Who is this guide for?

Photographers with a growing archive

You keep large project folders and need space for a separate local copy that can grow with your archive. The Consumentenbond and product specifications from Toshiba and Seagate offer useful points to consider when choosing storage capacity.

Photographers with a regular backup routine

You want to know which folders are copied and whether you’ll be able to restore your files later. VeiligInternetten, the Consumentenbond, Apple and Microsoft outline key considerations for backups and recovery.

Photographers who move projects between locations

You switch between workspaces or open large files directly from the drive. This makes transfer speeds, portability and compatible connections more important when choosing a drive. Samsung and Crucial list model specifications you can compare.

What should you look for?

Portable HDD

Best for: regular copies of large photo folders when you want to be able to take the drive with you.

Bear in mind: mechanical drives are more susceptible to knocks; also check the capacity and file system of the specific version.

Desktop HDD

Best for: backups from a fixed workspace where space for a growing archive is the priority.

Bear in mind: the Seagate Expansion Desktop model reviewed uses an external power adapter, so you’ll need a mains socket and a permanent place for it.

External SSD

Best for: frequent transfers of large projects, opening files directly from the drive or taking your copy with you.

Bear in mind: a quoted maximum speed doesn’t guarantee how quickly a complete photo folder will transfer; an SSD is no substitute for a second copy.

First, work out how much space your current folders and future projects will need. Then check that your backup software includes the right folders and that you can connect the drive in the way you want.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Space for your archive Check the size of your project folders and compare it with the capacity of the specific version. Allow for future projects and any older versions you want to keep. If I want room for my growing photo archive, I compare the capacity with my folders and planned copies. Around 36% of consumers prioritise archive storage space.
Restorable backup Check which folders the software includes and try restoring a file. Don’t keep the only version on the external drive. If I need to be able to rely on the copy, I want to know which project folders it contains and whether restoration works. Around 29% of consumers give recoverability top priority.
Transfer time Compare speeds only for the exact model, and check your computer’s port and cable. A maximum sequential speed doesn’t necessarily predict how long it will take to copy a folder containing lots of files. If I often move large projects or work directly from the drive, I pay extra attention to transfer speeds. Around 21% of consumers prioritise transfer time.
Portability and connections Check the connection, cable, power supply and file system against your devices and backup software. Back up existing files before reformatting. If I take my drive between workspaces, I want it to be practical to connect in each location. Around 14% of consumers choose mainly based on portability and connections.

Common pitfalls

  • Moving the only copy and calling it a backup

    An external drive is only a backup if the original files are also kept elsewhere. Otherwise, a fault, loss or accidental deletion could affect your only copy.

    Keep the original files until you’ve checked the copy, and try restoring a file. The Consumentenbond advises disconnecting an external drive after making a backup.

    If the drive stays connected all the time, your backup remains connected to your computer too.

  • Confusing USB interface speed with copy speed

    A quoted maximum interface speed isn’t the same as the speed at which a complete folder containing lots of photos will be copied. SSD performance can also vary between systems.

    Check the port and cable, and compare only speeds quoted for the same model under the same conditions. Don’t assume a fixed copy time based on a single maximum figure.

  • Choosing a desktop HDD without considering its power supply

    The Seagate Expansion Desktop model reviewed uses an external power adapter, which affects where you can make your backup.

    Choose this option for a fixed workspace if you have room for the adapter and a mains socket.

    You’ll need a suitable space and a mains socket to use the adapter.

  • Reformatting without securing your files first

    Changing the file system can erase data on the drive. Toshiba lists NTFS for Canvio Basics and says it needs to be reformatted for macOS; Apple warns that setting up Time Machine may require you to erase the drive.

    Check which file system your backup method needs, and copy existing files elsewhere before erasing or reformatting the drive.

Brands to consider

Western Digital

My Passport is a range of portable HDDs. Western Digital lists a 5 TB version in black, model number WDBPKJ0050BBK-WESN.

  • A portable HDD is worth considering if you want to keep a large local copy without a desktop enclosure.
  • Compare it as an HDD, not against SSD speeds. The extended warranty mentioned by Western Digital applies to purchases from WesternDigital.com and won’t necessarily apply when buying from other retailers.

Seagate

Expansion Desktop is a range of desktop HDDs for storage in a fixed workspace. Seagate lists, among others, a 4 TB version.

