Which drive is right for you?

Photographers with a growing home archive

You copy lots of photos from a desktop computer and want to know how much space future backups will need. The Consumers' Association compares external HDDs and SSDs, while Intenso, for example, documents an 8 TB desktop model.

Photographers who move their drives around

You regularly take a drive with you or switch between computers. USB power, the connection and the file system all matter. Toshiba and Seagate document USB-powered HDDs, while Samsung specifies the T7 Shield as a portable SSD.

Photographers who want to check they can restore their files

You want to be able to restore not just the catalogue, but your photos and exports too, and keep a separate copy. Adobe makes clear that a Lightroom Classic catalogue backup contains only the catalogue file.

What should you consider when choosing?

Start with the files you want to be able to restore. Then compare the storage space you need, the connection and how often you move large files.

Desktop HDD

A good fit for: a fixed workstation where you regularly copy a growing photo archive.

Bear in mind: the documented 8 TB Intenso Memory Center is a 3.5-inch drive with a separate mains adapter, so it needs a power socket.

Portable HDD

A good fit for: a drive you want to disconnect or move after backing up, without needing a separate mains adapter.

Bear in mind: the cable and file system vary by model. For the Canvio Basics model reviewed, Toshiba lists NTFS for Windows and says it needs reformatting for the macOS versions specified.

Portable SSD

A good fit for: anyone who regularly moves large files or also uses the same drive away from their fixed workstation.

Bear in mind: Samsung lists maximum sequential speeds of 1.050 MB/s read and 1.000 MB/s write for the T7 Shield 2 TB. These are manufacturer figures, not a measured speed for your backup.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this more important for?
Restorable backup Include your original photos and exports as well as the catalogue, and check that you can open files from the backup. If I want to restore my photo files after losing them, I need to know which folders have actually been copied. Around 36% of consumers put the ability to restore files first.
Space for your archive Allow for original photos, the catalogue, exports and any older versions. With a growing archive, I want to make sure there is enough space for future copies too. Around 29% of consumers give archive space top priority.
Connection and power Check the port, the cable supplied and the file system for the exact model. If I regularly connect my drive and put it away again, I want to make sure it works with my computer. Around 21% of consumers put ease of connection first.
Transferring large files Check that the interface and cable work with your computer. Don’t treat quoted maximum speeds as a guaranteed backup time. When I often move large photo files, I want to take transfer speed into account. Around 14% of consumers put speed first.

Common backup mistakes

  • Backing up only the photo catalogue

    According to Adobe, a Lightroom Classic backup contains only the catalogue file. That means your edited photos and exports are not automatically included.

    Make a note of where your original photos, catalogue and exports are stored. Check them separately by opening files from the backup.

  • Assuming one external drive is a complete backup plan

    An external drive holds a copy of your files, but it can fail too. If that one copy is lost, you may no longer be able to access the files stored on it.

    Keep a separate, recent copy and regularly check that you can open your files from it.

  • Assuming every USB drive works straight away with every computer

    The connection and file system can vary by model. For the Canvio Basics model reviewed, Toshiba lists a Type-A-to-Micro-B cable and NTFS for Windows; the drive needs reformatting for the macOS versions specified.

    Before your first backup, check the port, cable and file system for the exact model. Move any existing files elsewhere before formatting a drive.

  • Treating a quoted peak speed as a guaranteed backup time

    The maximum sequential speeds Samsung quotes for the T7 Shield are not a measurement of how long it takes to copy your photo archive.

    Check that your computer’s port and cable work with the interface. If you only copy your archive occasionally, also consider how much storage space you need.

Brands to consider

Toshiba

Canvio Basics is a range of USB-powered portable HDDs for anyone who wants to connect a drive and put it away after backing up.

  • Toshiba lists models up to 4 TB and includes a USB cable. For the model reviewed, it specifies NTFS for Windows and says reformatting is needed for the macOS versions mentioned.
  • The included cable and file system depend on the model, so check the exact version.

Seagate

Expansion Portable is a USB-powered HDD option, while Expansion Desktop is designed for storage in a fixed location.

  • For the Expansion Portable model reviewed, the Seagate datasheet lists a 2 TB version, USB power and a USB 3.0 cable.
  • According to Seagate, the recovery service mentioned is not available in every country. Check the terms for the exact purchase before relying on cover.

