Who should consider this choice?

Groups using Windows and Mac computers

You share recordings and want everyone to be able to read and write files. Check the file format, ports and cables on the computers used by your group. Apple Support explains that a Mac may be able to read NTFS but not write to it.

People managing recordings with recognisable voices

You need to decide who receives copies and how the files are protected. The Dutch Data Protection Authority cites recognisable audio recordings as an example of personal data; this privacy consideration is separate from choosing between an HDD and an SSD.

People managing a growing recording archive

You’re storing more and more sessions and want a separate backup as well as the copy used for transfers. Compare the size of your current files with expected growth before choosing a capacity. Safe Internetting describes a backup as a copy of files.

What should you look for?

Start with the computers you use and how you share recordings. Then choose the type and capacity of storage that suit your transport and archiving needs.

What to consider What should you check? Who should pay particular attention?
Sharing between computers Check that the file format allows you to read and write files on all the computers you use. Also check that the ports and cables are compatible. I want every group member to be able to read and write files on their own computer. Around 33% of consumers prioritise sharing between computers.
Protecting voices Check how authorised recipients will access the files and agree separately on who will receive copies. If recordings contain recognisable voices, I want to limit access to the intended recipients. Around 25% of consumers prioritise protecting voices when sharing recordings.
Archive space and backups Compare the stated capacity in TB with your current file size and expected growth. Arrange a backup that is separate from the drive used for transfers. I want space for new sessions and a recovery copy in addition to the drive that gets passed around. Around 25% of consumers prioritise archive space and recovery.
Carrying and transferring files Check that the connection is compatible with the computers you use. Don’t treat a stated maximum speed as a real-world test with your equipment and files. If the drive is carried around frequently, I want to be able to transfer recordings at different times. Around 17% of consumers prioritise portability and repeated transfers.

Common pitfalls

  • Checking only the USB connector

    A compatible connection doesn’t automatically mean that every computer can write to the file format on the drive. Apple Support warns that a Mac may not be able to write to NTFS.

    Check the ports, cables and file formats used by the group’s computers. If you’re going to format the drive, first make a copy of any existing files elsewhere; formatting erases the files on the drive.

    Allow time to back up your files safely and reformat the drive.

  • Using the shared drive as your only archive

    If the drive used for transfers is lost or stops working, you won’t have a second copy to fall back on unless you have a separate backup.

    Keep a recent backup separate from the drive that group members share.

  • Assuming a fast or rugged SSD solves privacy concerns

    A speed rating or casing doesn’t determine who can receive recognisable recordings. The Dutch Data Protection Authority cites recognisable audio recordings as personal data; organisations must follow rules on protecting and sharing personal data.

    Agree on who can access the recordings and for what purpose. If they contain personal data, consider which legal basis and security measures are appropriate for the specific use.

Brands to compare

Samsung

The T7 Shield is a portable SSD range worth comparing if you’ll be carrying the drive around regularly. For the 1 TB black MU-PE1T0S/EU, Samsung lists USB-C-to-C and USB-C-to-A cables, as well as optional password protection.

  • For this model, Samsung claims read speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s, write speeds of 1.000 MB/s and an IP65 rating. These are manufacturer specifications, not results from testing with voice recordings.
  • Check that all authorised recipients can access the files using the chosen security feature.

Western Digital

Elements Portable is a portable HDD range worth comparing when archive space is your priority. Western Digital lists model WDBU6Y0020BBK-WESN, with a capacity of 2 TB.

  • For this model, Western Digital lists USB 3.2 Gen 1/USB 3.0 and a two-year limited warranty.
  • These model specifications don’t, by themselves, say anything about the speed or reliability of other Western Digital ranges.

Kingston

XS1000 is a compact external SSD range for transferring files. Kingston lists support for USB Type-A and Type-C.

  • Kingston lists USB 3.2 Gen 2 and speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s for the XS1000 range.
  • Check the capacity and colour variant you choose, as well as the connection supplied; the stated speed isn’t a test using your group’s computers.

Seagate

Expansion Portable is a portable HDD range worth comparing for storage and transport. Seagate lists the 2 TB version, model STKM2000400, among its options.

  • Seagate’s user guide describes a USB micro-B-to-USB-A cable for this range.
  • Check the connection if group members only have USB-C ports; don’t assume models with different codes are the same version.

Toshiba

Canvio Basics is a portable HDD range worth considering alongside other HDD options for storing recordings.

  • For Canvio Basics, Toshiba lists USB 3.2 Gen 1, capacities of up to 4 TB and compatibility with Windows straight out of the box.
  • Check the file format if Mac users also need to write to the drive; Canvio Ready features aren’t necessarily the same.

Joybuy products

These portable SSDs and HDDs are options for storing and transferring recordings; check the connection and computer compatibility for each model.

SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB

SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB

A portable SSD option for storing files and sharing them between group members.

Check that the connection is compatible with the computers used by your group.

View at Joybuy
SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1TB 2000MB/s

SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1TB 2000MB/s

A portable SSD option if you regularly carry and transfer recordings.

According to the product information, the stated maximum speed requires a compatible USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 host; actual speeds may vary.

View at Joybuy
My Passport for Mac 2TB Blue

My Passport for Mac 2TB Blue

A portable HDD option for storing and transferring files from a Mac.

The product information describes use with Mac; check compatibility before sharing this drive with Windows computers.

View at Joybuy
My Passport 6TB White

My Passport 6TB White

A portable HDD option for storing a larger recording archive.

The product information doesn’t confirm Mac compatibility; check this if group members need to use the drive with Mac computers.

View at Joybuy
My Passport 2TB Blue

My Passport 2TB Blue

A portable HDD option for storing and copying recordings.

The product information doesn’t confirm Mac compatibility; check this if the drive will be used with different computers.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can you use the same drive with a Windows PC and a Mac?

Yes, as long as the connection and file format are compatible with both computers. Apple Support lists exFAT as a format compatible with Windows and warns that a Mac may not be able to write to NTFS. Seagate says exFAT isn’t suitable for Time Machine. Back up your files elsewhere before formatting, as formatting erases the drive.

How can you prevent files being lost when the drive is passed between group members?

Keep a recent, separate backup; the drive shared between members shouldn’t be the only copy you keep. After copying, check that the intended files are there, and safely eject the drive in Windows before unplugging it.

Is encryption always built in and usable on every computer?

No. Check the security features of the model you choose and whether authorised recipients can open the files. Microsoft says BitLocker Drive Encryption is available on Windows Pro, Enterprise and Education devices, but not on Windows Home.

Can a group simply copy and share recordings containing recognisable voices?

First check which privacy rules apply to the way the recordings will be used. The Dutch Data Protection Authority cites recognisable audio recordings as personal data; organisations need a legal basis under the GDPR to process personal data and must also consider any further sharing. Consent is one possible legal basis, but it isn’t automatically the only or the right one for every recording. The appropriate legal basis and measures depend on the recordings, the recipients and the original purpose.