Project archivist focused on keeping files safe
You want to keep original photos, recordings and documents organised and be able to find them later. Having enough storage and a restorable copy matters more to you than working at maximum speed.
If you’re building a garden project archive that will usually stay in one place and needs plenty of storage, an external HDD is the obvious choice. An SSD is better if you regularly take your source files with you or work directly from the drive. In 2022, the Dutch Consumers’ Association highlighted that HDDs are more vulnerable to knocks. Whichever drive you choose, keep a separate copy and test that you can restore your files from it, as advised by the National Cyber Security Centre.
You want to keep original photos, recordings and documents organised and be able to find them later. Having enough storage and a restorable copy matters more to you than working at maximum speed.
You regularly take project files into the garden to copy or edit them there. Connections, portability and the protection offered by the specific drive model all matter.
You may use both Windows and Mac, or store images of identifiable people or information that reveals locations. Check the file format and consider the content and how you use it to decide which access controls and privacy rules apply.
Suitable if: you mainly store completed source files and storage space matters more than working from the drive.
Trade-off: an HDD is more vulnerable to knocks than an SSD, and even a high-capacity drive is still only one copy.
Suitable if: you regularly take the drive with you or work directly from it with project files.
Trade-off: maximum speeds also depend on your computer and cable; protection claims apply to specific models and have their limits.
| What to consider | What should you check? | Which consumers should consider this? |
|---|---|---|
| Space for source files | Check the size of the complete project folder, including originals and additions, and compare it with the capacity of the exact model. Toshiba lists 4 TB for the Canvio Basics HDTB440EK3CA; Seagate offers a 5 TB variant in its Portable range. | If I want to keep all the originals and any later additions, the total folder size matters most to me. Around 27% of consumers prioritise having enough space for their source files. |
| Restoring files | Keep a separate copy and test it by opening some original files. The National Cyber Security Centre advises keeping multiple versions on different media, including a copy in another location. | If I can’t collect the project files again, I want to know that a copy is genuinely usable. Around 27% of consumers say the ability to restore files is their main concern when buying. |
| Use and transport | Check your computer’s USB port and cable, as well as the specifications of the exact model. Samsung lists IP65 for the T7 Shield 1 TB; Crucial warns that the X9 Pro must not be submerged. | If I want to copy or work with files on location, I focus on transport and connectivity. Around 20% of consumers prioritise using their drive on the go. |
| Access from your devices | Note whether you use Windows, Mac or both, and whether you copy individual files or use Time Machine. Toshiba says the Canvio Basics model reviewed needs to be reformatted for macOS; Apple recommends APFS or encrypted APFS for Time Machine. | If I want to open the same project files on my own Windows and Mac devices, I check the format first. Around 13% of consumers prioritise device compatibility. |
| Access to sensitive data | Consider whether the folder contains images of identifiable people or information that could reveal someone’s identity, who needs access and whether security is set up on your chosen drive. The Dutch Data Protection Authority describes identifiable images as potentially containing personal data; the exception for personal or household use is conditional. | If my source files identify people or locations, I want to manage access carefully. Around 13% of consumers name access security as their main concern. |
If your only drive fails or gets lost, you could lose your entire archive.
Keep a separate copy as well, and periodically try restoring some source files. A second storage device takes up extra space, and testing a restore takes time.
A protection rating applies to the specific model and doesn’t eliminate every risk during transport. Crucial explicitly states that the X9 Pro must not be submerged.
Read the specifications for your chosen model and protect the drive while transporting it, even if the manufacturer gives it a protection rating.
A drive for transferring individual files may need a different format from a Time Machine drive. Reformatting can erase existing data.
Choose a format based on your devices and how you plan to use the drive. Back up existing files before reformatting it.
The maximum quoted speed depends on the USB port and cable you use. Crucial says that you need a compatible USB 3.2 Gen 2 host and cable to get the best speed from the X9 Pro.
Check your computer’s connection before making speed the deciding factor. If you rarely access your archive, available storage may matter more.
Canvio Basics is a range of portable HDDs for storing project folders. Toshiba lists 4 TB for the EMEA model reviewed, HDTB440EK3CA.
The Portable HDD range is worth comparing if you’re looking for space to store photos, videos and documents that you don’t access as often.
The T7 Shield is a range of SSDs for anyone who regularly takes their drive with them. The Dutch manufacturer page reviewed covers the black 1 TB model, MU-PE1T0S/EU.
The X9 Pro is a compact SSD worth considering if you regularly take your source files with you. The 1TB model reviewed has the model number CT1000X9PROSSD9.
WD Elements Portable is a range to compare if you’re looking for a straightforward external archive drive.
This selection includes portable and desktop HDDs, as well as portable SSDs, for storing project files locally or taking them with you.
Image unavailable
A portable SSD for taking project files with you; the description lists 1 TB of storage.
The description lists IP65, drop protection from up to 3 m and password protection with 256-bit AES hardware encryption. Read speeds of up to 2.000 MB/s require a compatible USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 device; write speeds are lower.
Image unavailable
A desktop HDD for a large archive that will mainly stay in one place.
The description lists 6 TB, USB 3.0, NTFS and a mains adapter included. You may need to reformat it for Mac; the description doesn’t mention built-in password protection or encryption.
Image unavailable
A portable HDD for an archive you may want to move around; the description lists 6 TB of storage.
The description lists USB 3.0, password protection and 256-bit AES hardware encryption. According to the description, the drive weighs 210 g and should not be moved while in use.
Image unavailable
A portable HDD for storing project files; the description lists 4 TB and USB power.
The 2.5-inch drive features USB 3.2 Gen 1 and plug-and-play functionality. It’s preformatted for Windows and needs to be reformatted for macOS; don’t move or shake the drive while it’s running.
Image unavailable
A portable SSD for project files you regularly take with you; the description lists 2 TB of storage.
The description lists USB 3.2 Gen 2, AES 256-bit encryption and drop resistance from up to 2 m. USB-C to USB-C and USB-C to USB-A cables are mentioned; the quoted sequential speeds of up to 1.050/1.000 MB/s depend on having a suitable connection.
Don’t do this if it leaves the external drive as your only copy. The National Cyber Security Centre advises keeping multiple versions of important data on different media, including a copy in another location. Also test that you can restore your project files.
That depends on the file format and how you use the drive. Apple lists ExFAT as a Windows-compatible format, but recommends APFS or encrypted APFS for Time Machine. You may need to reformat the drive, which will erase existing data, so back it up first.
Restore a few files to a suitable location and open them to check they work. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends testing your ability to restore files; simply seeing that a copy has finished doesn’t confirm that you can retrieve the right files.
If a product is faulty, the seller must provide a solution. According to the Dutch Government, the Netherlands has no fixed statutory warranty period; a manufacturer’s warranty is additional and doesn’t limit your statutory rights.
Images of identifiable people and information that can be traced back to someone may count as personal data. The Dutch Data Protection Authority describes a conditional exception for purely personal or household use; you can’t automatically rely on this exception for business use or wider distribution. Which rules apply depends on the content of your project and how you use it.