Who is this choice relevant to?

Recording archive manager

Wants to be able to find and restore sessions if a working file or drive is lost. The National Cyber Security Centre advises keeping multiple versions of important data and testing backups.

Volunteer transferring recordings

Takes files between locations or computers, so portability, available connections and transfer speeds under their own usage conditions are important.

Manager of identifiable voices

Stores recordings in which people may be identifiable and must also consider access security and the relevant privacy rules. The Dutch Data Protection Authority classifies identifiable audio recordings as personal data.

What should you look for in an external drive?

Portable external HDD

A good fit when: archive space for existing and future recordings matters more than frequent transport or fast transfers.

Bear in mind: check the capacity and file system of the exact model. A drive that needs reformatting for macOS will have its existing files erased in the process.

Portable external SSD

A good fit when: group members regularly take the drive with them or transfer files between compatible computers.

Bear in mind: compare capacities and USB connections. Advertised peak speeds do not guarantee the same performance on every computer.

SSD with added protection for transport

A good fit when: the drive is often taken to locations where protection against dust, water or drops is an important requirement.

Bear in mind: the stated protection features do not prevent data loss. This drive also needs a separate backup.

What to consider What to check before buying Who is this important for?
Restorable copies Decide whether the drive will hold the working copy or a separate backup, and who will manage the copies and restoration tests. If I want to be able to restore recordings after a loss, I’ll plan a separate copy alongside the working drive and test that restoration works. Around 33% of consumers prioritise being able to restore recordings.
Space for the archive and new sessions Measure the existing archive and estimate how quickly it will grow. Include any second copy in your storage plan. If I want to keep existing recordings and new sessions, I’ll choose a capacity that suits the files and the number of versions the group wants to retain. Around 25% of consumers prioritise archive space.
Transfers between locations and computers Check the USB ports, supplied cable and file systems on the computers you use. If I want to share files between locations and group computers, I’ll check in advance that the connection and file system work on those devices. Around 25% of consumers prioritise smooth file transfers.
Access to identifiable recordings Establish who is allowed to use the files and what security measures are appropriate. If I manage recordings containing identifiable voices, I’ll want to control access carefully and know how passwords are managed. Around 17% of consumers prioritise access security.

What to watch out for when buying an external drive

  • Using the new drive as your only copy

    If that drive is lost or becomes unreadable, the group will not be able to restore the recordings from that copy.

    Before buying, decide where the working copy and separate backup will be kept, and regularly test that you can open files from the backup.

  • Expecting USB speeds on every computer

    Kingston states that the XS1000’s optimal speed requires a USB 3.2 Gen 2 host. A different connection or computer may limit transfer speeds.

    Check the ports and cables on the group’s computers, and don’t base your choice on the stated peak speed alone.

  • Reformatting before copying your files

    The Canvio Basics model reviewed here is formatted as NTFS by default. Apple warns that formatting erases files.

    First check the current file system, make a copy elsewhere and test the chosen file system on the devices you need to use.

Brands to consider

Toshiba

Canvio Basics is a range of portable HDDs for groups looking primarily for archive space.

  • Toshiba lists 1 TB, 2 TB and 4 TB models, USB power and a Type-A-to-Micro-B cable in the box.
  • The range reviewed here is formatted as NTFS by default and, according to Toshiba, needs reformatting for macOS. Check the exact model and copy your files elsewhere before reformatting.

Samsung

The T7 is a compact external SSD. The T7 Shield is a separate model for those looking for stated protection during transport.

  • For the grey 1 TB T7, Samsung lists read speeds of up to 1,050 MB/s and password protection with AES 256-bit encryption.
  • For the blue 1 TB T7 Shield, Samsung specifies IP65 and drop resistance from up to 3 metres. These features do not automatically apply to every T7 model and are no substitute for a separate backup.

Kingston

The XS1000 is a compact external SSD for transfers and backups, provided the capacity of your chosen model is sufficient.

