Who is this choice relevant to?

Manager of a large photo archive

You mainly need enough space for your photo files and their backups in one permanent location.

Photographer who takes their backup with them

You move your backup regularly and want to weigh the capacity you need against the transfer speed you’d like.

Shared computer user

You want to know which files are copied and who can access the backup. The right access controls depend on how it’s used.

What should you consider when choosing an external backup drive?

First decide which files you need to back up and how much space they’ll require. Then choose between a drive that stays in one place and one that’s easier to take with you. Finally, check that the connection and access arrangements suit your shared workstation.

What to consider What to look for when buying Who is this most relevant to?
Capacity for photos and catalogue Add together the photo files, catalogue and any other files you want to keep, then compare the total with the capacity of the exact model. If I want to keep my entire archive in one place, the drive needs to have room for all the files I need. Around 40% of consumers put capacity at the top of their list when buying.
Portability and transfers Check the connection and the cable supplied. Also find out whether the drive can be used without a separate mains adapter. If you move your backup regularly, you’ll want to know whether the drive suits your workstation and how you plan to use it. Around 30% of consumers prioritise portability and transfer time.
Completeness and recovery Check which files the software copies and whether you can recover both your photos and the catalogue information you need. If I want to restore my photo library later, I need to keep more than just the catalogue; I also need to know where the photos are. Around 20% of consumers say a complete, recoverable copy is their top buying concern.
Access on a shared workstation Decide who can access the drive. Check whether you need encryption and how you can regain access if you lose the password. If not every user should be able to view the same photos, I want to check in advance how the backup is protected. Around 10% of consumers put access management first.

Common buying mistakes

  • Keeping only the catalogue and assuming the photos are included

    According to Adobe, Lightroom Classic’s built-in catalogue backup only includes the catalogue file. Photo files and exports need to be backed up separately.

    Check which files your photo software includes, and make separate copies of your photos, catalogue and any necessary exports if needed. Test that you can restore those files.

  • Using a connected drive as your only backup

    An external drive can also fail or become inaccessible. If it’s your only copy, you may have no second backup available when that happens.

    Keep a separate backup as well as your working copy, and regularly check that you can recover the files you need.

  • Checking the power supply and formatting only after you’ve bought it

    The Seagate Expansion desktop range reviewed here uses an external power adapter. Toshiba says the Canvio Basics model reviewed here is formatted as NTFS for Windows and needs to be reformatted for macOS.

    Check that the exact model is compatible with the connections and operating systems on your computers. Before formatting, check whether the drive contains any files you want to keep.

Brands to consider

Toshiba

Canvio Basics is a portable HDD range for anyone looking for USB-powered storage, with models available up to 4 TB.

  • Toshiba says the model reviewed here works with Windows straight out of the box.
  • The model reviewed here is formatted as NTFS and, according to Toshiba, needs to be reformatted for macOS.

Seagate

The Expansion desktop range is designed for a permanent backup location and offers a choice of higher capacities.

  • For the desktop model reviewed here, Seagate specifies USB 3.0 and an external power adapter.
  • Check the exact model and what’s included. A data recovery service is no substitute for keeping your own backup.

Samsung

The T7 Shield is a portable SSD range for anyone who values fast transfers and portability.

  • For the black 2TB model, Samsung specifies USB 3.2 Gen 2 and sequential speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s read and 1.000 MB/s write.
  • These are Samsung’s specifications for that model, not measured backup speeds on your workstation.

SanDisk

The Extreme PRO Portable SSD (V3) is an external SSD range for demanding transfers. Check that your workstation’s connection is compatible with the model you choose.

  • For the 2TB model, SanDisk specifies sequential read speeds of up to 4.000 MB/s and a five-year limited manufacturer’s warranty.
  • The stated maximum speed doesn’t determine the transfer speed on a particular computer.

Joybuy products for backing up a photo catalogue

These products include portable HDDs for anyone looking for capacity and portability, portable SSDs for transfers, and a desktop HDD for a permanent backup location.

Western Digital My Passport USB-C 4TB Black

Western Digital My Passport USB-C 4TB Black

A 4 TB portable HDD for an archive where capacity and portability both matter.

USB bus-powered; exFAT; password protection with AES 256-bit hardware encryption; compact 2.5-inch design.

View at Joybuy
Toshiba Canvio Basics 4 TB, USB Type-A and Micro-USB B

Toshiba Canvio Basics 4 TB

A 4 TB portable HDD for anyone who wants to move a backup without a separate mains adapter.

USB bus-powered; USB 3.2 Gen 1; USB Type-A and Micro-USB B. Formatted for Windows; reformat for macOS.

View at Joybuy
Samsung Portable SSD T7 2TB USB Type-C, blue

Samsung Portable SSD T7 2TB USB Type-C, blue

A 2 TB portable SSD for anyone who transfers large files and wants a drive they can take with them.

USB 3.2 Gen 2; sequential speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s read and 1.000 MB/s write; AES 256-bit hardware encryption. Includes USB-C-to-C and USB-C-to-A cables; compatible with Windows and macOS.

View at Joybuy
Samsung MU-PE2T0R 2TB USB Type-C, blue

Samsung MU-PE2T0R 2TB USB Type-C, blue

A 2 TB portable SSD for transferring large files from a workstation with a compatible connection.

USB 3.2 Gen 2; stated sequential speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s read and 1.000 MB/s write. The product description lists IP65; this doesn’t mean the drive can be submerged.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Desktop Storage 8 TB

WD Elements Desktop Storage 8 TB

An 8 TB desktop storage drive for a large backup kept in one place.

USB 3.0; backwards compatible with USB 2.0; plug-and-play use with Windows 10 and later.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does backing up a photo catalogue automatically copy the photos too?

Not necessarily. According to Adobe, Lightroom Classic’s built-in backup only includes the catalogue file; you need to back up photos and exported files separately. Check which files the backup feature includes in other software.

Do I need to format a new external drive for the computers on the workstation?

It depends on the drive and the computers you use. Toshiba says the Canvio Basics model reviewed here is formatted as NTFS for Windows and needs to be reformatted for macOS. Before formatting, check whether it contains any files you want to keep.

How can I keep a backup usable?

Make a recent copy regularly and check that you can recover the files you need. Safe Internet recommends automatic or manual backups and suggests using encryption if appropriate. Keeping a second copy separately reduces your reliance on a single drive.

Does the GDPR always require an encrypted photo drive?

Assess security based on how the drive is used and the risks involved; don’t assume one measure will be enough in every situation. The Dutch Data Protection Authority notes an exception for strictly personal or household use. When an organisation processes personal data, appropriate security measures must be determined based on the risks, including who can access photos on the shared workstation.

What can I do if the drive breaks too soon during normal use?

For a consumer purchase in the Netherlands, the seller is responsible for the statutory guarantee if the product doesn’t meet the standard you were entitled to expect. This statutory right is separate from any limited manufacturer’s warranty; what’s appropriate depends on the circumstances of the fault.