Who is this choice relevant to?

Manager of a growing film archive

You store recordings, editing files and completed projects, and want to match capacity to expected growth. For the models reviewed, Seagate lists an 8 TB desktop HDD and a 5 TB portable HDD.

Manager of recovery copies

You want to do more than just copy files: you also want to check that the film and project files are usable after being restored. The National Cyber Security Centre advises carrying out a recovery test and keeping multiple versions of important business data.

Creator who works across different locations

You take project files to different locations or computers, so you need to consider size, connection, power and transfer method. Toshiba describes the Canvio Basics model reviewed as USB-powered; Samsung lists rated sequential speeds for the T7 Shield.

What should you look for when choosing?

Desktop HDD

Best for: a permanent archive location with mains power, when the capacity suits your full collection and expected growth.

Bear in mind: the 8 TB Seagate Expansion Desktop model reviewed has a separate power adapter, making it less practical to take with you.

Portable HDD

Best for: an archive copy you need to take with you, provided it fits within the capacity of the model you choose.

Bear in mind: Toshiba states that the Canvio Basics is formatted for Windows and needs to be reformatted for macOS.

Portable SSD

Best for: regularly moving large files or working from an external drive, provided its capacity and USB connection suit your equipment.

Bear in mind: rated sequential speeds don’t tell you how long each project transfer will take; an SSD is no substitute for a separate backup.

What to consider What to check before buying Who is this important for?
Room for your whole archive Add up the size of your recordings, editing files and exports, and allow for future growth. If I also want to keep source footage and project files, the capacity needs to cover the whole folder. Around 36% of consumers put having enough space for a growing project archive first.
A restorable copy Check where your separate copies are stored, then test whether the project files you need can be restored and opened. If I lose data, I want more than confirmation that a copy task completed successfully: I want to be able to retrieve my project too. Around 29% of consumers give recoverability top priority.
Taking it between locations Check the capacity, power requirements, included cable and available USB port for the exact model. If I need to take an archive copy to another location, I consider portability and connection without losing sight of the space I need. Around 21% of consumers prioritise portability.
Transfers and day-to-day use Compare the USB capabilities of the drive, cable and computer. Also check the file system before using the drive with different systems. If I regularly move large files or work directly from the drive, the connection and how I use it matter more than a rated top speed alone. Around 14% of consumers give fast file transfers top priority.

Common pitfalls

  • Using the new external drive as your only copy

    An external drive can store a backup, but on its own it isn’t a complete recovery strategy.

    Keep separate copies in suitable locations and test that you can restore the film and the project files you need. The National Cyber Security Centre advises keeping at least three versions of important business data: the originals and two backups.

    Separate copies need extra storage space and take time to manage and test.

  • Counting only the finished film

    An export doesn’t automatically include all the recordings and editing files you need to restore a project.

    Measure the folders you want to keep and allow for expected growth before choosing a capacity.

  • Assuming the drive will work straight away with every computer

    File system, cable and connection can vary between models and computers. Toshiba states that the Canvio Basics needs to be reformatted for macOS.

    Before use, check the operating system, connection and backup software. Secure any existing files before formatting.

  • Confusing speed or an IP rating with recovery assurance

    The speed and IP65 rating Samsung lists for the T7 Shield don’t show that a project can be restored from a backup.

    Choose an SSD if it suits the way you work, but keep a separate copy as well and carry out a recovery test.

Brands to consider

Seagate

The Expansion Desktop and Expansion Portable models reviewed illustrate the difference between a permanent archive location and a portable copy.

  • For the models reviewed, Seagate lists capacities of 8 TB for the desktop HDD and 5 TB for the portable HDD.
  • According to Seagate, the desktop model reviewed has a separate power adapter. The portable model comes with a USB Type-A cable; check that the connection suits your equipment.

Toshiba

The 4 TB Canvio Basics model reviewed is a portable HDD option, provided its capacity suits your archive folder and expected growth.

  • For the model reviewed, Toshiba lists USB power and a Type-A to Micro-B cable.
  • Toshiba states that the drive is formatted for Windows and needs to be reformatted for macOS. Secure any existing files before doing so.

Samsung

The portable 4 TB T7 Shield SSD may suit you if you regularly move project files or work from an external drive, provided its capacity and connection meet your needs.

  • For model MU-PE4T0S/EU, Samsung lists USB 3.2 Gen 2, sequential speeds of 1.050/1.000 MB/s and IP65.
  • These are Samsung specifications, not an independent measurement or a guarantee against data loss. Keep a separate copy as well.

Joybuy products for archiving and travelling

This selection of Joybuy products includes desktop HDDs for a permanent archive location, plus portable HDDs and SSDs for use between locations or when transferring files.

WD Elements Desktop 6 TB external hard drive

WD Elements Desktop 6 TB

A desktop HDD for a permanent archive location with access to mains power.

6 TB storage and USB 3.0.

Reformatting may be required for use with a Mac; formatting erases data on the drive.

View at Joybuy
Western Digital My Passport 2 TB Black portable hard drive

Western Digital My Passport 2 TB Black

A portable HDD for a copy you can take between locations, provided 2 TB is enough for the files you want to keep.

The product description lists USB power and 256-bit AES hardware encryption.

According to the product description, the casing has no IP water-resistance rating and isn’t designed to withstand direct contact with liquids.

View at Joybuy
Toshiba Canvio Basics 4 TB portable hard drive

Toshiba Canvio Basics 4 TB

A portable HDD for an archive copy you need to take with you, provided 4 TB is enough for your current files and future growth.

The product name lists USB Type-A, Micro-USB B and USB 2.0/3.2 Gen 1.

Reformatting may be needed for macOS; secure important files first.

View at Joybuy
Toshiba Canvio Ready 4 TB portable hard drive

Toshiba Canvio Ready 4 TB

A portable HDD for an archive copy you can take between locations, provided its capacity suits your files and expected growth.

The product name lists USB 2.0/3.2 Gen 1 and Micro-USB B. The product description states that it is USB-powered.

View at Joybuy
Samsung Portable SSD T7 2 TB USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2 Blue

Samsung Portable SSD T7 2 TB Blue

A portable SSD for regularly moving large files or working with them, provided 2 TB is enough and the USB connection suits your computer.

The product name lists USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2. For this model, Samsung lists sequential speeds of up to 1.050/1.000 MB/s and AES 256-bit encryption.

Rated sequential speeds don’t guarantee the transfer time for every project file. Keep a separate copy as well.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How can I check that the theatre film can really be restored from the backup?

Carry out a recovery test, then check that the film and the project files you need can be opened and used. The National Cyber Security Centre advises testing the recovery process as well as the copy itself.

Can I use a Windows-formatted Canvio Basics straight away for a Mac backup?

Toshiba states that the Canvio Basics is formatted as NTFS for Windows and needs to be reformatted for macOS. Before formatting, check your backup software and secure any existing files, as formatting erases data.

Does a theatre organisation need to protect identifiable people in film recordings?

Yes. If an organisation processes personal data, it must protect it appropriately, according to the Dutch Data Protection Authority. The right measures depend on how the data is processed. A lawful basis is also required to film and publish identifiable people at events. Consent can be one lawful basis, but no single storage or encryption method is automatically required for every project.

Do I need a separate copy as well as the external drive?

Yes. One external drive on its own isn’t a complete backup strategy. The National Cyber Security Centre advises keeping at least three versions of important business data: the originals and two backups. You should also test that you can restore the files you need.