Who is this choice relevant to?

People reading old CD and DVD backups

You want to know which disc types you have and choose a drive that can read those specific formats. DVD-RAM, for example, requires explicit support; Dell lists this format for the DW316.

People switching between laptops

You use the drive with different computers, so you compare the available USB ports, included cables, power supply and supported operating systems. Verbatim and ASUS specify different connection options supplied with particular models.

People looking after fragile archive files

You want to transfer old files while allowing for possible reading errors. The Library of Congress notes that scratches and smudges can cause reading problems. If the discs contain personal data, access to files on the shared computer matters too.

What should you look for when choosing?

What to consider What to look for Who is this important for?
Disc format Compare the disc label with the read formats listed for the exact model; check DVD-RAM or Blu-ray separately. If I want to make sure the drive can read my existing discs first, I check the full format in the specifications. Around 36% of consumers put the right disc format first.
Connection and power Check the USB port, included cables, power supply and supported operating systems for each computer. If you use the drive with computers that have different ports, you don't want to run into connection problems at every workstation. Around 29% of consumers give connection and power top priority.
Fragile files Distinguish between a drive that isn't recognised and a disc that can't be read; check the saved files after copying them. If the files on old discs matter, I want to copy them carefully and check the copy. Around 21% of consumers put safeguarding fragile files first.
Confidentiality Before transferring files, check whether the backup contains personal data and what rules apply to temporary files and storage. At a shared desk, I want to prevent others from accessing any personal data I've recovered. Around 14% of consumers make confidentiality their top priority.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming a ‘DVD drive’ supports every old disc format

    Supported media vary by model. Dell lists DVD-RAM for the DW316; that doesn't mean other DVD drives support this format.

    First, note the label on the disc and compare it with the read formats listed for the full model number.

    If the drive isn't compatible with your disc type, you may need to buy a second, suitable drive.

  • Assuming a new drive guarantees data recovery

    Scratches, smudges or age can cause reading errors. A configuration issue can also stop the computer recognising a drive, as Microsoft explains for Windows.

    First, check whether the computer recognises the drive. Handle the disc carefully and save a successful copy somewhere else.

    Diagnosis or another recovery method may take extra time if the disc turns out to be damaged.

  • Looking only at the shape of the connector

    The included cables vary by model; the ASUS Blu-ray drive reviewed also has a separate power adapter.

    For every computer you use, compare the port, cable, power supply and supported operating system with the specifications for the exact model.

    Depending on the workstation, you may need a suitable cable, adapter or available port.

  • Assuming an old model page confirms current availability

    LG marks the specific GP57EB40 as discontinued. On its Dutch product page for the BW-16D1X-U, ASUS stated that the model was out of stock.

    Use pages like these to check model specifications, and check the current product page separately before deciding to buy.

Brands and models to consider

Verbatim

The Slimline CD/DVD Writer 43886 is a compact option for CDs and DVDs, provided its specified read formats match your discs.

  • Verbatim specifies USB power and read modes for various CD and DVD formats.
  • The listed read modes don't include DVD-RAM or Blu-ray. Verbatim says the included Nero software is for Windows only.

Dell

The DW316 is worth considering if you specifically have DVD-RAM backups.

  • Dell lists DVD-RAM among the supported optical media and specifies USB 2.0 with a USB cable included.
  • Check how USB 2.0 connects to the computer you use; these specifications don't confirm Blu-ray reading.

ASUS

The ZenDrive U9M is a CD/DVD model supplied with Type-A and Type-C cables. The separate BW-16D1X-U is a Blu-ray option.

  • ASUS lists read modes for Blu-ray, DVD and CD for the BW-16D1X-U.
  • ASUS specifies a separate power adapter for the BW-16D1X-U. These are model specifications, not the results of an independent recovery test.

LG

The GP57EB40 is a model reference to consider when comparing external DVD drives.

  • For this specific model, LG lists features including Super Multi DVD Writer and M Disc.
  • LG marks the GP57EB40 as discontinued. This says nothing about other LG models or stock at other retailers.

Joybuy products

This selection of Joybuy products focuses on reading CDs and DVDs using an external drive with a USB connection.

ASUS SDRW-08U7M-U Optical Disc Drive DVD±RW Silver

ASUS SDRW-08U7M-U Optical Disc Drive DVD±RW Silver

An external CD/DVD drive to consider if its specified formats match your backup discs and your computer supports USB 2.0.

USB 2.0 connection; slim 13 mm design; specified read speeds: CD 24x and DVD 8x.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is an external DVD drive enough for old Blu-ray backups?

No. For a Blu-ray disc, choose a model that explicitly states it can read Blu-ray. The read modes listed by Verbatim for the 43886 cover CDs and DVDs; ASUS also lists BD-ROM reading for the BW-16D1X-U.

What should I check if Windows can't see the drive?

First, check whether the drive appears in File Explorer or Device Manager. Microsoft Support explains that a missing drive in Windows 10 and 11 may also be caused by a driver or configuration issue. So first establish whether the computer recognises the drive before assuming the disc itself can't be read.

How should I handle an old disc while transferring its contents?

Hold a CD or DVD by its edge and centre hole, not by the reading surface. The Library of Congress warns that scratches and smudges can cause reading problems. Also, store copied files somewhere else and check that you can access them.

Can I leave recovered personal data on a shared computer?

Don't leave personal data accessible to anyone who isn't authorised to access it. The Dutch Data Protection Authority describes unauthorised access to personal data as a potential data breach. Make sure you know who is allowed access and follow your organisation's security and storage policies.

What warranty and cooling-off period apply to an online consumer purchase in the Netherlands?

As well as any manufacturer's warranty, you're entitled to a statutory warranty if a product doesn't meet reasonable expectations under normal use; ACM ConsuWijzer notes that the retailer is responsible for this. Online consumer purchases usually come with a 14-day cooling-off period from delivery, subject to statutory exceptions. Check which terms apply to your purchase.