A portable HDD is a good fit if your main priority is space for a growing archive. An SSD is worth considering if you regularly move recordings between workstations and want to transfer them quickly. Whichever you choose, keep a separate backup and test that you can restore your files. If recordings contain identifiable personal data, make sure you also have appropriate access controls, a valid legal basis and a clearly justified retention period.
Who should consider this choice?
People responsible for confidential recordings
You decide who can access the archive and how long recordings are kept. If people can be identified in the files, privacy and security should be part of your decision. The Dutch Data Protection Authority explains how to protect personal data and control access to it.
People responsible for recoverable recordings
You want to be able to restore files after a fault, mistake or incident. That’s why a separate copy and a restore test should be part of your storage plan. The Digital Trust Center recommends keeping backups in different locations.
Studio teams with a growing archive
You need space for new recordings and a connection that works with your studio computers. How often you move files between workstations may help you decide between an HDD and an SSD. The Dutch Consumers’ Association outlined the differences in a buying guide published in 2022.
What should you look for?
Portable external HDD
A good fit if: you mainly need archive space and don’t move files between workstations constantly.
The trade-off: HDDs have moving parts and, according to the Dutch Consumers’ Association, are more susceptible to wear and shock damage than SSDs. One drive also isn’t a second backup.
Portable external SSD
A good fit if: you regularly transfer recordings in person or copy them between workstations.
The trade-off: a quoted maximum speed isn’t the same as the speed you’ll get in your studio. Your computer’s port also affects the performance you can achieve.
| What to consider |
What to look for |
Who should care? |
| Confidentiality |
Check the security features of the exact model and agree who can unlock and access the drive. |
If I manage recordings featuring identifiable people, I want to limit access to the team. Around 29% of consumers put confidentiality at the top of their list. |
| Recoverability |
Plan a separate copy and test whether you can restore a recording. |
If I can’t recreate important recordings, I want to be able to recover them after loss or an error. Around 29% of consumers give recoverability top priority. |
| Archive space |
Compare the stated capacity with the size of your existing and expected files. Set the retention period separately. |
If my archive keeps growing, I want to choose enough space without keeping files for longer than necessary. Around 24% of consumers put capacity first. |
| Transfer and compatibility |
Check the ports, cables and file formats at every workstation. Reformatting may be necessary. |
If I regularly switch between computers, I want to know whether the drive will work straight away and what transfer speeds I can expect. Around 18% of consumers start with transfer and compatibility. |
Common buying pitfalls
-
Mistaking one archive drive for a complete backup
If the drive holds your only copy, a fault, mistake or incident could make the archive unusable.
Keep a second copy in a separate location and regularly test that you can restore a recording. The Digital Trust Center recommends keeping backups in different locations.
-
Mistaking a password option for full access control
A password feature on the drive won’t automatically control which team members can access it. Organisations must restrict unauthorised access to personal data; the Dutch Data Protection Authority explains this responsibility.
Check the features of the exact model and also agree who can access the recordings and how team members will be given access.
The team will also need to manage unlocking and access permissions.
-
Judging speed and compatibility by the USB or SSD label alone
Your computer’s port and the file format also affect transfer speeds. For the Canvio Basics version it reviewed, Toshiba specifies NTFS for Windows and says the drive needs reformatting for macOS.
Before choosing, check the ports, cables and operating systems at all the workstations you plan to use. Also check the model code and how reformatting could affect existing files.
Brands to consider
Western Digital
The My Passport range is a line of portable HDDs with password protection and stated hardware encryption, for those looking for archive space and a security feature.
- According to Western Digital, the documented My Passport range offers 256-bit AES hardware encryption.
- You need to set up the feature. This isn’t an independent security test and doesn’t replace managing team permissions or keeping separate backups.
Samsung
The T7 Shield is a portable SSD for anyone who regularly transfers files or takes their drive with them.
- For the black 2 TB T7 Shield, Samsung Netherlands specifies maximum read speeds of 1.050 MB/s and write speeds of 1.000 MB/s via USB 3.2 Gen 2, and lists an IP65 rating.
- These are manufacturer figures for this model, not measured results in a studio. The computer port you use and your backup process still matter.
Seagate
Expansion Portable is a range of USB-powered HDDs for portable archive storage.
- Seagate Netherlands lists model STKM4000400, among others, with a capacity of 4 TB.
- A Seagate data sheet says the Rescue service mentioned isn’t available in every country, so don’t assume it’s available in the Netherlands.
Toshiba
Canvio Basics is a range of portable HDDs for USB storage.
- The Toshiba Storage Solutions EMEA specification consulted lists NTFS for Windows.
- For macOS use, Toshiba says the drive needs reformatting. Check the full model code: product versions list different codes for 4 TB.
Joybuy products
This selection of Joybuy products includes portable HDDs for archive storage and a portable SSD for transferring recordings.
Image unavailable
Western Digital My Passport 6 TB, white
A portable HDD for a growing archive of recordings.
Stated capacity: 6 TB; USB 3.0; password protection with 256-bit AES hardware encryption and backup software, according to the product description. You’ll need to activate security and encryption using the included software.
View at Joybuy
Image unavailable
Western Digital My Passport 4 TB, black
A portable HDD for storing studio recordings.
Stated capacity: 4 TB; USB 3.0; the product description lists password protection with 256-bit AES hardware encryption and automatic backup software. You’ll need to activate security and encryption through WD Discovery.
View at Joybuy
Image unavailable
Western Digital My Passport USB-C 4 TB, black
A portable HDD for storing archives across different workstations.
Stated capacity: 4 TB; the description lists USB-C, exFAT and compatibility with Windows and macOS. Set up password protection and encryption according to the manual or using WD software.
View at Joybuy
Image unavailable
Portable SSD 1 TB
A portable SSD for regularly transferring recordings.
Stated capacity: 1 TB; USB-C; read speeds of up to 1.000 MB/s and drop protection from heights of up to 2 metres, according to the product description. Speeds also depend on the computer port you use. You may need to format the drive the first time you use it with Windows.
View at Joybuy
Image unavailable
Toshiba Canvio Basics 4 TB, black
A portable HDD for an archive where storage space is the main priority.
Stated capacity: 4 TB; 2.5-inch; USB 3.2 Gen 1. The product specifications don’t list any security features. The product description says the drive needs reformatting for macOS.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is one external drive enough to back up meeting recordings?
Not if it holds the only copy you’ve kept. The Digital Trust Center recommends keeping backups in different locations and regularly testing that you can restore them. This advice doesn’t specify a particular drive model.
Can a Windows-formatted Canvio Basics be used with a Mac straight away?
For the Canvio Basics version consulted, Toshiba lists NTFS for Windows and says the drive needs reformatting for macOS. Check the exact model and what reformatting means for files already stored on the drive.
How long can we keep identifiable meeting recordings?
The Dutch Data Protection Authority states that the GDPR doesn’t set a general, specific retention period for personal data. Don’t keep recordings for longer than necessary for their purpose, and document the retention period and your reasons for it. Other applicable laws may set specific periods.
Is consent always the required legal basis under the GDPR for identifiable recordings?
No. The Dutch Data Protection Authority lists six possible legal bases. The organisation responsible must decide which one applies before processing the data. You should also tell the people concerned about the processing and its purpose.
Does the warranty cover recovering our files?
Don’t assume it does. Check the terms for the exact model and whether any recovery services are available: Seagate says the Rescue service mentioned isn’t available in every country. You should also keep a separate backup and test that you can restore it.