Who should consider this choice?

Manager of a growing data archive

You store lots of measurement series or image files, mainly use the drive on a small desk and are weighing up storage space against having a separate backup. The Consumentenbond and Toshiba Storage outline important considerations for external storage and the Canvio Basics.

Researcher who takes storage into the field

You take files to and from the coast and want to know what protection the specific drive offers against dust, water or drops. Kingston’s product specifications and Samsung’s claims can help you make a comparison.

Researcher who copies data frequently

You regularly move large files between your computer and external drive. Check that your computer’s connection is compatible with the stated capabilities of your chosen drive; Kingston and Samsung list conditions specific to each product.

What should you look for when choosing?

Compact external HDD

Choose this if: you mainly store large files that you access less often on your desk, and have worked out how much capacity you need.

Bear in mind: according to the Consumentenbond, an HDD with moving parts is more susceptible to knocks than an SSD; Toshiba says the Canvio Basics needs to be reformatted for macOS.

Compact external SSD

Choose this if: you regularly transfer files or take the drive with you, and your computer’s connection is compatible with the SSD.

Bear in mind: protection varies by model, and stated maximum speeds depend on the host connection.

Consideration What should you check? Who should consider this?
Dataset space and backup Add up your current files and expected growth, and leave room for a separate copy. The available space after formatting may differ from the stated capacity. If I’m storing a growing archive, I want enough space for the files and a separate copy. Around 40% of consumers put capacity and backup first.
Protection in transit Check the dust, water and drop-protection claims for the exact model. Samsung claims that the T7 Shield has an IP65 rating and is drop-resistant from up to 3 metres; these claims don’t automatically apply to other models. If I’m taking the drive to the coast, I want to know what protection the model I choose offers and where its limits lie. Around 30% of consumers give transport and physical protection top priority.
Transfer time Compare the USB connections on your computer and drive; don’t treat stated maximum speeds as guaranteed performance. Samsung states a maximum of 2,000 MB/s for the T9 2 TB via USB 3.2 Gen 2x2. If I’m copying large files frequently, I want to avoid my computer’s port limiting the transfer. Around 20% of consumers prioritise frequent file transfers.
Connection and desk space Check the available USB port, cable, dimensions and file system used by your computers. Toshiba lists NTFS as the preconfigured file system for Canvio Basics and says it needs to be reformatted for macOS. If my desk has limited space, I want a drive that’s practical for my computer and workspace. Around 10% of consumers give the connection and desk space top priority.

Things to watch out for when buying

  • Using your new drive as your only copy

    An external drive can fail or get lost; physical protection won’t prevent data loss.

    Plan and check a separate backup before using the drive as your main storage.

  • Assuming an SSD’s maximum speed is its guaranteed working speed

    Kingston’s maximum XS1000 speed depends on a suitable USB 3.2 Gen 2 host; hardware, software and usage can also affect performance.

    Compare the connections on your computer, cable and exact drive model before using a stated peak speed as a reason to buy.

  • Assuming a compact HDD and a protected SSD can handle the same conditions

    According to the Consumentenbond, an HDD is more susceptible to knocks than an SSD. Samsung’s IP65 and drop-protection claims apply specifically to the T7 Shield and don’t promise protection against every incident.

    Choose based on the transport and exposure you expect; even with a protected SSD, keep a separate copy.

  • Confusing a recovery service or manufacturer’s warranty with data protection

    Seagate states that Rescue Data Recovery Services isn’t available in every country. The statutory guarantee for a faulty product is also different from a backup.

    Check the terms for the exact model and don’t treat a recovery service or guarantee as a substitute for a separate copy. ACM ConsuWijzer explains that the Dutch statutory guarantee entitles you to a product that meets the required standard.

Brands to compare

Toshiba

Canvio Basics is a range of compact, USB-powered HDDs for storage on your desk or on the go.