  • The version mentioned has a USB-C connection and an external power adapter; both are worth considering for your setup.
  • The duration and cover of Rescue Data Recovery Services may vary by region. Don’t treat this service as a substitute for a separate backup.

Samsung

The Portable SSD T7 Shield is a portable SSD option. The Dutch product page is for the black 2TB version, MU-PE2T0S/EU.

  • Samsung specifies sequential speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s for reads and 1.000 MB/s for writes via USB 3.2 Gen 2, and lists IP65-rated protection.
  • These are Samsung’s specifications, not independently measured speeds on your computer or a guarantee against data loss. Check that your port and cable are compatible with the exact model.

Toshiba

Canvio Basics is a range of portable, USB-powered HDDs, including a 4 TB version.

  • Toshiba says the drive is ready to use with NTFS for Windows.
  • According to Toshiba, it needs to be reformatted for macOS. The quoted maximum interface speed of 5,0 Gbit/s is not the HDD’s measured copy speed.

Crucial

X9 Pro is a range of compact external SSDs. The product page consulted is specifically for the 2TB version, CT2000X9PROSSD9.

  • Crucial quotes speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s for both reads and writes, and says the drive comes formatted as exFAT.
  • Crucial notes that performance can vary between systems. Reformatting erases any data already on the drive.

Joybuy products

This product selection focuses on portable and desktop HDDs for local photo backups, with versions to suit different storage needs and connections.

WD Elements Portable 5TB USB-C, Graphite Black

WD Elements Portable 5TB USB-C, Graphite Black

This portable external HDD is an option if your project folders fit within 5 TB and you want to be able to take the drive with you.

The product information lists USB-C and pre-formatting for Windows and Mac; check that the connection is compatible with your computer and backup method.

Joybuy
WD My Passport for Mac 2TB Blue

WD My Passport for Mac 2TB Blue

This portable drive is an option for a Mac backup if 2 TB is enough for the folders you want to keep.

According to the product description, the drive is pre-formatted for Mac and compatible with Time Machine. The description also lists a weight of 120 g.

Joybuy
WD Elements Desktop 6TB USB 3.0

WD Elements Desktop 6TB USB 3.0

This desktop HDD is an option for a fixed workspace if 6 TB is enough for your growing archive.

The product information lists USB 3.0 and an external power adapter. The description says it is pre-formatted for Windows; check that this suits your backup method.

Joybuy
WD My Passport USB-C 5TB Black

WD My Passport USB-C 5TB Black

This portable external HDD is an option if your photo folders fit within 5 TB and you want to take the drive with you.

The product information lists USB-C and exFAT. Check that the connection and file system are compatible with your devices and backup method.

Joybuy
WD My Passport USB-C 1TB Black

WD My Passport USB-C 1TB Black

This portable HDD is an option if 1 TB is enough for the folders and copies you want to keep.

The product information lists USB-C, exFAT and USB power. The description says it works with Windows, Mac, Android and iOS; check that the connection is compatible with your devices.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How do I choose the right capacity for backing up large project folders?

Check the size of the folders you want to protect and decide how many future projects and older versions you want to keep on the same drive. For a complete Mac backup using Time Machine, Apple recommends a drive with at least twice the storage capacity of your Mac; this isn’t automatically a minimum for a copy of just your photo folders.

Does Windows File History include my project folder if it’s outside the default folders?

Check this first: Microsoft says you can add folders from other locations to an existing or new library. Check which folders are selected, then try restoring a file.

Can I use a drive formatted for Windows as a Time Machine drive straight away?

Don’t assume so without checking. Toshiba lists NTFS for Canvio Basics and says it needs to be reformatted for macOS; Apple says setting up Time Machine may require you to erase the drive. Secure any existing files first.

What does the warranty cover if the drive develops a fault?

For consumers in the Netherlands, statutory warranty rights apply alongside any manufacturer’s warranty. ACM ConsuWijzer says the retailer must resolve, at no cost, an issue with a product that breaks sooner than you could reasonably expect under normal use. Keep your photos somewhere else too: replacing the drive won’t automatically restore your files.

Do privacy rules apply because there are people in my photos?

The Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens describes an exception for photos that someone keeps for private use or shares with a very limited circle. This exception doesn’t necessarily apply to business or commercial activities or wider publication; assess these uses separately. Buying an external drive doesn’t in itself determine which rules apply to how you use your photos.