Samsung

The T7 Shield is a range of portable external SSDs for anyone who regularly moves large files.

  • For the T7 Shield 2 TB, Samsung specifies USB 3.2 Gen 2 and maximum sequential speeds of 1.050 MB/s read and 1.000 MB/s write.
  • These are manufacturer figures for that model, not an independent measurement of a photo backup or a guarantee of the same speed with every computer.

Intenso

Memory Center is a range of desktop HDDs, including a documented 8 TB model for a fixed backup location.

  • For the 8 TB model, Intenso lists a 3.5-inch form factor and USB 3.2 Gen 1x1.
  • The model uses an external mains adapter; the quoted read and write speeds are manufacturer figures.

Western Digital

The Techboer ranking lists the WD Elements Portable 2 TB and My Passport 2 TB as different portable HDD options.

  • Both model names appear as separate options in Techboer’s editorial ranking.
  • A place in a ranking doesn’t prove that a model is right for every photo catalogue. Check the model and capacity for your needs.

Joybuy products for photo storage

This selection includes portable external HDDs and a portable SSD for backing up and moving files at a home workstation.

Western Digital My Passport 6TB White portable hard drive

Western Digital My Passport 6TB White

A good choice if you’re looking for a portable drive for a growing photo archive.

6 TB of storage; USB 3.0 and USB-powered. The description mentions automatic backups using the included Acronis software, which needs to be set up.

View at Joybuy
Western Digital My Passport 2TB Blue portable hard drive

Western Digital My Passport 2TB Blue

A good choice if you want to connect a portable drive, then disconnect it once you’ve made a copy.

2 TB of storage and USB-powered. The description notes that WD Discovery or the included backup software needs to be set up for password protection and scheduled backups.

View at Joybuy
Western Digital My Passport 4TB Black portable hard drive

Western Digital My Passport 4TB Black

A good choice if you need extra storage for a large photo archive and want to schedule backups from a computer.

4 TB of storage, USB 3.0 and USB-powered. The description lists Windows 10 and Windows 8.1 as supported operating systems; scheduled backups need to be set up using the WD Backup software mentioned.

View at Joybuy
Portable SSD 1TB with quoted read speeds of up to 1000 MB/s

Portable SSD 1TB 1000MB/s

A good choice if you’re looking for a portable SSD for photos and regularly moving large files.

1 TB of storage; USB-C and USB 3.2 Gen 2. The quoted maximum sequential read speed is up to 1.000 MB/s, but this isn’t a guarantee of the same speed for a full backup.

For connecting the drive, the description mentions USB-C or a USB-C-to-USB-A adapter. Formatting may be needed the first time you use it with Windows.

View at Joybuy
Toshiba Canvas Basics 1TB Black portable hard drive

Toshiba Canvas Basics 1TB Black

A good choice if you’re looking for a portable HDD for a catalogue and other files on a home computer.

1 TB of storage, USB 3.2 Gen 1, USB 2.0 compatibility and USB power. The description notes that the drive needs reformatting before use with macOS.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does backing up your Lightroom Classic catalogue also back up your photos?

No. Adobe says Lightroom Classic’s backup function includes only the catalogue file. Back up your edited photos and exports separately, and check that you can open the files from your backup.

Does your external drive need to stay connected all the time?

No, not to keep a copy you’ve already made. Back up regularly, and disconnect the external drive afterwards, as advised by the Consumers' Association. Do connect the drive when a scheduled backup is due to run.

Can you use a Canvio Basics formatted for Windows straight away as a Mac backup drive?

Don’t assume so. Toshiba specifies NTFS for Windows and says the Canvio Basics model reviewed needs reformatting for the macOS versions listed on the product page. Check the file system and save any existing files elsewhere before formatting.

In the Netherlands, do you still have rights after two years if an external drive fails too soon?

You may do. According to ACM ConsuWijzer, statutory guarantees apply alongside any manufacturer’s warranty: with normal use, a product should last as long as you can reasonably expect. Contact the seller if a product fails too soon; this is not a promise that lost photo files can be recovered.

Is your personal photo archive covered by the GDPR?

The Dutch Data Protection Authority describes an exception for photos you use only for personal or household purposes and keep private or share within a very limited circle. This exception does not automatically apply if you share identifiable people’s photos more widely or use photos for business. It is a condition of use, not a general requirement for the drive you buy.