First, choose a backup routine that someone can follow and test regularly. Then decide whether an HDD or SSD is right for your files, the connections on the shared computer and how often the drive will be carried around. If the files contain personal data, restrict access and put appropriate security measures in place: a portable drive or password feature won’t protect them automatically.
Who should consider this choice?
Membership records administrator
You might store members’ names, addresses or payment details, and need to decide who can use the backup and how it will be protected. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says that organisations processing personal data must protect it properly.
Volunteer responsible for backups
You want to follow a consistent routine at the shared workspace and check that files can actually be restored. The Digital Trust Center recommends testing backups regularly.
Administrator of a growing archive
You’re comparing storage capacity and connections for documents, photos or other club files. The capacity you need also depends on how many copies you want to keep.
What should you look for when buying?
External HDD
A good fit for: If you’ll mainly use the drive at one workstation, compare HDD models by the capacity you need and their connections.
Bear in mind: A storage drive isn’t a tested backup. Agree how copies will be made, stored and restored.
External SSD
A good fit for: If you regularly carry the drive around or transfer large files, consider a portable SSD.
Bear in mind: Check that the connection is compatible, and also arrange access security and regular recovery tests.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Access to personal data |
Check the security features of the exact model and agree who will manage access and recovery details. |
If I store members’ details on a shared computer, I want to know who can open and manage the copy. Around 36% of consumers put access security first. |
| Restoring files |
Decide who will make the copy, how often, and who will carry out a recovery test regularly. |
I don’t just want to store files; I also want to check that a usable copy can be restored. Around 29% of consumers give recoverability top priority. |
| Space for your archive |
Check the size of the files you want to copy and decide how many previous copies you want to keep. |
If our archive grows, I want to plan enough space for the files and the copies we keep. Around 21% of consumers put archive capacity first. |
| Connection and portability |
Check the USB port, cable and operating system; also see whether the exact model needs reformatting. |
If I want to carry the drive between workstations, it needs to connect to and work with the available computer. Around 14% of consumers cite portability and connectivity as their top priority. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Confusing extra storage with a recoverable backup
Having a drive connected doesn’t prove that the right files have been copied recently or can be restored. The Digital Trust Center recommends testing backups regularly.
Decide who will make the copy and regularly test restoring files.
Keeping a separate copy in another storage location and testing recovery takes extra time and organisation.
-
Assuming encryption automatically means password protection
Western Digital distinguishes between hardware encryption and password protection; features can also vary by product range.
Check the features of the exact model and configure access and password management carefully.
-
Buying a drive without checking the shared computer
Connections and the pre-formatted file system can vary between models. A quoted speed doesn’t tell you how fast the drive will work on the computer you have.
Make a note of the available port and operating system first, then compare them with the exact model.
You may need a different cable or additional setup, so check before transferring any files.
Brands to compare
Western Digital
My Passport is worth comparing if you’re looking for model-specific password and encryption options. Don’t assume these features are also available on Elements Portable.
- Western Digital lists hardware encryption and password protection options for My Passport.
- Western Digital says hardware encryption and password protection are separate features. Check the model and configure the features.
Toshiba
Canvio Basics is worth comparing if you’re looking for straightforward, USB-powered HDD storage. Toshiba lists downloadable backup and security software for Canvio Advance, not Canvio Basics.
- For the 2TB Canvio Basics HDTB520EK3AA, Toshiba lists NTFS for Windows and USB bus power.
- Toshiba says this model needs to be reformatted for use with Mac.
Seagate
Expansion Portable is a portable HDD range worth comparing if you’re looking for a USB-powered drive.
- Seagate’s support information distinguishes between various 2TB model numbers, including STKM2000400 and STEA2000400.
- Check the full model details; features of one model don’t necessarily apply to another.
Samsung
The T7 Shield is a portable SSD range worth comparing if you move the drive around often or transfer large files.
- For the black 2TB model MU-PE2T0S/EU, Samsung Netherlands lists USB 3.2 Gen 2 and sequential read and write speeds of up to 1.050/1.000 MB/s.
- These are figures quoted by Samsung; they don’t establish the speed you’ll get on the shared computer.
Joybuy products
These Joybuy products are portable external HDDs and SSDs to compare for storing and carrying club files. Before use, check that the connection and any security or backup settings suit the shared computer and your routine.
No image available
SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB
A portable SSD to compare if you want to carry a copy between workstations. Check that the USB-C connection is compatible with the computer you’ll use the drive with.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Western Digital My Passport 6TB White
A portable HDD to compare for an archive you want to keep in one place. Check which security and backup features are available for this model, and configure them carefully.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Western Digital My Passport 4TB Black
A portable HDD to compare for club files managed at a fixed workstation. Check which security and backup features are available for this model, and configure them carefully.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Western Digital My Passport 2TB Black
A portable HDD to compare if you want to store members’ files at a shared workspace. Western Digital distinguishes between hardware encryption and password protection; check the settings and compatibility with your operating system.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Samsung Portable SSD T7 2TB USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2 Blue
A portable SSD to compare if you want to move files between workstations. Check that the supplied cable is compatible with the computer, and set up any password protection before storing files.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is a connected external drive already a good backup?
Not by itself. Follow a consistent routine for making copies, don’t rely on a single storage location, and regularly test that you can restore files. The Digital Trust Center recommends this approach.
What should you check before using the drive with the shared computer?
Check the USB port, cable and operating system for the exact model. For example, Toshiba says the Canvio Basics model reviewed is formatted for Windows and needs to be reformatted for use with Mac.
Does the GDPR apply to a Dutch club that backs up members’ details?
Yes, if the club processes personal data, such as information in its membership records. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says that organisations processing personal data must protect it properly; the appropriate measures depend on the specific processing involved. This doesn’t mean that one particular type of drive is mandatory.
Does hardware encryption automatically mean the drive is password-protected?
No. Western Digital distinguishes between hardware encryption and password protection. Check which features are available for the exact model and whether they have been set up.