Who is this relevant to?

Creator with active recording projects

Regularly opens recordings and local audio sources from external storage, and pays attention to drive access, available space and the connection to the computer. Ableton describes both external SSDs and HDDs as possible storage for audio recordings.

Keeper of personal recordings

Wants to keep a separate, up-to-date copy of projects and the source files used, alongside working files. A backup is a copy, so one external drive is not automatically a second storage location.

Recording archive collector

Needs space for a growing collection of recordings and source files that are not all in constant use. Consider the capacity needed for complete projects, not just the size of individual audio files.

What should you look for when choosing?

Consideration What to check before buying Who is this important for?
Active audio projects Compare SSDs and HDDs for the way you work; Ableton says SSDs can help reduce disk overload. Also check the available space and the connection between the drive and audio interface. If I open files directly from the drive while recording a project, I want to keep working smoothly. Around 33% of consumers prioritise active projects as a reason to buy.
Separate backup Keep the copy in a different storage location and include both the project and the audio sources used. Ableton Live projects may refer to files outside the project folder. If I want to recover my recordings if the working drive fails, I need an up-to-date copy of my projects and source files. Around 27% of consumers prioritise a separate backup.
Growing archive Check how much space your complete existing projects take up, then choose a capacity that suits what you want to keep. If my collection of recordings and local source files is growing, I want enough space to keep complete projects. Around 27% of consumers prioritise archive space.
Sharing between computers Check the USB ports and file system. Apple says a Mac may be able to read an NTFS drive, but not write to it. If I want to use and transfer audio files between computers, I check both the cable and the file system. Around 13% of consumers prioritise use across different devices.

Common pitfalls

  • Moving your only copy and calling it a backup

    A copy on one external drive will not protect you if that same drive is lost.

    Keep a separate, up-to-date copy of your projects and source files, and check that you can open them.

  • Copying only the project file

    Ableton Live can use a Set to refer to audio files stored outside the project folder. Those files will not automatically be included if you transfer only the project file.

    When transferring, gather the files used into the project folder and copy that folder. Then check that the audio files are available.

  • Assuming a compatible USB plug means you can write to the drive on any computer

    The file system can determine whether you can save files on a computer. Apple says macOS may be able to read an NTFS drive, but not write to it. Reformatting deletes existing files: Toshiba warns of this in the Canvio Flex manual.

    Check the port, cable and file system separately. Make a copy of existing files first if you plan to reformat a drive.

  • Taking an SSD’s stated maximum speed as a guaranteed recording performance

    Manufacturers quote maximum sequential speeds; these do not, by themselves, tell you how a particular recording session will perform. Ableton also highlights audio file use and the connection as relevant factors in disk overload.

    Choose based on your project and computer, not just the highest figure in MB/s.

Brands to consider

Samsung

The T7 Shield range includes portable SSDs for active projects and use on the go.

  • For the T7 Shield 1 TB MU-PE1T0S/EU, Samsung lists USB 3.2 Gen 2, sequential speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s read and 1.000 MB/s write, and IP65 protection.
  • These product specifications are not an independent recording benchmark and do not mean a backup is unnecessary.

Toshiba

Canvio Flex is a range of portable HDDs for storing and transferring files.

  • Toshiba lists 1, 2 and 4 TB versions, supplied with USB-A and USB-C cables.
  • Check which capacity and cables come with the version you choose. The product range is no proof that every drive is suitable for every demanding recording session.

Kingston

The XS1000 range consists of compact external SSDs for portable working files or copies.

  • Kingston lists 1 and 2 TB versions, USB 3.2 Gen 2 and sequential speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s read and 1.000 MB/s write. The listed accessories are a USB-A cable and USB-C adapter.
  • Check which capacity, connection and accessories come with the version you choose; the stated maximum speeds are not a measurement of your own recording session.

Seagate

Expansion Portable includes portable HDD versions for local collections and copies.

  • Seagate Netherlands lists, among others, the 2 TB STKM2000400 and 4 TB STKM4000400 models.
  • Capacity alone says nothing about the performance of a specific audio project.

Western Digital

My Passport is a range of portable HDDs for local files and backups.

  • For the range described, Western Digital’s product sheet lists capacities from 1 to 6 TB, password protection and hardware encryption.
  • Check the version you choose and keep important recordings in another storage location too; security features do not turn one drive into two copies.

Products at Joybuy

This selection includes external HDDs for archiving or keeping a separate copy, and external SSDs for active projects.

WD Elements Portable 5 TB USB-C, graphite black

WD Elements Portable 5 TB USB-C

A portable external HDD for storing or taking archive files with you.

5 TB storage; USB-C connection.

Joybuy
1 TB portable external SSD

Portable SSD 1 TB

An external SSD option for projects or source files you regularly use from external storage.

1 TB storage; the product name lists 1.000 MB/s, but this should not be taken as guaranteed recording performance.

Joybuy
Western Digital My Passport 2 TB black

Western Digital My Passport 2 TB

A portable HDD option for local music files and a copy kept in a separate storage location.

2 TB storage; the product information says an NTFS compatibility driver is required for use with macOS.

Joybuy
Toshiba Canvio Basics external hard drive, 4 TB

Toshiba Canvio Basics 4 TB

A portable external HDD for storing recordings and local source files.

4 TB; USB Type-A and Micro-USB B connection. The product information says it is formatted for Windows; it must be reformatted for use with macOS. Make a copy of any files you want to keep beforehand.

Joybuy
Samsung Portable SSD T9 4 TB black, MU-PG4T0B

Samsung Portable SSD T9 4 TB MU-PG4T0B

A portable SSD option for active projects and large files.

4 TB; the product information lists USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 and USB-C-to-C and USB-C-to-A cables. The stated maximum speeds are not a recording benchmark.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I put my recording project directly on an external HDD?

That depends on your project and software: Ableton lists both SSDs and HDDs as possible storage for audio recordings. If you use many audio files at the same time, an SSD can help reduce disk overload; also check the available space and the connection to your computer.

Why are audio files missing after I transfer a project?

In Ableton Live, a saved Set may contain only references to the files used. Where appropriate, use ‘Collect All and Save’, check which files are included, then copy the entire project folder. This will not copy plug-ins.

What should I check if my Mac can read an external drive but cannot save anything to it?

Check the available space, file system and access permissions. Apple says macOS may be able to read an NTFS drive but not write to it; exFAT is a file system compatible with Windows. Secure any existing files before erasing the drive to reformat it.

Should I buy extra cover for an external drive in the Netherlands?

First compare the terms of any extra cover with your statutory rights. According to the Dutch Government, there is no fixed statutory warranty period for consumer purchases in the Netherlands; if a product is faulty, the seller must provide a solution. Paid extra cover is most relevant if its terms offer something beyond those rights.

Where can I take an old external drive for recycling in the Netherlands?

According to the Dutch Government, you can hand in old electrical appliances when buying a new, similar appliance, at suitable collection points or at your local council recycling centre. Before handing in a drive, check whether you still need the files and remove any data you do not want to keep.