For a growing archive that usually stays in one place, an external HDD is a good fit when you need plenty of storage; if you often transfer files or take the drive with you, an SSD may be a better choice, provided the workstation’s USB port supports the transfer. Neither type of drive automatically provides a separate backup or controls who can access files on a shared workstation. So check your expected storage needs, connections and operating systems. For recordings containing personal data, follow your educational institution’s security and retention policies.
Who is this guide for?
Manager of a growing lecture archive
You’re storing more and more recordings on a fixed workstation and weighing up storage capacity, transfers and a separate backup. Lenovo Netherlands outlines some considerations around external storage, while VeiligInternetten stresses the importance of keeping a recent backup.
Manager of recordings with access restrictions
You manage access to recordings in which people may be identifiable or audible, and need to check which security measures and retention period are appropriate for processing them. The Dutch Data Protection Authority explains security measures and the retention of personal data.
Staff member who transfers recordings frequently
You regularly copy large files between a workstation and external storage, so the connection, transfer speed and portability all matter. Lenovo Netherlands discusses portable storage, while Samsung provides specifications for the T7 Shield.
What should you consider when choosing?
When recordings contain personal data, access management should be part of your choice: the Dutch Data Protection Authority says organisations must protect personal data properly.
| Consideration |
What to look for |
Who should pay particular attention? |
| Space for your archive |
Add up your existing files, then allow for expected new recordings and the capacity of the exact model. |
If I’m building an archive that will keep growing, I want to plan enough space for the files that need to be kept. Around 25% of consumers prioritise having enough space for their archive. |
| Recovery after loss or failure |
Decide where a separate backup will be kept, who will make it and whether restoring files will be checked. |
If I want to be able to recover recordings after loss or a drive failure, I need a separate copy in addition to the archive drive. For around 25% of consumers, limiting data loss is their main buying concern. |
| Access on a shared workstation |
Check who can access the drive and workstation, what security the exact model offers and how to set it up. |
When several staff members use the same workstation, I want to be able to control who opens recordings and how recovery access is managed. Access management is a priority for around 20% of consumers. |
| Transferring large files |
Compare the USB specifications of the drive and workstation; the stated model speeds don’t guarantee the speed of your connection. |
If I often transfer large recordings, I want to avoid slowing down my work unnecessarily. Around 15% of consumers give transfer time their highest priority. |
| Connection and file system |
Check the port type, included cables and compatibility with the operating systems in use; back up your files before formatting. |
If the drive needs to work with the workstations we have, I want to know in advance whether the connection and file system are suitable. For around 15% of consumers, compatibility is their main buying concern. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Confusing an external drive with a complete backup strategy
Files stored only on the external drive don’t have a separate backup. VeiligInternetten recommends keeping a recent backup of your files.
Decide where the second copy will be kept, who will check the backup and how you’ll test recovery.
-
Assuming built-in encryption automatically means password protection
Western Digital distinguishes between hardware encryption and password protection. On a shared workstation, it also matters who can access the drive once it’s unlocked.
Check the settings on the exact drive and the access permissions on the workstation.
-
Comparing only the connector or advertised speed
A suitable connector doesn’t confirm that the drive and file system will work with every computer in use. Formatting erases existing files, and a stated top speed doesn’t tell you how fast the workstation’s connection will be.
Check which ports and operating systems are in use, find out which cable is included and make a copy before formatting.
Brands to compare
Seagate
The Expansion Portable is a range of portable HDDs for files including video. Seagate Netherlands lists the STKM4000400 as a 4TB version.
- The manufacturer states that it connects via a USB cable.
- The manual says a micro-B-to-USB-C cable isn’t included for a USB-C port. Check the port and cable for the version you choose.
Toshiba
Canvio Basics is a range of portable HDDs that includes the 4TB HDTB540EK3CA, listed by Toshiba Storage EMEA.
- Toshiba lists USB bus power and a Type-A-to-Micro-B cable.
- The manufacturer lists NTFS as the file system and says the drive needs reformatting for macOS. Formatting erases existing files.
