Who is this buying guide for?

Manager of a growing photo archive

You want room for new photos, so you’re comparing drive capacities as well as connections and how the archive is managed. The Consumentenbond covers capacity as one factor when choosing between types of external storage.

Volunteer responsible for restoring files

You want to know whether photos can be restored after an error or drive failure. A drive is only one part of your routine: the Digital Trust Center recommends keeping copies in different locations or in different formats, and testing your ability to restore them regularly.

Volunteer who transfers photos

You move files between locations or computers, so portability, connections and file formats matter. Seagate and Samsung describe portable storage options for transferring files.

What should you consider when buying?

First, work out how much storage you need and how you’ll restore files. Then compare HDDs and SSDs based on how often the copy will be moved, and check that the drive works with volunteers’ computers and file formats.

What to consider What should you look at? Who is this most important for?
Room to grow Check the size of your photo folders, allow for growth and check the available capacity after formatting. If I want room for both my current collection and new photos, capacity comes first. Around 25% of consumers say storage capacity is their main concern when buying.
Restoring files Agree how often you’ll make a copy, where a second copy will be kept and when you’ll test restoring photos. If I need to restore photos after an error or drive failure, I look beyond the drive itself. Around 25% of consumers say the ability to restore files is their main concern when buying.
Access and privacy Decide who needs access and how the drive, passwords and any recovery keys will be managed. If photos show identifiable people, I want to manage access and storage carefully. Around 20% of consumers say access security is their main concern when buying.
Taking it between locations Compare the size, power requirements and cable; when transporting the drive, bear in mind that HDDs and SSDs differ in how vulnerable they are to knocks. If I regularly take the copy with me, portability is a factor in my choice. Around 15% of consumers say portability is their main concern when buying.
Working with computers Check the ports, included cable and file format for the computers you want to use the files on. If volunteers use different computers, I want to know in advance whether the drive will connect and be readable on them. Around 15% of consumers say computer compatibility is their main concern when buying.

Common pitfalls

  • Relying on an external drive as your only back-up

    Even a local copy can become unusable or inaccessible if something goes wrong.

    Decide where a separate copy will be kept, and periodically test restoring a few photos. The Digital Trust Center recommends storing copies in different locations or in different formats.

  • Looking only at the stated capacity in TB

    Not all the stated capacity will be available for storage, and a photo archive can grow.

    Check the size of your current folders, allow for new photos and confirm the usable capacity of the specific model.

  • Assuming every USB drive will work straight away with every computer

    A suitable connection doesn’t automatically mean a computer can read the file format without preparation. Reformatting can erase existing data.

    Check the ports, cable and file format of the drive you choose before making your first copy.

  • Confusing drive encryption with a complete privacy policy

    If photos show identifiable people, they may contain personal data. The right security measures depend on how the data is processed and the risks involved.

    Decide who has access, how passwords or recovery keys will be managed and how long the archive should be kept for its intended purpose. The Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens notes that the GDPR does not set a general fixed retention period for personal data.

Brands to consider

Toshiba

Canvio Basics is a range of portable HDDs for local storage. According to Toshiba, Canvio Advance also comes with back-up and security software.

  • The EMEA specification for Canvio Basics lists models with capacities of up to 4 TB and USB power.
  • Canvio Basics is supplied formatted as NTFS for Windows; Toshiba says it needs reformatting for use with macOS. Check the exact model and how you plan to use it.

Western Digital

My Passport is a range of portable HDDs for local file copies. Check the features of the specific model.

  • Western Digital lists features including back-up software and password protection with hardware encryption for My Passport.
  • Check that the available software and features suit the computers you use and how the archive is managed. These manufacturer specifications don’t tell you how well your own recovery routine will work.

Seagate

Expansion Portable is a range of portable storage; Expansion Desktop is a separate range designed for use with a power adapter.

  • Seagate lists USB 3.0 and support for Windows, macOS and ChromeOS for Expansion Portable.
  • According to Seagate, the Expansion Desktop model requires a power adapter. Check the model and file format before sharing the drive.

