Who might be building this archive?

Managing a growing lecture archive

You want to store existing and new recordings at a fixed workstation. The Library of Congress also recommends keeping copies on different storage media and in separate physical locations.

Volunteering to transfer recordings

You move files from the recording location to the archive computer. First, check that the ports and cables are compatible with both computers, then check the files after copying them.

Managing recordings with restricted access

You need to decide who can access or share recordings that contain personal data or protected material. The Dutch Data Protection Authority sets out security measures for organisations that process personal data; a feature on one drive does not replace an access policy.

What should you look for?

Desktop HDD

Choose this option: if your collection is growing at a fixed archive workstation and you can match the capacity to your existing files and expected growth.

Bear in mind: this drive is less suited to being carried around; a separate backup remains an essential part of your archive plan.

Portable HDD

Choose this option: if volunteers carry recordings between the recording location and the archive computer.

Bear in mind: check the connections and file system; a portable drive is not automatically ready to use with every computer.

Portable SSD

Choose this option: if you regularly import or transport recordings and an SSD suits the way you work.

Bear in mind: quoted interface speeds do not measure the full transfer speed on your computer.

The Library of Congress recommends keeping copies on at least two different storage media and in separate physical locations. The KB explains how to check checksums during file transfers; allow time for these checks in your archive process too.

What to consider What should you look for when buying? Who should pay particular attention?
Copies and checks Allow space for a separate copy and decide who will carry out transfers and checks. I don’t want to rely on a single drive or an unchecked copy. Around 36% of consumers prioritise preservation and checking copies.
Capacity and growth Add up your existing files, estimate new recordings using the same file basis, and compare the total with each drive’s capacity. Don’t count the backup as free space on your primary drive. I want to know whether my collection and future recordings will fit before choosing a model. Around 29% of consumers prioritise room to grow.
Transport and connections Check the ports on both computers, which cables are included and whether the drive is powered via USB. Check the files after copying them. If I transfer recordings between locations, I want the drive to connect to both computers. Around 21% of consumers prioritise transport and importing files.
Restricted access Decide who should have access and whether recordings contain personal data, then assess which technical and organisational measures are appropriate. When deciding who can access sensitive recordings, I want to do more than simply put a password on the drive. Around 14% of consumers prioritise restricting access.

Pitfalls of archive storage

  • Using the archive drive as your only copy

    If the drive fails or goes missing, you could lose your only copy. The Library of Congress recommends keeping copies on different storage media and in separate physical locations.

    Plan those copies before choosing the capacity, and check transferred files.

  • Assuming USB speed guarantees copy speed

    A manufacturer’s quoted interface or sequential speed does not tell you how quickly the entire transfer will run through your computer and cable.

    Check the connections and cables for both devices. Choose an SSD if frequent transfers really matter for your archive, not just because of a speed figure.

  • Formatting without first protecting existing files

    Toshiba states that the Canvio Basics model reviewed is formatted for Windows and needs reformatting for the macOS versions listed. Formatting can erase existing files on the drive.

    Decide in advance which computers will use the drive, and first save your files safely somewhere else.

  • Confusing a password with permission or full access management

    A drive’s security feature does not determine who in your organisation can access it, nor does it manage permissions to keep or share recordings publicly. The Dutch Data Protection Authority recommends appropriate security when an organisation processes personal data.

    Set out access rights and the purpose for keeping recordings, and assess publication rights separately from technical security.

Brands as product references

Western Digital

Elements Desktop is a desktop option for an archive kept at a fixed workstation. Western Digital lists an 8 TB capacity for model WDBWLG0080HBK-EESN.

  • The manufacturer lists the model and capacity for this version.
  • The capacity does not prove that it will last longer than drives from other brands; keep a separate copy.

Seagate

Expansion Desktop is a desktop option for a fixed archive location. Seagate’s Dutch support information lists model STKP8000400 as the 8 TB version.

  • Seagate lists tools such as SeaTools for diagnostics.
  • A diagnostic tool is no substitute for a separately stored backup.

Toshiba

According to Toshiba, Canvio Basics HDTB540EK3CA is a 4 TB portable HDD model.

  • Toshiba says the version reviewed is ready to use with Windows.
  • It needs reformatting for the macOS versions listed; back up existing files before doing so.

Samsung

The black T7 Shield MU-PE2T0S/EU is a 2 TB portable SSD model.

  • For this version, Samsung specifies USB 3.2 Gen 2, USB-A and USB-C cables, and optional password protection.
  • Samsung’s quoted top speed is not an independent measurement of a complete archive transfer.

LaCie

LaCie Rugged USB-C STFR4000800 is a 4 TB portable HDD model.

  • Seagate lists USB-C connectivity and drop resistance for this model.
  • Drop resistance does not make the drive invulnerable or remove the need for a separate copy.

Joybuy products

These product choices are suited to storing and transferring lecture recordings, with portable drives and a desktop model for a fixed archive location.

SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB

SanDisk Portable SSD 1 TB

A 1 TB portable SSD for transferring recordings, if that capacity suits your collection.

Also plan a separate archive copy and check files after transferring them.

View at Joybuy
My Passport SSD WDBAGF0010BGY, 1 TB

My Passport SSD WDBAGF0010BGY, 1 TB

A portable SSD for taking recordings with you, if 1 TB is enough for the files you want to transfer.

Consider access management and backups separately from your choice of drive.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 5 TB, USB-C, Graphite Black

WD Elements Portable 5 TB, USB-C, Graphite Black

A portable drive for transfers between locations, if 5 TB suits your collection and expected growth.

The product name specifies USB-C; check that the connection works with both computers, and plan to keep separate copies.

View at Joybuy
My Passport for Mac 2 TB, Blue

My Passport for Mac 2 TB, Blue

A portable drive for a Mac archive, if 2 TB suits your collection.

Check the file system and connection before use; first save existing files somewhere else.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Desktop 6 TB, USB 3.0

WD Elements Desktop 6 TB, USB 3.0

A desktop HDD for a fixed archive workstation, if 6 TB suits your existing collection and expected growth.

The product name specifies USB 3.0. Bear in mind that it is designed for a fixed setup, and keep a separate copy.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is one external drive enough for a long-term archive?

No. Don’t treat one drive as your only copy. The Library of Congress recommends keeping copies on at least two different storage media in separate physical locations; also check that transferred files are intact.

What should you check after transferring a lecture?

Check that the file is present and readable at its destination, and record an integrity check for valuable recordings. The KB explains how to check supplied checksums, as well as alternative checks during transfer when checksums are not available.

Will a portable HDD work straight away with both Windows and Mac?

Not always. Toshiba says the Canvio Basics model reviewed is formatted for Windows and needs reformatting for the macOS versions listed. Check the file system and save existing files somewhere else before formatting.

Can an archive share a recorded lecture publicly without further checks?

First, check the rights to the content. The Government of the Netherlands says permission from the creator may be needed to use copyright-protected material. If personal data is being processed, there must also be a lawful basis for doing so; the Dutch Data Protection Authority lists consent as one possible basis.

Is there a fixed statutory retention period for lecture recordings?

No. If recordings contain personal data, the Dutch Data Protection Authority says they must not be kept for longer than necessary for their purpose. The GDPR does not set a general, specific retention period; decide on and justify a period for your own collection.