If you mainly want to store scans and photos, a portable HDD is a sensible choice. An SSD is better if you regularly search through, move or edit files on the drive. ID.nl describes mechanical drives as more vulnerable and slower than external SSDs, while the right choice also depends on your desk, computer and archive size. Don’t store irreplaceable files on just one drive: organise your archive and keep a separate backup too, as the National Archives and VeiligInternetten recommend.
Who is this choice relevant to?
Keeper of irreplaceable family records
You want to store scans, photos and research notes in a way that means losing one device won’t cost you your entire archive. You also want to organise files logically so you can find them later. The National Archives describes digital archiving as selecting, organising and describing material.
Collector of lots of scans and photos
Your archive is growing and you want plenty of storage without a bulky setup taking over your desk. It’s worth comparing a portable HDD and an SSD for capacity and how you’ll use them.
Researcher with a small desk
You regularly open or edit files and want a drive that takes up little space and connects to your computer. So check the dimensions of the specific model, as well as its cable and connection.
What should you look for in an external drive?
First, work out how large your archive is and how often you’ll work from the drive. Then check the space available on your desk, your privacy needs and the connection. The National Archives emphasises that organising and describing files are part of digital archiving—not just storing them.
| What to consider |
What to look for when buying |
Who is this important for? |
| Recovery and finding files |
Think about how you’ll organise your folders and where you’ll keep a separate, up-to-date copy. |
If I don’t want to lose scans and notes, I need a clear folder structure and an extra copy. Around 29% of consumers put recovery and finding files first. |
| Room to grow |
Check the size of your current folders and allow for files you may add later. |
If my collection of photos and scans keeps growing, I want enough storage without using more desk space than necessary. Capacity is the main concern for around 23% of consumers. |
| Desk space |
Compare the dimensions of the specific model and check which cable you’ll need. |
When my desk is small, I want a drive that fits comfortably and is easy to connect. Around 18% of consumers prioritise the space available on their desk. |
| Privacy of family records |
Consider who will have access and whether encryption suits the way you’ll use the drive. |
If my archive contains information about living family members, I want to manage access carefully. Confidentiality is the main buying concern for around 18% of consumers. |
| Connection and files |
Check the USB connection, operating system, file system and included cable. |
If I want to use the drive with my computer without any hassle, I’ll check the cable, port and formatting in advance. Around 12% of consumers put compatibility first. |
Common pitfalls
-
Treating one drive as a complete archive
One device is one storage location. A separate backup helps if you lose that drive, while a clear folder structure makes it easier to find files later.
Keep a separate copy and use recognisable folder names for documents, scans and research notes.
An extra copy also takes up storage space and time to keep the files organised and up to date.
-
Assuming the stated maximum speed is your guaranteed copy speed
Kingston states a speed of up to 1.050 MB/s for the XS1000 when connected to a USB 3.2 Gen 2 host. Your computer’s connection therefore matters for achieving the manufacturer’s stated speed.
Check your USB port, and don’t choose a drive based only on its maximum speed rating.
-
Assuming a compatible plug means full Mac compatibility
Toshiba states that the Canvio Ready model reviewed here is formatted for Windows and may need reformatting for full Mac compatibility.
Check the file system of the exact model and make a copy of any files already on the drive before reformatting it.
Brands to compare
Western Digital
The Elements Portable range reviewed here offers portable HDD storage.
- For the Elements Portable 2 TB, Western Digital lists dimensions of 110,5 × 82,0 × 15,0 mm and an included USB-A cable.
- Specifications indicate that reformatting may be needed for operating systems other than Windows. Check the details for the exact model.
Toshiba
The Canvio Ready and Canvio Basics ranges reviewed here are USB-powered HDDs.
- Toshiba lists a USB-A cable and Windows pre-formatting for Canvio Ready. The manufacturer also states that Canvio Basics is USB-powered.
- Compatibility information for Canvio Ready doesn’t automatically apply to Canvio Basics. Check the exact range and model.
Samsung
The Portable SSD T7 reviewed here is a 1 TB portable SSD.
- Samsung lists sequential read speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s for the T7, USB-C and USB-A connection options, and optional password protection.
- These are manufacturer claims, not speeds measured on your computer. Also check which cables are included with the model you choose.
Kingston
The XS1000 range reviewed here is a compact external SSD, available in 1 and 2 TB models.
- Kingston lists dimensions of 69,54 × 32,58 × 13,5 mm and speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s with compatible equipment.
- The stated speed depends on your equipment. Check that your computer’s connections work with the model you choose.
Seagate
The Seagate Portable range is a line of portable HDDs for tasks including backing up documents and photos.
- Seagate lists USB 3.0 and capacities of up to 5 TB for this product range.
- The features of a product range don’t necessarily tell you the dimensions of every model. Check the one you’re considering.
Joybuy products
These Joybuy products include portable external HDDs and SSDs for storing and transferring family archives.
Image unavailable
SanDisk Portable SSD 1 TB
A portable SSD option for storing or transferring family archive files.
Capacity: 1 TB.
View at Joybuy
Image unavailable
SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1 TB, 2.000 MB/s
A portable SSD option if you regularly transfer archive files.
Capacity: 1 TB. The stated maximum speed requires a compatible USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 host.
View at Joybuy
Image unavailable
WD Elements Portable 5 TB USB-C
A portable HDD option for a growing collection of scans, photos and documents.
Capacity: 5 TB. USB-C is specified in the product name.
View at Joybuy
Image unavailable
WD My Passport for Mac 2 TB Blue
A portable HDD option for a Mac archive. Check that the listed features suit the way you work.
Capacity: 2 TB. The product name specifies Time Machine readiness and password protection.
View at Joybuy
Image unavailable
WD Elements Portable 2 TB USB-C
A portable HDD option for documents, photos and other archive files.
Capacity: 2 TB. USB-C is specified in the product name.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is one external drive enough to store my family history archive?
Don’t keep irreplaceable files on just one drive. VeiligInternetten recommends keeping a recent backup, for example on an external drive or in the cloud. The National Archives also stresses the importance of organising and describing an archive.
Can I use a Windows-formatted HDD straight away for my Mac archive?
Check the specifications for the exact model. Toshiba states that the Canvio Ready model reviewed here may need reformatting for full Mac compatibility. Make a copy of any files already on the drive before reformatting it.
Does a two-year manufacturer’s warranty mean my Dutch statutory guarantee ends after that?
No. According to ACM ConsuWijzer, statutory guarantee is separate from a manufacturer’s or seller’s warranty; what you can expect from a product depends on the circumstances. A replacement drive is no substitute for a backup made in advance.
Can I put information about living family members from my archive online?
First, consider the context in which you’re publishing it. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says that, in most cases, publishing personal data publicly under the GDPR requires consent. The exception for purely personal or household use applies only under specific conditions, including sharing with a limited group and ensuring the material can’t be found through search engines. This applies to publishing and doesn’t automatically apply to an unpublished copy on your own external drive.