A portable HDD is a good fit for a growing archive that is mainly used for storage and retrieval. An SSD makes more sense if volunteers often carry files around or work directly from the drive. Calculate the capacity you need based on your own files and expected growth, and don’t use either drive as your only archive copy: the Library of Congress recommends keeping copies on different storage media and in separate locations. If people can be recognised in the recordings, also determine the appropriate GDPR lawful basis, retention period and security measures.
Who is this guide for?
Group archive manager
Wants recordings to remain recoverable if a drive is damaged or lost. A regular routine for copying and checking files helps ensure the archive doesn’t depend on a single storage device. The Library of Congress recommends storing copies on different media and in different locations.
Manager of a growing collection of recordings
Regularly adds audio or video files and wants to choose capacity based on the existing recordings, expected growth and computers in use.
Volunteer who takes recordings with them
Moves files between locations or works directly from the drive. Portability and connectivity matter, while keeping a separate archive copy in mind.
What should you consider when choosing?
Portable HDD for storage
A good fit if: your group mainly adds and retrieves recordings and wants a compact drive that doesn’t need a separate power supply.
Bear in mind: an HDD is not automatically a safe sole archive copy; also check the file system used by your computers.
Portable SSD for working on the move
A good fit if: volunteers often carry files around or work directly from the drive.
Bear in mind: quoted speeds depend on the computer, port and cable used; an SSD doesn’t replace a separate archive copy.
Working drive with a separate archive copy
A good fit if: recordings are difficult to recreate and your group wants to keep copies on separate storage media and in different locations.
Bear in mind: this requires extra storage and a regular routine for copying and checking files.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Preservation and recovery |
Decide who will make copies, where they will be stored and how files will be checked after transfer. |
If the recordings are difficult to recreate, I want to know how the archive will be preserved if one drive fails. Around 33% of consumers put preservation and recovery first. |
| Capacity and growth |
Add up the existing files and estimate growth using your own recent recordings; calculate space for separate copies separately. |
I want to match the storage space to both the files we already have and the archive’s growth. Around 27% of consumers prioritise having enough capacity. |
| Portability and working |
Check the ports and cables on the computers in use; don’t treat quoted speeds as guaranteed real-world speeds. |
If volunteers regularly take recordings with them or edit them directly from the drive, a suitable connection matters. Around 20% of consumers prioritise working on the move. |
| Privacy and computers |
Decide who needs access and check which file systems the group’s computers support. |
If people can be recognised in the recordings, I want to arrange access and use on the group’s computers in advance. Around 20% of consumers prioritise privacy and shared access. |
Common mistakes
-
Treating one external drive as a complete archive
External media can be damaged and, by themselves, don’t actively monitor the integrity of files. If a drive is lost or damaged, one copy may not be enough to preserve the recordings.
Agree where a separate copy will be kept, who will make it and how transfers will be checked.
A second copy requires extra storage, as well as time for management and checks.
-
Assuming a maximum SSD speed is a guaranteed copying speed
Manufacturer figures depend on factors including the computer, port and cable used for testing. A high quoted speed won’t make an unsuitable connection compatible.
Check the computers and cables in use before giving speed too much weight.
-
Leaving formatting and access until after purchase
According to Toshiba, the Toshiba Canvio Basics described here is formatted as NTFS and needs to be reformatted for macOS. If people can be recognised in the recordings, access and security also need to be assessed appropriately.
First, work out which computers will be used and who should be able to open the recordings. Make a copy of any files already on a drive before reformatting it.
Formatting, copying files and managing access can all take extra time.
Brands to consider
Toshiba
Canvio Basics is a range of portable, USB-powered HDDs for storage on the go.
- Toshiba lists capacities including 2 and 4 TB.
- The range described is formatted as NTFS for Windows; Toshiba advises reformatting for macOS.
Samsung
The portable T7 Shield is an SSD range worth comparing for carrying and working with files directly from the drive.