  • For the 4 TB model, Toshiba Storage lists dimensions of 78 × 109 × 19,5 mm.
  • Canvio Basics comes preformatted as NTFS; Toshiba says it needs to be reformatted for macOS. A USB 3.2 Gen 1 interface doesn’t indicate a measured transfer speed.

Samsung

The T7 Shield and T9 are different portable SSD ranges, each with its own features and conditions.

  • Samsung claims that the T7 Shield has an IP65 rating and is drop-resistant from up to 3 metres. For the T9 2 TB, Samsung states a maximum speed of 2,000 MB/s.
  • The T9’s stated speed depends on a suitable host; the T7 Shield’s features don’t automatically apply to the T9.

Kingston

XS1000 is a range of small external SSDs, available in 1 TB and 2 TB models.

  • The Kingston data sheet lists dimensions, a cable and maximum speeds subject to certain conditions.
  • The data sheet doesn’t specify an IP rating. Check the host connection before expecting the maximum speed.

Seagate

Expansion Portable is a range of external HDDs powered via a single USB cable.

  • For the 5 TB model, the Seagate data sheet lists model STKM5000400 and dimensions of 115,3 × 80 × 20,9 mm.
  • Seagate says the included Rescue service isn’t available in every country; check the terms for the model you’re considering.

Western Digital

My Passport is a range of portable HDDs for storage and backup.

  • The product information checked for the 5 TB model lists password protection.
  • Western Digital says password protection for this model only works with Windows. Check the model and operating system.

Products for desk and fieldwork

This selection includes portable external SSDs for taking or transferring files, and external HDDs for archiving on a compact desk.

SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB

SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB

An option if you’re looking for a 1 TB portable SSD for taking and transferring files.

Joybuy
SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1TB 2000MB/s

SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1TB

Suited to anyone looking for a portable SSD for files on the go; the product name lists 1 TB and 2,000 MB/s.

According to the product information, the stated speed requires a compatible USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 host; actual performance may vary.

Joybuy
My Passport 4TB Black portable hard drive

My Passport 4TB Black Portable Hard Drive

An option to compare if you’re looking for a portable 4 TB HDD for archiving on a compact desk.

The product name lists password protection and automatic backup software; check the terms for this model and your operating system.

Joybuy
Portable SSD 1TB 1000MB/s

Portable SSD 1TB 1000MB/s

An option if you’re looking for a 1 TB portable SSD and want to weigh the stated 1,000 MB/s against your computer and connection.

According to the product information, the SSD may need formatting before first use on Windows. Check this before saving files.

Joybuy
Toshiba Canvas Basics 1TB Black 2.5-inch USB 3.2

Toshiba Canvas Basics 1TB Black 2.5" USB 3.2

A compact HDD option to compare for storage on a small desk or for taking with you.

The product information says the drive is formatted for Windows and needs to be reformatted for use with Mac. It also warns against physical knocks.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How do you work out the capacity you need for your dataset?

Add up your current files and expected growth, and allow space for your backup plan. You may not be able to use the full stated TB capacity for files: formatting uses some space, and an operating system may display capacity differently. The Consumentenbond highlights the importance of keeping a separate backup.

Will an external drive work straight away with both Windows and macOS?

Not always. Toshiba says Canvio Basics comes preformatted as NTFS for Windows and needs to be reformatted for macOS. Check your computers and back up any existing files before formatting a drive.

What if your external drive stops working?

For a purchase by a consumer in the Netherlands, the statutory guarantee is separate from the manufacturer’s warranty and backups. According to ACM ConsuWijzer, the seller must provide an appropriate solution for a faulty product used normally; what you could reasonably expect from the product also helps determine the time period. Keep a separate copy of any irreplaceable data too.

Do you need to encrypt a coastal ecology dataset under the GDPR?

That depends on its contents and how it’s processed; the description ‘coastal ecology dataset’ doesn’t automatically mean it contains personal data. If an organisation processes personal data, the Dutch Data Protection Authority says it must decide on appropriate security measures based on the risks. Drive encryption may be one such measure, but it isn’t described as a standard product requirement for every dataset.