Who is this choice relevant to?

Manager of a growing recordings archive

You store completed meeting recordings along with their local source files, and need enough storage space as well as copies you can restore. The National Cyber Security Centre advises keeping multiple versions of important business data, using different media and storing a copy in another location.

Editor of local source files

You regularly move large recording files or work directly from external storage. In that case, the connection and speed of the drive with your computer and workflow are important factors to consider.

Manager of confidential recordings

You manage recordings that may contain personal data, so you need to consider access, security and how long they need to be kept. The Dutch Data Protection Authority treats these as aspects of data processing, separate from the choice between an HDD and an SSD.

What should you look for when choosing?

Start by considering the size and use of your archive. Then decide how you’ll restore copies and which computers need to be able to read the drive.

Consideration What to look for when buying Who is this important for?
Enough capacity Add up recordings, source files and project versions over a representative period. Allow for growth and the available retention period. If I want to store recordings and source files together, I compare the capacity with the actual size of my archive. Around 27% of consumers prioritise storage space.
Recoverability Allow space for a separate copy, and check that you can actually open and restore your files. If losing one drive must not also mean losing my archive, I want to be able to restore a separate copy. Around 27% of consumers put recoverability first.
Access and confidentiality Consider who needs access and what level of security is appropriate for the content and risks. Check how any password or encryption features work. For recordings containing personal data, I want access and security to match the way the data is processed. Around 20% of consumers put confidentiality at the top of their list.
Transfer and editing Compare the USB connections on the drive and computer, as well as the cable. Consider the stated speeds in light of how you’ll use the drive. If I often move large files or edit them directly from the drive, I want the connection to keep up with my workflow. Around 13% of consumers put working speed first.
Connection and readability Check the included cable and file system for the computers you want to use with the archive. Back up your files before reformatting. If I want to be able to read the same files on the computers I use, I check the connection and formatting in advance. Around 13% of consumers start with compatibility.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming the archive drive is a complete backup

    If the external drive holds your only usable copy, losing or damaging it could make the archive impossible to recover.

    Keep a separate copy and test periodically that you can restore a recording together with its source files.

    A separate copy requires extra storage space and time to test recovery.

  • Focusing only on the maximum speed printed on the packaging

    Your computer’s port and cable can limit transfer speeds, so a higher stated speed won’t automatically mean faster archiving.

    Compare the connections on the drive and computer, and the cable, with how often you move or edit large files.

  • Saving files before checking the formatting

    According to Toshiba, the Toshiba Canvio Basics model reviewed comes preformatted as NTFS for Windows. Toshiba says it needs to be reformatted for macOS.

    Check the file system and the computers you want to use with the drive before saving files to it.

    Reformatting requires preparation and may mean you need temporary storage to keep existing files safe first.

  • Confusing a security feature with full GDPR compliance

    A feature on a drive does not in itself answer separate questions about the lawful basis, appropriate security and retention period for personal data.

    Assess the data processing and its associated risks separately from the choice between an HDD and an SSD. The Dutch Data Protection Authority treats these obligations separately.

Brands to consider

Toshiba

The Canvio Basics model reviewed is a portable HDD for anyone looking for archive storage.

  • Toshiba lists a 4 TB model powered via USB.
  • The model reviewed comes preformatted as NTFS for Windows; Toshiba says it needs reformatting for macOS. The included cable is Type-A to Micro-B.

Seagate

The Expansion Portable model reviewed is a portable HDD for extra storage space.

  • The model reviewed has model number STKM5000400 and a capacity of 5 TB. Seagate describes connecting via USB 3.0 and dragging and dropping files.
  • Seagate says the drive needs reformatting for Time Machine; the limited warranty mentioned varies by region.

Samsung

The T7 Shield 1 TB and T9 2 TB models reviewed are portable SSDs for frequent transfers and working with local files.

  • For the T7 Shield, Samsung states maximum read/write speeds of 1.050/1.000 MB/s via USB 3.2 Gen 2. For the T9, Samsung states speeds of up to 2.000 MB/s via Gen 2x2.
  • These are manufacturer figures for these models, not guaranteed speeds on every computer. Check that your computer and cable can make use of the T9’s connection.

Joybuy products for archiving and transferring files

This selection includes external HDDs for storing larger archives and external SSDs for frequent transfers. Match the capacity and connection to your own files and computer.

SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1 TB 2000 MB/s

SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1 TB 2000 MB/s

A portable SSD option for anyone who regularly transfers files and wants to use USB-C.

1 TB of storage; the description mentions USB-C and read speeds of up to 2.000 MB/s with a compatible host device.

The stated read speed depends on using a compatible device.

Also plan for a separate copy and test that you can restore your files.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 5 TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 5 TB USB-C

A portable HDD option for anyone who wants to store an archive with more storage space.

5 TB; the description mentions USB-C, USB 3.2 Gen 1 and plug-and-play.

The description says it works with Windows and Mac; check that the formatting is suitable for your devices.

You’ll still need a separate copy and a recovery test to restore your files.

View at Joybuy
My Passport for Mac 2 TB Blue

My Passport for Mac 2 TB Blue

A portable HDD option for an archive managed from a Mac.

2 TB; the product name indicates Mac formatting and Time Machine support.

The description mentions a USB-A cable and USB-C adapter. Before use, check that the connection and formatting suit your equipment.

Plan for a separate copy as well, so you can restore your files.

View at Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 6 TB USB-C

WD Elements Portable 6 TB USB-C

A portable HDD option for storing a large archive of recordings.

6 TB; the description mentions a 2.5-inch design, USB-C, USB 3.2 Gen 1 and plug-and-play.

Check that the formatting suits the computers you want to use to read the files.

The drive is not a separate backup in itself, so plan for a separate copy and test recovery.

View at Joybuy
My Passport 6 TB White

My Passport 6 TB White

A portable HDD option for a large archive, with password protection and automatic copying features according to the description.

6 TB; the description mentions USB power, plug-and-play and 256-bit AES hardware encryption with password protection.

The description also mentions backup software. A security feature does not replace an assessment of the appropriate protection for personal data.

Keep a separate copy too, and test recovery.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is one external drive enough for an archive and a backup?

Not if it contains your only recoverable copy. The National Cyber Security Centre advises keeping multiple versions of important business data, using different media and storing a copy in another location. Test that you can restore your files too.

How can I check that my recordings archive is usable after copying?

Test restoring files and open some from the copy, including a recording and its source files. The National Cyber Security Centre advises testing backups so you know whether files can actually be opened.

Do I need to reformat an external drive to use it with a Mac?

It depends on the model and file system. Toshiba says the Canvio Basics model reviewed is formatted as NTFS for Windows and needs to be reformatted for macOS. Check this before saving any files.

What extra effort does a separate backup involve?

You’ll need storage space for a separate copy and time to test recovery. The amount of space required depends on the size of your own files and how many versions you want to keep.

Can an organisation keep meeting recordings containing personal data indefinitely on its own drive?

No. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, you need an applicable lawful basis under the GDPR, personal data must be appropriately secured, and it must not be kept for longer than necessary. The GDPR does not set a single general retention period for this. A password feature on a drive does not, by itself, answer every question about data processing.