- For the 2 TB black model, Samsung quotes USB 3.2 Gen 2 and sequential read and write speeds of up to 1.050 and 1.000 MB/s.
- These are manufacturer figures under applicable conditions, not guaranteed speeds on your group’s computers.
Seagate
The Expansion range includes portable HDDs for USB storage.
- For the range described, Seagate lists USB 3.0 and compatibility with Windows, Mac and Chromebook.
- Check the specifications for the exact model and the computers the drive will be used with.
Crucial
The 2 TB X9 is an SSD option worth comparing for working on the move.
- Crucial describes its speed measurement as maximum sequential performance on a high-performance test computer.
- Achievable speeds and compatibility depend on the computer and formatting used.
Western Digital
My Passport is a range of portable HDDs; Western Digital Support covers topics including setup and file recovery.
- The support information includes guidance on using the My Passport model family.
- Check the features and support for the exact model before choosing it for your group’s archive.
External drives at Joybuy
This selection includes portable HDDs for storage capacity and portable SSDs for carrying and working with files.
No image available
Western Digital My Passport USB-C 4TB black
The stated 4 TB capacity may suit a growing archive. Calculate the space you need based on your own files and separate copies.
USB-C, exFAT and password protection with AES 256-bit hardware encryption are listed. Don’t use this drive as your only archive copy.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Portable SSD 1 TB, up to 1000 MB/s
This portable SSD may suit carrying and transferring files; check that its capacity meets your group’s archive requirements.
The description lists USB-C, USB 3.2 Gen 2 and read speeds of up to 1000 MB/s. This quoted speed isn’t guaranteed on every computer. The description also mentions drop protection of up to 2 metres.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Western Digital My Passport 2TB black
According to the product description, this portable HDD offers 2 TB for files such as videos. Match the capacity to your existing recordings and expected growth.
The description lists USB 3.2 Gen 1, password protection and AES 256-bit hardware encryption. It also specifies NTFS for Windows and additional driver support for macOS. Keep a separate archive copy as well.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Toshiba Canvio Basics 4TB
This 4 TB portable HDD may suit a growing collection of recordings. Work out the space you need based on your own files and copies.
The product name lists USB 3.2 Gen 1. The description mentions USB power and an included USB cable. According to the description, the drive is formatted for Windows and needs to be reformatted for macOS.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Samsung Portable SSD T7 2TB blue
This 2 TB portable SSD may suit volunteers who carry files around or work from an external drive. Check in advance that there’s enough capacity for the recordings and separate copies.
The product name lists USB Type-C and USB 3.2 Gen 2. The description mentions AES 256-bit hardware encryption and USB-C-to-C and USB-C-to-A cables. Don’t use the SSD as your only archive copy.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
How do we calculate how much storage we need?
Add up the actual size of your existing recordings and use recent recordings by your group to estimate growth. Calculate space for separate copies separately; a drive’s capacity isn’t the same as having a complete archive strategy.
Can the group use a Windows-formatted drive straight away on a Mac?
Don’t assume so without checking. For the Canvio Basics described here, Toshiba specifies an NTFS file system and says the drive needs to be reformatted for macOS. Check which computers your group uses and make a copy of any existing files before reformatting a drive.
How do we keep recordings accessible after copying them?
Keep copies on separate media and in different locations, organise files clearly and check that the copy is correct after transfer. The Library of Congress presents this as preservation advice, not a legal requirement for a group in the Netherlands.
What ongoing effort should we allow for?
As well as the working drive, allow for separate storage and its management. Check the warranty and recovery terms for the exact model; data recovery or a warranty claim is no substitute for a backup.
Can we keep identifiable lecture recordings indefinitely or share them online?
No. Keeping a recording as an archive doesn’t mean it can be kept indefinitely. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, identifiable audio and video recordings may be personal data. The group must determine an appropriate GDPR lawful basis and security measures for processing, and must not keep personal data for longer than necessary. Assess privacy and any copyright issues separately before sharing recordings online; consent is not automatically the only possible GDPR lawful basis.