Samsung

The Portable SSD T7 Shield may suit a working copy that’s often taken on the move or used to transfer large files.

  • For the Dutch 2TB model MU-PE2T0S/EU, Samsung specifies USB 3.2 Gen 2 and sequential speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s read and 1.000 MB/s write.
  • These are Samsung’s specifications; actual speeds also depend on the connected equipment. An SSD is no substitute for a separate copy.

Joybuy products

This selection includes portable external SSDs for taking with you and transferring files, as well as external HDDs for storing a photo archive locally.

SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1TB

SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1TB

A portable SSD for taking a local copy between archive locations.

1 TB storage; USB-C and USB bus-powered. The description lists 256-bit AES password protection, IP65 dust and water resistance, and drop protection up to 3 m. The stated read speed of up to 2.000 MB/s requires a compatible USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 device; the write speed is lower.

One drive isn’t a separate second copy. The Digital Trust Center recommends using multiple storage locations or formats and testing file recovery.

Joybuy
Portable SSD 1TB 1000MB/s

Portable SSD 1TB 1000MB/s

A portable SSD for a local copy of your photos that you can take between locations.

1 TB storage and USB-C. The product description lists drop protection up to 2 m.

One drive isn’t a separate second copy. The Digital Trust Center recommends using multiple storage locations or formats and testing file recovery.

Joybuy
WD My Passport 6TB White

WD My Passport 6TB White

A portable HDD for a local archive where plenty of storage space is important.

6 TB storage. The product description lists password protection, 256-bit AES hardware encryption and back-up software. The Consumentenbond notes that HDDs are more vulnerable to knocks than SSDs, so bear this in mind when transporting the drive.

One drive isn’t a separate second copy. The Digital Trust Center recommends using multiple storage locations or formats and testing file recovery.

Joybuy
WD My Passport 4TB Black

WD My Passport 4TB Black

A portable HDD for local photo storage, with listed access-control features.

4 TB storage. The product description lists USB-C, exFAT, password protection, AES 256-bit hardware encryption and automatic back-up software. The Consumentenbond notes that HDDs are more vulnerable to knocks than SSDs.

One drive isn’t a separate second copy. The Digital Trust Center recommends using multiple storage locations or formats and testing file recovery.

Joybuy
Toshiba Canvio Basics 4TB

Toshiba Canvio Basics 4TB

A portable HDD for a local copy of a larger photo collection.

4 TB storage, USB 3.2 Gen 1 and compatibility with USB 2.0 are listed in the product description; the drive is USB-powered. Toshiba says Canvio Basics is formatted as NTFS for Windows and needs reformatting for macOS. The Consumentenbond notes that HDDs are more vulnerable to knocks than SSDs.

One drive isn’t a separate second copy. The Digital Trust Center recommends using multiple storage locations or formats and testing file recovery.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How can you tell if your photo back-up is working?

Periodically restore a few photos from the copy to check that it works. The Digital Trust Center also recommends keeping a recent back-up and storing copies in different locations or formats; a single drive won’t provide that separation on its own.

Does a new external drive need formatting before use?

It depends on the model and the computers you want to use the drive with. Toshiba, for example, says Canvio Basics is supplied formatted as NTFS for Windows and needs reformatting for macOS. Check this before copying photos: formatting can erase data already on the drive.

What can you do if a drive you’ve bought fails prematurely?

For a consumer purchase in the Netherlands, the seller is responsible if a product doesn’t meet what you could reasonably expect under normal use. ACM ConsuWijzer lists free repair, replacement or a refund as possible solutions. If you’re buying on behalf of an organisation, check which terms and conditions apply; consumer rights don’t automatically apply to that kind of purchase.

Does the GDPR also apply to photos in a community archive?

It may do if photos show identifiable people and an organisation processes that personal data. The exception for purely personal or household use doesn’t automatically apply to an organisation. According to the Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens, appropriate security depends on the risks, and the GDPR doesn’t set a general fixed retention period for personal data. So having an encrypted drive alone doesn’t determine whether the archive as a whole complies with the rules.