Who is this choice relevant to?

Recording archive manager

Wants to find and restore meetings later. Choose the capacity based on the archive and expected growth, and arrange separate copies too. The National Cyber Security Centre stresses that occasionally copying files to a single external drive is not enough for a backup strategy.

Volunteer who takes recordings with them

Transfers files between locations or computers, so portability, connections and how often files are moved all matter. The Consumers’ Association describes SSDs as less susceptible to shock than HDDs. That makes an SSD an option worth considering, especially if you often take files with you.

Manager of confidential discussions

Needs to decide who can open identifiable recordings, how access is secured and how long the files are needed. The Dutch Data Protection Authority considers audio recordings in which someone is identifiable to be potential personal data.

What should you look for in an HDD or SSD?

Portable external HDD

Best for: a growing archive that is mainly kept in storage and moved only occasionally.

Bear in mind: handle it carefully when transporting it and keep a separate copy; an HDD is not a backup.

Portable external SSD

Best for: regularly taking large recordings with you or transferring them between computers.

Bear in mind: check the connections on the computers you use. A model’s stated speed is no guarantee of the speed you’ll get with your equipment.

Concern What to look for when buying Who is this important for?
Recoverability Keep separate copies, decide where the second backup will be stored and check that files can be restored. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends the 3-2-1 approach; it is advice, not a product specification. If I want to avoid making the archive unrecoverable through the loss or failure of a single drive, I’ll plan for copies and recovery checks. Around 31% of consumers prioritise recoverability.
Archive space Add up your existing files and allow for expected growth and how long you need to keep them. Don’t estimate a fixed number of recording hours per TB without knowing the recording format and bitrate. If I expect the number of recordings to grow, I want to match capacity to my files and retention needs. Around 25% of consumers prioritise archive space.
Confidentiality and access Decide who needs access and how administrators will manage it. Check which security features are available on the exact model and how access can be maintained if a password is lost. If the recordings include identifiable participants, I want to make sure carefully managed access is in place and decide how long they’re needed. Around 25% of consumers prioritise confidentiality.
Transferring between computers Check the USB ports, cables and operating systems on the computers used by your group. Toshiba states that the Canvio Basics examined uses NTFS for Windows and needs reformatting for the macOS versions listed on the product page. Make a copy before reformatting. If I regularly transfer recordings between locations or computers, I want the connection and file format to work with those devices. Around 19% of consumers prioritise transferring files.

Pitfalls to avoid when buying

  • Mistaking a single archive drive for a backup plan

    If the only copy is on one drive, losing or damaging it could mean losing the recordings too.

    Keep separate copies and check that you can restore files before using the drive as your only storage location.

  • Choosing an SSD based solely on its stated top speed

    Samsung lists maximum sequential speeds of 1.050 MB/s for reading and 1.000 MB/s for writing for the T7 examined. The speed you experience depends not only on that product specification, but also on the computer and connection you use.

    First consider how often you transfer files, then check that your computer supports the required USB interface.

  • Assuming every external drive has password protection

    Security features aren’t automatically available on every drive or version. WD’s documentation lists supported My Passport models; don’t assume the feature applies to other product lines.

    Check the security feature on the exact model and agree how authorised administrators will retain access.

  • Assuming there’s a fixed retention period or an available recovery service

    According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, the GDPR does not set a general, specific retention period for personal data. Seagate also states that Rescue Data Recovery Services are not available in every country.

    Set a retention period based on the purpose of the recordings, and check the coverage of any recovery service for the specific version.

Brands to consider

Toshiba

Canvio Basics is a compact range of USB-powered HDDs for local storage. The EMEA product information examined lists versions including 2 TB and 4 TB.

  • For the Canvio Basics examined, Toshiba lists NTFS as the file system for Windows.
  • Reformatting is required for the macOS versions listed on the product page. Make a separate copy of existing files before reformatting.

Seagate

Expansion Portable offers portable HDD storage; the manufacturer’s datasheet examined describes the 2 TB STKM2000400 version.

  • Seagate specifies power via a single USB cable.
  • Seagate states that Rescue Data Recovery Services are not available in every country. Check coverage for the specific version before assuming the service applies in the Netherlands.

Western Digital

Elements Portable is a range of portable HDDs for file storage; the 2 TB version examined has model number WDBU6Y0020BBK-WESN.

  • For that Elements version, Western Digital lists USB 3.2 Gen 1/USB 3.0.
  • WD Security documentation lists supported My Passport models for password protection. This feature does not automatically apply to Elements.

Samsung

The grey 2 TB Portable SSD T7 examined has model number MU-PC2T0T/WW and is an SSD option for those who take files with them or move them between locations.

  • Samsung lists maximum sequential read and write speeds of 1.050 and 1.000 MB/s respectively, along with a USB-C-to-C cable and a USB-C-to-A cable.
  • Samsung lists password protection with AES 256-bit encryption as an option. Check the setting and agree how your group will manage the password.

Products at Joybuy

These products are suited to a portable archive of recordings: the selection includes SSDs for taking files with you and HDDs for local storage and archive space.

SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB

SanDisk Portable SSD 1 TB

A portable SSD option for anyone who regularly takes recordings between locations.

Capacity: 1 TB. The product description lists read speeds of up to 800 MB/s and drop protection from heights of up to 2 metres.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 5TB USB-C, Graphite Black

WD Elements Portable 5 TB USB-C, Graphite Black

A portable HDD option for an archive that needs 5 TB of storage space.

The product description lists USB-C, USB 3.2 Gen 1 and a 2.5-inch design. Protect the drive from physical shocks and eject it safely.

View at Joybuy
My Passport 6TB, white

My Passport 6 TB, white

A portable HDD option for anyone looking for an archive with 6 TB of capacity.

The product description lists USB 3.0, 256-bit AES hardware encryption and password protection. According to the description, the drive weighs 210 grams; avoid knocks or shaking it while it’s in use.

View at Joybuy
My Passport 2TB, blue

My Passport 2 TB, blue

A portable HDD option for anyone who wants to take a 2 TB archive with them.

The product description lists USB 3.0, 256-bit AES hardware encryption and password protection.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 2TB USB-C, Graphite Black

WD Elements Portable 2 TB USB-C, Graphite Black

A portable HDD option for anyone looking for 2 TB of storage and taking the drive between computers.

The product description lists USB-C and compatibility with Windows and Mac computers.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is one external drive enough for an archive?

Not if you want to be able to restore recordings after they’re lost or the drive fails. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends the 3-2-1 approach: the original and two backups, on different media, with one copy kept in a separate location. This is security advice, not a requirement to buy a particular drive model.

Can a Windows drive be shared with a Mac straight away?

First check the file system and the exact version. Toshiba states that Canvio Basics uses NTFS for Windows and needs reformatting for the macOS versions listed on the product page. Make a separate copy of existing recordings before reformatting.

How can the group keep its recording archive usable?

Keep separate copies and check that you can restore a backup. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends not only making copies, but also checking that recovery works. Agree who will carry out the checks and where the copies will be stored.

Do participants always need to consent to meeting recordings being kept?

There’s no straightforward yes-or-no answer without considering the specific processing involved. If someone is identifiable in an audio recording, it may be personal data. Before processing begins, the group must determine an appropriate GDPR legal basis and inform the people concerned. Consent is one possible legal basis, but it isn’t automatically the only one.

How long can the group keep identifiable recordings?

The Dutch Data Protection Authority states that the GDPR does not set a general, specific retention period for personal data. Don’t keep recordings for longer than needed for the stated purpose, and assess any other applicable legal retention periods separately.