A desktop HDD is suited to a back-up that stays in one place, while a portable HDD or SSD makes more sense if volunteers need to take files with them. An SSD is particularly worth considering if transfer speed is a priority. First, work out how much space your current collection and new recordings will need, and check that the drive is compatible with your group’s computers. One drive isn’t a complete back-up strategy: the NCSC recommends the 3-2-1 rule, and a recovery test helps you check that files can be restored.
Who should consider this?
Managing a growing video archive
You need enough space for your existing collection and new recordings. Work out the capacity you’ll need for your own files and expected growth; the 8 TB STKP8000400 is an example of a desktop model, not a general capacity recommendation.
Volunteers who take files with them
You share videos between locations, so portability, power and compatibility with your group’s computers all matter. If you transfer files often, the stated speed may also be relevant, provided the computers support the connection.
Responsible for keeping files safe
You want to be able to restore files after data loss. If people are identifiable in the footage, also consider who has access and how long you need to keep it; the Dutch Data Protection Authority considers identifiable images to be personal data.
What should you look for?
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Capacity |
Add up your current files and allow for planned growth. Compare the space you need with the capacity of the exact variant. |
I want to keep existing videos and new recordings without running short of space. Around 28% of consumers prioritise having enough capacity for their collection. |
| Recoverable back-up |
Plan a separate copy and check periodically that you can restore a file. The NCSC recommends the 3-2-1 rule for back-ups. |
I don’t want to rely on a single drive in case it fails or gets lost. Around 28% of consumers give top priority to recoverability and keeping a separate copy. |
| Taking files with you and transferring them |
Check whether the drive can work without a separate power adaptor and whether the computer supports its connection. Remember that stated maximum speeds depend on the equipment being used. |
I take files between volunteers or locations and want the connection to work with the computers we use. Around 17% of consumers prioritise portability and file transfer. |
| Access and privacy |
If people are identifiable in the footage, consider who should have access, what security measures are appropriate and how long you need to keep it. The Dutch Data Protection Authority notes that identifiable images are personal data. |
I want to manage access to potentially identifiable footage carefully and avoid keeping it for longer than necessary. Around 16% of consumers prioritise privacy and access management. |
| Computer compatibility |
Note the operating systems you use and check the ports, cable and file system of the exact drive. Toshiba says the Canvio Basics variant reviewed needs reformatting for macOS; back up your files before reformatting. |
I want volunteers to be able to connect the drive to our group’s computers and access its files. Around 11% of consumers choose primarily based on compatibility with those computers. |
Common buying pitfalls
-
Moving your only copy to a new external drive
If that drive fails or gets lost, you won’t have a separate copy to restore your collection from.
Keep a separate copy as well, and periodically test that you can restore a file. The NCSC recommends the 3-2-1 rule for back-ups.
-
Leaving your back-up drive connected all the time
A connected copy can also be affected by ransomware; Which? warns that ransomware can affect files on connected external drives too.
Decide when you need the drive, and keep a separate copy elsewhere as well.
-
Choosing based only on capacity or stated SSD speed
The right capacity doesn’t guarantee that the connection will work with your group’s computers. What’s more, stated maximum SSD speeds depend on the equipment being used.
First, work out how much storage your collection needs, then check the ports, cable, power and file system of the exact variant.
Brands to consider
Seagate
The Expansion Desktop range is an option for a large video back-up that stays in one place. The EMEA variant reviewed, STKP8000400, has 8 TB of storage.
- Seagate’s data sheet says this variant has USB 3.0 and comes with a power adaptor.
- You’ll need a mains socket. Any data recovery service is no substitute for a separate back-up; check the terms for your specific purchase.
Toshiba
Canvio Basics is a portable HDD option; the variant reviewed, HDTB540EK3CA, has 4 TB of storage.
- Toshiba says it is powered via USB and supplied in NTFS format.
- Toshiba says it needs reformatting for macOS. Also check that the USB-A cable is suitable for your group’s computers, and back up your files before reformatting.
Samsung
The T7 Shield is a portable SSD range for people who regularly transfer large files. The Dutch variant reviewed, MU-PE4T0S/EU, has 4 TB of storage.
- For this variant, Samsung lists USB 3.2 Gen 2, sequential speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s for reading and 1.000 MB/s for writing, and IP65 protection.
- These are manufacturer specifications, not the results of independent performance or reliability testing. Check that 4 TB is right for your collection and that the computer supports the connection you plan to use.
Joybuy products for video back-ups
These Joybuy products are portable external drives for storing and taking group videos with you. Choose a capacity based on the size of your collection and its expected growth, and keep a separate back-up as well.
No image available
SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1 TB
A portable SSD for taking videos with you. Check whether 1 TB is enough for your collection and planned growth. The stated maximum read speed requires a compatible USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 device.
The product name lists a maximum speed of 2.000 MB/s.
Joybuy
No image available
My Passport 6 TB White portable hard drive
A portable hard drive for taking video files with you. Check whether 6 TB is enough for your current collection and expected growth.
Joybuy
No image available
Western Digital My Passport USB-C 4 TB black
A portable hard drive for videos. Check whether 4 TB is enough for your full back-up. The product name specifies USB-C, so check that the computers you use have this connection or can use a suitable adaptor.
Joybuy
No image available
Toshiba Canvio Basics 4 TB USB Type-A / Micro-USB B
A portable HDD for files taken between locations. The name specifies 4 TB and USB Type-A / Micro-USB B; check the connection and file system are compatible with your group’s computers. The product information says it needs reformatting for macOS; back up your files before doing so.
Joybuy
No image available
Samsung Portable SSD T7 2 TB USB Type-C blue
A portable SSD for transferring video files. Check whether 2 TB is enough for your collection. The product name specifies USB Type-C and USB 3.2 Gen 2; check that your equipment is compatible.
Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is one external drive enough for a back-up?
No, not as your only recovery option. For important data, the NCSC recommends the 3-2-1 rule: keep multiple copies, use different types of media and store one copy in another location. Also test that you can restore your files.
Can the group use a new drive straight away on both Windows and Mac?
That depends on the file system, connection and exact model. Toshiba says the Canvio Basics variant reviewed is supplied in NTFS format and needs to be reformatted for macOS. Back up any files before reformatting.
What ongoing arrangements should the group factor in?
Allow for the space and management needed for a separate back-up, as well as the main drive. Check the warranty and any data recovery service terms for the exact variant; such a service is no substitute for a working, separate back-up.
Can the group keep videos showing identifiable people on an external drive?
According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, identifiable people in videos are personal data. The group needs an appropriate GDPR legal basis for processing, must decide on suitable security measures and must not keep footage for longer than necessary. The GDPR does not set one general retention period for this; whether keeping specific footage is lawful depends on the purpose and circumstances.