For a large archive copy that will mostly stay in one place, a portable HDD is often the better fit. If you regularly take project folders with you or work directly from the drive, an SSD makes more sense. First, check the total size of your folders, then check your computer’s connection, formatting and backup settings. Don’t keep an external drive as the only copy of irreplaceable photos.
Who is this guide for?
Managing a growing photo archive
You want to be able to copy and find large folders of scans, photos and project files. Capacity and a repeatable backup routine may matter more than maximum transfer speed. VeiligInternetten describes a backup as a separate copy of your files.
Editing photos and taking files with you
You move large project sessions between workstations or work directly from a portable drive. Transfer and access are important factors when choosing a drive, but portability doesn’t make it an extra backup. In 2022, the Consumentenbond discussed the differences between external HDDs and SSDs in Digitaalgids.
Managing a shared archive
You want to check which computers can use the copy and who has access to the images. If an organisation processes photos showing identifiable people, appropriate security measures are also relevant; the Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens treats identifiable people as personal data.
What should you look for in an external backup drive?
When it comes to large photo project folders, your choice depends on having enough space, being able to restore files and how you use them. First, decide which of these matters most to you.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Space for your archive |
Add up your current folders and planned projects. Check the capacity of the exact model and leave room if you want to keep earlier versions. |
I want my existing and expected project folders to fit without choosing far more space than I need. For around 25% of consumers, having enough archive space comes first. |
| Being able to restore files |
Copy files rather than simply moving them, set up regular backups and try restoring a file. VeiligInternetten points out that an external drive itself can be lost or damaged. |
I want to have a usable copy if one copy is lost or damaged. For around 25% of consumers, being able to restore files is the top priority. |
| Transfer and access |
Check the connections on your computer and drive. Treat stated speeds as product specifications, not as a guaranteed copy time for your folders. |
I often move or open large projects and want to know whether the connection will work with my computer. Transfer speed is the top priority for around 20% of consumers. |
| Connection and formatting |
Check the supplied cable and the file system of the exact model. Before formatting, decide whether you want to use standard file copies, Windows File History or Mac Time Machine. |
I want the drive and backup method to work with my computer without accidentally erasing existing data. Around 15% of consumers start with compatibility. |
| Access to images |
Decide who manages the photos and who can access them. The Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens advises organisations processing personal data to determine appropriate security measures. |
I want to limit unauthorised access to images, especially when they’re shared or used by an organisation. Access security comes first for around 15% of consumers. |
Common mistakes with photo archives
-
Moving files and calling it a backup
If the drive becomes the only place where your photos are stored, you no longer have a separate copy to fall back on. VeiligInternetten points out that external storage can also be damaged.
Keep the original files or another separate copy, and check that you can restore your files.
Otherwise, damage to or loss of that one drive could also affect your irreplaceable photos.
-
Assuming the stated top speed guarantees a particular copy time
An interface speed or maximum SSD specification doesn’t tell you how long it will take to copy your project folders. Crucial says the X9’s maximum read speed was measured under test conditions and may vary.
Check the ports and cables on your computer and drive. Don’t treat specifications as a real-world test using your own files.
-
Formatting without first securing existing files
Reformatting can erase data on the drive. Apple says that a Mac may ask you to erase the drive when setting up Time Machine.
First check which files are already on the drive and make a separate copy of them before changing the format.
Formatting can erase files already stored on the drive.
Brands to compare
The details below apply to the product ranges and models mentioned; they aren’t a judgement on every product from each brand.
Toshiba
The Canvio Ready is a portable HDD range. Toshiba lists a capacity of up to 4 TB for the EMEA model reviewed.
- Toshiba lists USB power, a shock sensor and a USB Type-A cable included in the box.
- The model reviewed is preformatted as NTFS; Toshiba says it needs reformatting for the macOS versions listed. The stated 5 Gbit/s is an interface specification, not a measured copy speed.
Seagate
Seagate lists portable Expansion Portable models with capacities of up to 5 TB for local file storage.