Samsung
The T7 Shield is a range of external SSDs. Samsung Business Netherlands lists the black 2TB version, MU-PE2T0S/EU; this isn’t the same model as the standard T7.
- For this version, Samsung quotes read speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s and write speeds of up to 1.000 MB/s, with USB 3.2 Gen 2 and USB-C-to-C and USB-C-to-A cables.
- These are manufacturer specifications, not measured speeds on a shared workstation. The port and your setup affect transfer speeds.
Kingston
IronKey Vault Privacy 80ES is a range of external SSDs with access security. Kingston describes, among others, a 1,92TB version.
- Kingston specifies a touchscreen, hardware encryption and separate administrator and user passwords. For the 1,92TB version, the manufacturer quotes read and write speeds of 250 MB/s.
- Passwords and recovery access need to be managed carefully. After a risk assessment, decide whether this type of security is right for your use.
Western Digital
With the My Passport range, it’s important to distinguish between hardware encryption and password protection that has actually been set up.
- Western Digital describes hardware encryption and password protection for certain versions.
- According to Western Digital, adding or removing a password doesn’t switch hardware encryption on or off. Check the support and configuration of the exact version.
Joybuy products for lecture recordings
These Joybuy products are intended for storing lecture recordings on a workstation, from HDDs for archiving to SSDs for frequent file transfers and versions with password protection.
No image available
WD Elements Portable 6TB USB-C Graphite Black
Suitable for an archive kept at a single workstation with a USB-C connection.
The product description lists 6 TB, USB-C, USB 3.2 Gen 1, a portable 2.5-inch enclosure and a weight of 240 g.
Joybuy
No image available
WD My Passport USB-C 5TB Black
A good choice if storage capacity and configurable password protection are important for a portable archive.
The product description lists 5 TB, USB-C, exFAT, use with Windows and Mac, and hardware encryption with password protection. According to the description, you need to use WD Discovery or WD Security and set a password to activate this protection.
Joybuy
No image available
WD My Passport 4TB Black Portable Hard Drive
Suitable for a portable 4 TB archive where password protection is important.
The product information lists USB 3.0, USB power, an included USB cable and 256-bit AES hardware encryption. According to the description, you need to activate WD Discovery and set a password for password protection.
Joybuy
No image available
Samsung Portable SSD T7 2TB USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2 Blue
A good choice if you want a portable SSD for regularly transferring large files.
The product description lists 2 TB, USB-C-to-C and USB-C-to-A cables, and AES 256-bit encryption. Stated transfer speeds are up to 1.050 MB/s for reading and 1.000 MB/s for writing; the actual speed also depends on the workstation’s USB port.
Joybuy
No image available
Samsung Portable SSD T9 4TB Black MU-PG4T0B
Suitable for an archive where you’re considering a portable 4 TB SSD with a fast USB connection.
The product description lists USB 3.2 Gen 2x2, read and write speeds of up to 2.000 MB/s and drop resistance from up to 3 metres. It also mentions compatibility with Windows, macOS and Android, plus hardware encryption with password protection; check that the workstation supports the connection.
Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Can several staff members use one USB drive at the same time?
A USB drive plugged directly into a computer doesn’t automatically provide shared network storage. If staff need simultaneous access from different computers, look into managed network storage and access permissions. For recordings containing personal data, the organisation must tailor security measures to the risks, as the Dutch Data Protection Authority explains.
What if the drive needs to work with both Windows and Mac?
First check the existing file system and the requirements of your backup software. Apple Support describes ExFAT as an option for sharing files with Windows on drives larger than 32 GB, but warns that formatting erases all files on the volume. Toshiba says Canvio Basics needs to be reformatted for macOS.
What extra work is involved in managing a lecture archive?
Allow for managing a separate backup, checking that files can be restored and keeping access details secure. VeiligInternetten recommends keeping a recent backup, so also decide who will check the copies and where they will be stored separately.
Can you keep identifiable lecture recordings on a shared drive indefinitely?
No. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says organisations must not keep personal data for longer than necessary and must tailor security to the risks. The GDPR does not set a single, specific retention period for every situation. The appropriate retention period and access arrangements depend on the purpose, the content of the recordings and the educational institution’s policies.