Who is this choice relevant to?

Photo editors with lots of versions

If you want to restore an earlier edit, you need more than just a drive: set up File History or Time Machine to include the right project folders.

Families with a growing photo archive

If you keep both originals and edited photos, you can work out the capacity you need based on your current collection, future photos and the number of versions you want to keep. Keep a separate copy too.

Photographers who take projects with them

If you move or edit files in different places, weigh up portability and connectivity against the archive space you need and the speed your computer supports.

What should you look for when choosing?

First, decide how you want to restore older versions and how much space you’ll need. Then choose between a drive for archiving and one you can take with you regularly.

External HDD

Best suited to: keeping a growing photo archive and multiple versions mainly at home.

Bear in mind: check the formatting and backup software for your computer; capacity alone won’t back up different versions.

Portable SSD

Best suited to: regularly taking project files with you, transferring them or editing them directly from the external drive.

Bear in mind: quoted maximum speeds depend on factors including your computer and cable; a rugged casing is no substitute for keeping a second copy.

What to consider What to look for Who is this important for?
Restoring earlier versions Check that the backup programme includes the right project folders, then try restoring an older version. If I want to restore an edit, I need to know that my project folder is included. Around 30% of consumers prioritise version recovery.
Space for your archive and future growth Compare the capacity with the size of your collection and the number of versions you want to keep. I want enough room for originals, edits and future photos. Around 30% of consumers prioritise archive space.
Loss and privacy Keep a separate copy; if you have sensitive files, check whether the model you choose offers password protection. I don’t want to rely on a single drive, and I may want to keep private photos secure. Around 20% of consumers prioritise keeping a separate copy and privacy.
Taking files with you and transferring them Check that the connection and cable are compatible with your devices; don’t assume a quoted maximum speed is what you’ll get in practice. When I use projects in different places, a suitable connection and quick transfers matter. Around 20% of consumers prioritise portability and file transfer.

Microsoft Support explains how to restore versions with File History, while Apple Support explains how to back up with Time Machine. Both require you to set up a backup; extra storage space alone isn’t enough.

Common pitfalls

  • Mistaking extra storage for version backup

    A drive won’t automatically keep earlier project files. The backup process you set up determines which versions you can restore.

    Check which photo folders are included and try restoring a test file after your first backup.

    Allow time to set up your backups and check regularly that they can be restored.

  • Keeping your only copy on one external drive

    If the drive is damaged, the photos on it could be lost too.

    Keep important files in a separate location as well, and check that both copies can be restored.

  • Assuming speed or Mac compatibility will take care of itself

    Actual speeds also depend on the connected equipment. Some backup setups require you to reformat a drive.

    Check the port, cable, file system and backup software before formatting a drive that already contains files.

Brands to consider

Western Digital

The My Passport range includes portable HDDs for photo archives; the model mentioned here has a capacity of 4 TB.

  • Western Digital lists password protection, hardware encryption and included backup software for the range.
  • Features and compatibility vary by model. If you use a Mac, check the formatting; security features are no substitute for keeping a separate copy.

Seagate

The Expansion Portable is a range of USB-powered HDDs; model STKM4000400 is the 4 TB version.

  • Seagate says this drive doesn’t need a separate power supply.
  • According to the specification sheet, you’ll need to reformat the drive to use Time Machine. Seagate says Rescue Data Recovery Services aren’t available in every country; check the terms that apply in the Netherlands.

Samsung

The T7 Shield 2 TB, model MU-PE2T0S/EU, is a portable SSD for taking projects with you or working directly from the drive.

  • Samsung Netherlands specifies maximum sequential read and write speeds of 1.050 and 1.000 MB/s, and lists an IP65 rating and drop resistance from up to 3 metres.
  • These are manufacturer claims, not a guarantee of the same speed on every computer or of data being preserved if the drive is damaged.

Crucial

The X9 Portable SSD 2 TB, CT2000X9SSD9, is a USB-C option for taking photo files with you and transferring them.

  • Crucial lists a maximum read speed of 1.050 MB/s and compatibility with Windows File History and Apple Time Machine.
  • Crucial says speed and compatibility depend on the computer, cable and formatting. Check these before you buy.

Joybuy products

This selection includes external HDDs for photo archives and a portable SSD for projects you regularly take with you or transfer.

WD My Passport for Mac 2TB Blue external hard drive

WD My Passport for Mac 2TB Blue

An option for a Mac photo archive if you want to use Time Machine; you’ll need to set up the backup to keep earlier versions.

2 TB; Time Machine Ready; password protection.

View at Joybuy
WD My Passport 6TB White portable hard drive

WD My Passport 6TB White

An option for storing a large or growing photo archive on a portable HDD; keep a separate copy as well.

6 TB; password protection; automatic backup software.

View at Joybuy
WD My Passport 4TB Black portable hard drive

WD My Passport 4TB Black

An option for a growing photo archive on a portable HDD; the drive alone won’t automatically keep earlier versions.

4 TB; password protection; automatic backup software.

View at Joybuy
Toshiba Canvio Ready 4TB external hard drive

Toshiba Canvio Ready 4TB

A portable HDD option for storing or transferring files; check that the connection is compatible with your equipment before you buy.

4 TB; 2.5 inch; Micro-USB B; USB 2.0/3.2 Gen 1 (3.1 Gen 1).

View at Joybuy
Samsung MU-PE2T0R 2TB Blue portable SSD

Samsung MU-PE2T0R 2TB USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2 Blue

A portable SSD option for projects you regularly take with you or transfer; check that your computer and cable are compatible with the connection.

2 TB; USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2.

The stated IP65 rating doesn’t mean the SSD can be submerged in water.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can any external drive automatically restore earlier photo edits?

No. On Windows, for example, set up File History and check that your project folder is included; on a Mac, you can configure a suitable external drive for Time Machine. Then try restoring an older version to make sure it works.

How large should a drive for Time Machine be?

Apple recommends a storage device with at least twice the storage capacity of your Mac. For a 1 TB Mac, that means at least 2 TB, according to Apple. Apple recommends using the Time Machine drive only for Time Machine backups; this isn’t a general minimum requirement for all photo backups.

Is one external drive enough to protect family photos?

Not as your only storage location: an external drive can also be damaged. VeiligInternetten advises against relying on a single storage location for important files. So keep a separate copy too, and check that you can restore your files from it.

What should you do before giving away an old external drive?

Erase your personal data first. The Consumentenbond recommends thoroughly erasing a hard drive before selling or disposing of it; then check which recycling option is available to you.