- Seagate highlights straightforward file copying and includes a USB 3.0 Type-A cable.
- Seagate says the drive needs reformatting for use with Time Machine. Check the capacity and model you choose.
Samsung
The Samsung T7 Shield MU-PE2T0S/EU is a 2 TB portable SSD for project files you move regularly.
- For this model, Samsung lists sequential speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s read and 1.000 MB/s write, as well as IP65 and drop resistance.
- These are manufacturer figures for this model under applicable conditions, not independent test results. These features don’t make the SSD a replacement for an extra copy.
Crucial
The Crucial X9 is a portable SSD; the manufacturer model listed here is the 2 TB CT2000X9SSD9.
- Crucial lists a maximum read speed of 1.050 MB/s for this model.
- Crucial says the speed was measured on a high-performance test computer and may vary. According to the manufacturer, the drive is supplied as exFAT; reformatting erases data on the drive.
SanDisk
The Extreme PRO Portable SSD SDSSDE81-2T00-G25 is the 2 TB model reviewed for the Netherlands.
- SanDisk lists a sequential read speed of up to 2.000 MB/s for this model.
- The manufacturer specifies that this speed requires USB 3.2 Gen 2x2. Check whether your computer supports this interface before relying on the top speed.
Joybuy products for photo and project files
These Joybuy products include portable HDDs for local archive copies and portable SSDs for project files you take with you more often.
No image available
WD My Passport USB-C 5TB
A portable HDD for a large local copy of your project folders.
Storage capacity: 5 TB. USB-C is included in the product name.
Joybuy
No image available
Western Digital My Passport USB-C 4TB, Black
A portable HDD for a local copy of large photo and project folders.
Storage capacity: 4 TB. USB-C is included in the product name.
Joybuy
No image available
WD Elements Portable 4TB USB-C, Graphite Black
A portable HDD for a large local copy of your photos and project files.
Storage capacity: 4 TB. USB-C is included in the product name.
Joybuy
No image available
Samsung Portable SSD T7 2TB USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2 (3.1 Gen 2), Blue
A portable SSD for project folders you regularly move between workstations.
Storage capacity: 2 TB. The product name lists USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2 (3.1 Gen 2).
Joybuy
No image available
Samsung Portable SSD T9 4 TB Black (MU-PG4T0B)
A portable SSD for large project folders you take with you regularly.
Storage capacity: 4 TB. Model: MU-PG4T0B.
Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is one external drive enough to back up irreplaceable historical photos?
No. Don’t make the external drive your only copy. VeiligInternetten describes external storage as something that can be lost or damaged. Keep the original files or another separate copy, and regularly check that you can restore your files.
How can I include large project folders in an automatic backup?
Check whether your chosen backup method includes your project folders. Microsoft Support explains that folders outside the default libraries can be added to an existing or new library for File History. On a Mac, Time Machine can use a connected external drive; Apple says the Mac may ask you to erase the drive during setup.
Do I need to reformat an external drive for my Mac?
It depends on the model and how you plan to use it. Toshiba says the Canvio Ready model reviewed is preformatted as NTFS and needs reformatting for the macOS versions listed. Seagate says the Expansion Portable model reviewed needs reformatting to work with Time Machine. Before formatting, make a separate copy of any files already on the drive.
What warranty applies when buying as a consumer in the Netherlands?
According to the Rijksoverheid, you’re entitled to a product that works properly and should contact the seller if there’s a problem. The Rijksoverheid says there is no fixed statutory two-year warranty period in the Netherlands; a manufacturer’s warranty is in addition to your consumer rights. A warranty on a drive doesn’t promise that lost photo files can be recovered.
Which privacy rules apply to photos of identifiable people?
According to the Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens, identifiable people in photos are personal data. The AP describes an exemption for personal or household use that remains private or is shared with a very limited group; this doesn’t automatically apply to wider distribution or business use. An organisation processing such images must decide on appropriate security measures based on the risks. The obligations that apply to a particular archive depend on how it is used.