Film archive manager
You want to be able to recover films if a computer or drive fails, and you manage who looks after the copies. An external drive provides storage, but it isn’t a complete backup plan by itself.
Choose a drive based on the archive’s current size and expected growth, then decide whether you’ll mainly store films or regularly transfer and edit them. A portable HDD is a good fit when storage space is the priority; an SSD may be more suitable if volunteers often move large files or work directly from the drive. Keep a separate copy as well: one external drive on its own is not a complete backup plan.
You want to be able to recover films if a computer or drive fails, and you manage who looks after the copies. An external drive provides storage, but it isn’t a complete backup plan by itself.
You regularly add recordings and want to factor in both your current files and expected growth before choosing a capacity.
You may use different computers and move large files between them. So check the drive’s file system, cable and connection.
First, decide what you’ll mainly use the drive for. The capacity, compatibility and transfer speed you need will depend on that choice.
Best for: mainly storing films or taking a copy to another location.
Bear in mind: capacity and connection vary by model, so don’t choose based on expected speed alone.
Best for: regularly transferring large video files or editing them directly from the drive, provided it has a suitable connection for the computer you use.
Bear in mind: check that the capacity is sufficient; speed doesn’t make a separate backup unnecessary.
| Consideration | What to look for | Who should pay particular attention? |
|---|---|---|
| A recoverable copy | Decide where the second copy will be kept and how you’ll check that files can be restored from it. | If I lose the only copy, I want to be able to restore the films elsewhere; simply buying a larger drive won’t solve that. Around 36% of consumers prioritise recoverability. |
| Space for the archive | Add up your existing files and expected additions, then compare the total with the capacity of both your working drive and backup drive. | For a collection that keeps growing, I want to work out how much space the current and new films will take up. Around 29% of consumers say archive space is their main concern. |
| Computer compatibility | List the computers and ports you use, then test reading and writing with sample files before transferring any films. | If films need to be shared between different group computers, I want to know in advance whether they’ll all work with the drive. Computer compatibility is a priority for around 21% of consumers. |
| Transferring and editing | Check the computer’s connection and make sure the capacity suits the files you want to transfer or edit. | If volunteers regularly transfer or edit large files, I want to know whether an SSD would be worthwhile. Around 14% of consumers focus on transferring and editing. |
Capacity and recoverability are two different things. If the external drive is your only storage location, the extra space won’t help if the drive fails or goes missing.
Before buying, decide where a separate copy will be kept and who will check that files can be restored from it. Seagate describes an external drive as a destination for a copy of your files.
Managing the archive also means having a second storage location and setting aside time to check that files can be restored.
A matching plug doesn’t automatically mean every computer can read and write files in the drive’s default format. The Toshiba Canvio Basics model reviewed uses NTFS; you may need to reformat it for use with a Mac.
Test the drive with sample files on the group’s computers before transferring any films. Make a copy elsewhere first: Apple warns that formatting erases files.
You may need to make an extra copy and set aside time to reformat the drive or arrange a suitable cable.
The maximum sequential speeds quoted by Samsung for the T7 Shield don’t guarantee the same performance on the group’s computers. The connection you use and the task you’re doing will also affect the results.
Choose an SSD if fast transfers really matter, and check at the same time that its capacity suits the films you want to store.
The portable My Passport range includes options for storing a film archive.
Expansion Portable is a range of portable HDDs for storing and moving large files.
Canvio Basics is a range of USB-powered portable HDDs; Toshiba lists a black 4 TB model.
The portable T7 Shield SSD may be a good fit if volunteers often transfer or work with large files.
This selection includes portable external HDDs for archive storage and a portable SSD for anyone who regularly transfers large files.
No image available
A portable HDD option for groups whose main priority is archive storage.
5 TB storage; USB-C; 2.5-inch form factor.
You’ll also need a separate copy to be able to recover your files.
No image available
A portable HDD option for groups that need plenty of archive storage.
6 TB storage; the product name lists password protection and automatic backup software.
Check the software is suitable for the group’s computers; you’ll still need a separate copy.
No image available
A portable HDD option for an archive that can fit within 4 TB of storage.
4 TB storage; USB-C.
Compare the available space with your current collection and expected growth, and plan to keep a separate copy.
No image available
A portable HDD option for storing films and other files.
4 TB storage; USB Type-A and Micro-USB B; USB 2.0 and USB 3.2 Gen 1.
The drive described is formatted for Windows; you may need to reformat it for macOS. Make a copy elsewhere first, as formatting erases files.
No image available
A portable SSD option for volunteers who regularly transfer large video files.
2 TB storage; USB Type-C; USB 3.2 Gen 2.
The stated maximum speeds aren’t a guarantee of real-world performance; the connection and workload matter. Check that 2 TB is enough and keep a separate copy.
Not if losing the drive would also mean losing the only copy. Keep a separate copy and check that files can be restored from it; using an external drive as a backup destination won’t automatically cover every eventuality.
First, check the file system of the exact model. Toshiba says the Canvio Basics described uses NTFS and needs to be reformatted for Mac; Apple lists ExFAT as an option for an external drive larger than 32 GB used with Windows and Mac. Copy any existing films elsewhere first, as formatting erases files.
If an organisation films identifiable people or processes their images, the personal or household exemption may not apply. The Dutch Data Protection Authority points to the need for a valid legal basis and appropriate security. For events, it describes consent as an obvious legal basis, while also outlining circumstances in which another basis may be possible. Don’t keep personal data for longer than necessary, and establish the purpose, access arrangements and applicable legal basis for the specific films.
Before placing the order, check on whose behalf it’s being made and which sales and manufacturer terms apply. The Netherlands Authority for Consumers and Markets explains that statutory guarantees apply to sales to consumers; these consumer rules don’t automatically apply to an order placed on behalf of a group. A replacement drive can’t restore films if no other copy exists.