Who is this choice relevant to?

Manager of shared family records

You may store information about living family members and want to decide who can access the files in your studio. Whether the GDPR applies depends, among other things, on the data and how it is used; the Dutch Data Protection Authority explains where the limits lie.

Manager of a growing scan archive

You collect documents and photographs and need plenty of storage space. Keeping files accessible over time also requires managing the files themselves, not just adding more storage; the National Archives of the Netherlands highlights this point.

Working across several computers

You move or edit scans at different workstations. Check the connection, file system and the speed supported by the computers you’ll be using.

What should you look for when buying?

Portable HDD

Best for: storing lots of scans and occasionally moving the drive between workstations.

Things to consider: check that the supplied cable is compatible with your computers’ ports, and keep a separate copy too.

Portable SSD

Best for: regularly transferring scans or editing them on several computers.

Things to consider: stated speeds don’t guarantee the transfer speed you’ll get on your computer; check the connection and cable.

Desktop HDD

Best for: keeping the archive at one studio workstation most of the time, with storage space as the priority.

Things to consider: the Seagate Expansion Desktop we reviewed uses an external power adapter, making it less convenient to move.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this most relevant to?
Keeping a recoverable copy Keep a separate copy and check that you can restore files from it. If I don’t want to lose the archive because one drive is damaged or lost, I want to be sure I can actually recover it. Around 25% of consumers say recoverability is their main concern.
Protecting family information Decide who needs access and check how any encryption and recovery details work. The Dutch Data Protection Authority notes that family information can also reveal details about living people. In a shared studio, I want to control who can access family information that could identify people. Around 25% of consumers put data protection first.
Space for a growing archive Compare the space you need with your current files and future scans; check the capacity of the exact model. If I keep adding scans and photographs, I want enough space without making portability my main priority. Around 19% of consumers choose archive storage as their main consideration.
Connecting to studio computers Check the ports, cable and file system on every computer. For Time Machine, Apple recommends APFS or encrypted APFS; reformatting can erase files. If I want to use the same drive on different computers, I need to know that the connection and the features I want will work together. Around 19% of consumers say compatibility is their main concern.
Transferring scans quickly Check that the computer, port and cable support the stated speed; it isn’t a guarantee of real-world performance. If I regularly move or edit large scan files, I don’t want transfers to take longer than necessary. Around 12% of consumers put transfer speed first.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming one large drive is a complete archive plan

    If your only drive is damaged or lost, you could still lose the archive. Keeping it accessible over time also requires managing the files.

    Keep a separate, up-to-date copy and periodically try restoring a file.

    A separate copy requires extra storage space and time for restore checks.

  • Leaving a drive unprotected in a shared space

    Family records can also reveal information about living people. The Dutch Data Protection Authority lists encryption as one possible measure, but no single measure provides automatic protection in every situation.

    Decide which files need protection and who needs access. Then check how to enable your chosen security feature and how recovery works.

    Managing access, encryption and the secure storage of recovery details takes time and effort.

  • Focusing only on the plug or stated SSD speed

    A compatible plug doesn’t guarantee that the file system or the backup feature you want will work on every computer. Reformatting can erase existing files.

    Before transferring the archive, check the ports, cable and intended use on every computer involved. Make a copy first if you need to reformat the drive.

    You may need a suitable cable or adapter, as well as time to reformat the drive safely.

Brands to consider

Seagate

The Portable model we reviewed is a range of portable HDDs; the Expansion Desktop is designed for a fixed workstation where plenty of storage is needed.

  • The Portable model we reviewed comes with a USB Type-A cable.
  • The Expansion Desktop uses an external power adapter. Check the capacity, connection and service terms for the exact model and region.

Samsung

The Portable SSD T7 Shield 2TB we reviewed is a portable SSD for transferring scans.

  • For model MU-PE2T0S/EU, Samsung states sequential read and write speeds of up to 1.050 and 1.000 MB/s respectively.
  • These are manufacturer figures under suitable conditions, not an independent measurement or a guarantee of performance with your computer and files.

Crucial

The X9 2TB we reviewed is a portable SSD for use across devices.

  • Crucial lists exFAT as the supplied file system and says the drive can be reformatted to use other file systems.
  • Crucial says reformatting erases data on the drive. Check your computer’s requirements first and make a copy.

LaCie

The Rugged USB-C we reviewed is a range of portable HDDs for regular use on the go.

  • Seagate says the Rugged USB-C range is protected against knocks and rain.
  • This is a manufacturer’s claim, not a replacement for keeping a separate copy. Check the warranty terms for the specific model and region of purchase.

External drives at Joybuy

This selection includes portable HDDs for storing and carrying scans, as well as a portable SSD for transferring files.

My Passport for Mac 2TB Blue

My Passport for Mac 2TB Blue

A portable HDD for a Mac archive or Time Machine backup.

The product information lists 2 TB of storage, pre-formatted for Mac, and a USB-A cable with a USB-C adapter. You need to enable password protection using WD Discovery; the listed system support covers macOS Mojave, High Sierra and Sierra.

Joybuy
My Passport 6TB White

My Passport 6TB White

A portable HDD for a large or growing archive that you also want to take with you.

The product information lists 6 TB of storage and 256-bit AES hardware encryption with password protection. You’ll need to enable it using the supplied software.

Joybuy
My Passport 4TB Black

My Passport 4TB Black

A portable HDD for storing and carrying archive files.

The product information lists 4 TB of storage, USB 3.0 and USB bus power. You’ll need to enable password protection and encryption using WD Discovery; the listed system support covers Windows 10 and Windows 8.1.

Joybuy
Portable SSD 1TB 1000MB/s

Portable SSD 1TB 1000MB/s

A portable SSD for regularly transferring scans.

The product information lists 1 TB of storage, USB-C and a stated read speed of up to 1.000 MB/s. Your computer, connection and cable must all support this maximum speed; reformatting for Windows may be necessary.

Joybuy
Toshiba Canvio Basics 4TB

Toshiba Canvio Basics 4TB

A portable HDD for files in a growing collection of scans and documents.

The product information lists 4 TB of storage, USB 3.2 Gen 1 and compatibility with USB 2.0. The drive is pre-formatted for Windows; you may need to reformat it for macOS. Make a copy first, as reformatting can erase existing data.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is an external drive enough for keeping a family archive for the long term?

No. Keep a separate, up-to-date copy too, and check that you can restore your files. The National Archives of the Netherlands stresses that keeping files accessible over time takes more than storage space alone; rules for public archives don’t automatically apply to a family archive.

Do I need to format a drive to use it with different studio computers?

That depends on the computers and the features you want to use. Crucial lists exFAT as the supplied file system for the X9 we reviewed; for Time Machine, Apple recommends APFS or encrypted APFS. Reformatting can erase existing data, so check the file system and make a copy first.

How do I safely disconnect the drive after scanning?

Wait until the files have finished saving, then eject the drive through the operating system before unplugging the cable. Seagate warns that disconnecting a drive incorrectly can cause data loss.

In the Netherlands, is there always a fixed two-year warranty for a faulty drive?

No. The Dutch government says there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands; if a consumer product is faulty, the seller must provide an appropriate solution. A manufacturer’s warranty is an extra benefit and does not replace your statutory rights.

Does the GDPR apply to a family history archive in a shared studio?

You can’t determine this definitively without knowing what data is involved and how it is used. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says information about someone who has died can also reveal information about someone who is alive. The exception for purely personal or household use comes with conditions; the GDPR may apply if you are using the archive on behalf of an organisation or sharing it more widely. So consider who will have access and what you share.