  • Kingston lists 1 TB and 2 TB models, supplied with a Type-A cable and Type-C adapter.
  • The maximum read speed of 1,050 MB/s is based on internal testing. According to Kingston, optimal speeds require a USB 3.2 Gen 2 host.

Seagate

Expansion Portable is a portable HDD option for a local archive or a separate copy.

  • Seagate describes it as USB-powered, with file storage using drag and drop.
  • Seagate states that the Rescue Data Recovery Services mentioned are not available in every country. Check whether the service applies to your purchase before factoring it into your decision.

Joybuy products for group recordings

These portable external drives are designed for storing and transporting group recordings. Choose a model based on the space you need, the connections available and your security requirements.

SanDisk Portable SSD 1 TB

SanDisk Portable SSD 1 TB

A portable SSD option for groups who want to take files between locations.

Capacity: 1 TB. The product description lists read speeds of up to 800 MB/s and drop protection from up to 2 metres.

Keep a separate copy as well, and test that you can restore files from it.

Joybuy
Western Digital My Passport 2 TB black

Western Digital My Passport 2 TB Black

A portable HDD option for groups looking to combine storage space with access security.

Capacity: 2 TB. The product description mentions password protection with 256-bit AES.

The description lists NTFS and a compatibility driver for reading and writing on macOS. Keep a separate copy as well, and test that you can restore files from it.

Joybuy
Toshiba Canvio Basics external hard drive 4 TB

Toshiba Canvio Basics 4 TB

A portable HDD option for groups that prioritise space for their archive.

Capacity: 4 TB. The product name lists USB Type-A and Micro-USB B; the description mentions USB 3.2 Gen 1 and USB 2.0 compatibility.

The description lists a Windows file system that needs to be reformatted for macOS. Formatting erases files, so make a copy elsewhere first. Keep a separate backup too, and test that you can restore files from it.

Joybuy
Samsung Portable SSD T9 4 TB black

Samsung Portable SSD T9 4 TB Black MU-PG4T0B

A portable SSD option for groups looking for a 4 TB model to store large files.

The product description lists USB 3.2 Gen 2x2, hardware encryption, and USB-C-to-C and USB-C-to-A cables.

Advertised transfer speeds are maximums and are not guaranteed on every computer. Keep a separate copy as well, and test that you can restore files from it.

Joybuy
Samsung external SSD MU-PE2T0R 2 TB blue

Samsung MU-PE2T0R 2 TB USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2 Blue

A portable SSD option for groups who take the drive with them and prioritise protection during transport.

Capacity: 2 TB. The product description lists IP65, drop resistance from up to 3 metres and password protection.

The product description warns that IP65 does not protect against immersion in water. Keep a separate copy as well, and test that you can restore files from it.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is an external drive enough as the only place to store your recordings?

No, not if the group needs to be able to restore recordings after a loss. The National Cyber Security Centre advises keeping multiple versions on different media, with one copy stored elsewhere. Also, open files from a backup regularly to check that you can restore them.

What if the drive is used with both Windows and Mac?

First check the current file system and whether it works with all the computers and recording devices you use. Apple lists exFAT as an option for use with Windows and warns that a Mac may not be able to write to NTFS. Copy existing files elsewhere before reformatting, as formatting erases them.

How can you check that your backup works?

Include a restoration test in the group’s plan. The National Cyber Security Centre advises checking the technical result and, for file backups, opening a few restored files.

What costs or service terms should the group check in advance?

Check the warranty terms for the exact model and whether a second storage location or an extra drive fits your plan. Kingston describes the XS1000 as having a limited warranty with a condition relating to the remaining SSD life. Seagate states that the Rescue Data Recovery Services mentioned are not available in every country; check whether the service applies to your purchase.

Does the GDPR apply to your music recordings?

If someone is identifiable in an audio recording and the group processes that personal data, GDPR rules are relevant. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says that an applicable legal basis is required, personal data must be protected appropriately, and it must not be kept for longer than necessary. The legal basis and measures depend on how the recordings are used; consent is not automatically the only possible legal basis. Instrumental files with no identifiable people are not personal data simply because they are audio files.