computer

    Crucial’s quoted X9 speed requires a suitable USB-C cable and a USB 3.2 Gen 2 host; your computer may have a different connection.

    Check your computer’s port and cable before taking maximum speeds into account when choosing.

  • Erasing a Windows-formatted drive without preparing first

    Toshiba states that the Canvio Basics reviewed needs reformatting for macOS. Apple warns that Time Machine may ask you to erase the selected drive during setup.

    Check your operating system and backup method beforehand, and make sure any files already on the drive are safe before formatting it.

Brands to compare

Western Digital

The WD Elements Portable range includes portable HDDs, including the 4 TB model WDBU6Y0040BBK-WESN identified by Western Digital.

  • Western Digital lists a 2-year warranty and 4 TB capacity for this model.
  • The additional warranty period mentioned by the manufacturer applies only to direct purchases from Western Digital. These are manufacturer specifications, not the result of an independent reliability test.

Seagate

The Expansion Portable range includes portable HDDs; Seagate identifies STKM4000400 as a 4 TB model.

  • According to its support information, Seagate offers diagnostic and backup tools.
  • The availability of tools doesn’t guarantee that a damaged drive can be recovered. Check which services are available for each model.

Toshiba

Canvio Basics includes a portable 4 TB HDD, model HDTB540EK3CA.

  • Toshiba says the drive is ready to use with Windows and comes preformatted as NTFS.
  • Toshiba states that the drive needs reformatting for macOS. Check your backup method and make sure any existing files are safe before erasing the drive.

Samsung

The Portable SSD T7 Shield is a range of portable SSDs; the model reviewed is the 2 TB MU-PE2T0S/EU.

  • Samsung specifies maximum read speeds of 1.050 MB/s and write speeds of 1.000 MB/s for this model, along with password protection using 256-bit AES hardware encryption.
  • These are Samsung’s specifications, not speeds measured on your club’s computers.

Crucial

The Crucial X9 is a portable SSD; the 2 TB model reviewed is CT2000X9SSD9.

  • Crucial says it supports Windows File History and Apple Time Machine.
  • Crucial specifies maximum read speeds of 1.050 MB/s and says that a suitable USB-C cable and USB 3.2 Gen 2 host are needed for the best speed. Compatibility may depend on formatting.

Joybuy backup products

This selection includes external HDDs with 4 TB or 6 TB of storage, a 6 TB desktop HDD and a 2 TB portable SSD. Compare capacity and connections, and consider whether you’ll often need to take the drive with you.

My Passport 6TB White portable hard drive

My Passport 6TB White

An option to compare if you need plenty of space for large project folders and older versions.

The product name lists 6 TB, password protection and automatic backup software.

View at Joybuy
My Passport 4TB Black portable hard drive

My Passport 4TB Black

A good fit if you’re looking for a portable HDD for project folders and versioned backups.

The product name lists 4 TB, password protection and automatic backup software.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 4TB USB-C Graphite Black

WD Elements Portable 4TB USB-C Graphite Black

A portable HDD to compare if you need archive space and sometimes want to take the drive with you.

The product name lists 4 TB and USB-C.

View at Joybuy
Samsung Portable SSD T7 2TB USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2 Blue

Samsung Portable SSD T7 2TB USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2 Blue

An SSD option to compare if you regularly move large files between work locations.

The product name lists 2 TB and USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Desktop 6TB USB 3.0 external hard drive

WD Elements Desktop 6TB USB 3.0

A desktop model to consider if you’ll mainly keep your backup in one place rather than taking the drive with you often.

The product name lists 6 TB and USB 3.0.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How do you work out how much storage your club needs?

Measure the folders that really need to be included in the backup, then decide how far back you need to be able to go if files are changed or deleted. Keeping files for longer requires more space, according to the Digital Trust Center. For a full Mac backup with Time Machine, Apple recommends at least twice the Mac’s storage capacity; this isn’t a general rule for individual project folders.

Does Windows File History automatically include project folders outside the default locations?

Check which folders are selected: Microsoft Support says File History copies libraries by default, and you can add folders from other locations. Then test whether you can restore a file from one of those folders.

Can an external drive set up for Windows be used as a Mac backup drive without any changes?

Not always. Toshiba lists the Canvio Basics as NTFS and says it needs reformatting for macOS. Apple warns that Time Machine may ask you to erase the selected drive during setup, so make sure any existing files are safe first.

How can you check that a backup is still usable?

Regularly check that a recent copy has been made and periodically restore a test file. The Digital Trust Center also advises against relying on a single storage location. Make a note of who connects the drive and who carries out the checks.

Should a club encrypt its data on an external drive?

If files contain personal data, the club needs to decide on appropriate security measures. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, the measures that are suitable depend on the processing involved and the risks; encryption isn’t automatically a blanket requirement for every external drive.