For an archive that is mainly kept for reference, a portable HDD is a good fit if its capacity suits the designs and versions your group wants to keep. If group members regularly transfer large files or work on them directly from the drive, consider a portable SSD instead, and check that your computer and cable support its connection. Don’t rely on a single external drive as your only copy: the National Cyber Security Centre advises keeping important data in three versions—the original and two backups.
Who is this choice relevant to?
Group archive manager
Wants to be able to find and restore finished designs and earlier versions later. An agreed process for copying and restoring files matters just as much as the drive itself. The National Cyber Security Centre also recommends testing your recovery process.
Designer who transfers files
Moves large design files between workstations or works on them from portable storage. Consider the speed, connection and file format required by the computers you use.
Volunteer whose designs contain personal data
For example, manages designs that include names or identifiable photos. If the archive contains this kind of data, tailor access and security measures to its contents and how it is used.
What should you consider when choosing?
Portable HDD
Suitable for: an archive of finished designs and versions that the group moves between workstations.
Keep in mind: HDDs have moving mechanical parts. In 2022, the Dutch Consumers’ Association described them as more susceptible to wear and shocks than SSDs.
Portable SSD
Suitable for: large files that are transferred frequently or edited directly from the drive, provided your computer and cable support the required USB connection.
Keep in mind: quoted peak speeds don’t guarantee copy times; the connection and files also make a difference.
Desktop HDD alongside a working drive
Suitable for: an archive that mainly grows in one location, with a separate drive available for transfers.
Keep in mind: the Seagate desktop model consulted also comes with a power adapter. Keep a backup on a different type of storage and in a different location too.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Recoverability |
Agree who will make copies, where a second copy will be kept and how the group will test its recovery process. |
If I want to be able to restore earlier design versions after a loss or mistake, I’ll also arrange a second copy and test recovery. Around 31% of consumers give recoverability top priority. |
| Room for versions |
Check the size of the existing archive folder and decide which drafts and final versions to keep. Compare this with the capacity of the exact model. |
I want the archive to have room for existing designs as well as new versions. Around 25% of consumers prioritise having enough archive space. |
| Computer compatibility |
Check the USB ports, whether you use Windows or Mac, and whether the drive is intended for standard files or Time Machine. |
If the same process needs to work on group members’ computers, I’ll check the format and connection in advance. Around 19% of consumers prioritise computer compatibility. |
| Access to personal data |
Check whether the archive contains personal data, who needs access and which measures are appropriate. |
If designs include names or identifiable people, I want to manage access carefully. Around 13% of consumers give restricted access top priority. |
| Speed and portability |
Work out how often large files are transferred and compare the USB connections on the drive, cable and computer. |
If I regularly move large files between workstations, transfer speed and portability matter more to me than extra archive space. Around 12% of consumers prioritise fast, portable transfers. |
Common pitfalls
-
Deleting originals as soon as they’re on one external drive
This leaves the external drive as your only copy, with no separate recovery plan. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends keeping important data in multiple versions and testing your recovery process.
Make a separate backup before deleting originals, and test that you can restore a design version.
This requires an additional storage device or location, as well as time to run recovery tests.
-
Assuming the same USB plug also means the drive works as a Mac backup
A Windows format may not be suitable for the Time Machine backup you want to make. Reformatting erases existing data; Toshiba notes this for the Canvio Basics on Mac.
Check the intended use and file format before the group saves files to the drive. Apple lists APFS or APFS (Encrypted) as suitable formats for a Time Machine backup drive.
Reformatting takes time, and existing files need to be stored safely elsewhere first.
-
Taking an SSD’s quoted peak speed as a guaranteed copy time
Manufacturer speeds apply under specific conditions. Your computer’s and cable’s connections can limit transfer speeds.
Compare the USB specifications of the drive, cable and computer, and only prioritise speed if it matters for your group’s work.
-
Treating a different capacity or product line as the same model
A 4 TB WD Elements Portable isn’t the same variant as the 2 TB WD Elements Portable. A Toshiba Canvio Ready is a different model from a Canvio Basics too.
Before buying, check the full model code, capacity, connection and product line of the variant on offer.
Brands to compare
Western Digital
WD Elements Portable is a portable HDD range. The WDBU6Y0020BBK-WESN variant has a capacity of 2 TB.
- Western Digital lists USB 3.2 Gen 1/USB 3.0 for this range.
- Don’t assume this variant has built-in encryption or a guaranteed recovery feature. Check separately if you need either.
Toshiba
Canvio Basics is a portable HDD range. The EMEA specification lists the HDTB520EK3AA variant with a capacity of 2 TB.
- Toshiba says this variant is powered via USB.
- It comes formatted as NTFS for Windows. Toshiba says it needs to be reformatted for use with a Mac.
Samsung
The portable T7 Shield is an SSD range. The Dutch product information lists the black 2 TB variant as MU-PE2T0S/EU.
- Samsung lists USB 3.2 Gen 2, sequential speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s read and 1.000 MB/s write, and an IP65 rating for this model.
- These are manufacturer specifications. Actual transfer speeds also depend on the connection and files used.
Seagate
Expansion Portable and Expansion Desktop are separate ranges. The portable variant consulted has a capacity of 5 TB.
- Seagate lists a USB Type-A cable for the Expansion Portable model consulted.
- The Expansion Desktop model consulted also uses a power adapter. Don’t confuse the features or model numbers of the two ranges.
Crucial
The X9 2TB Portable SSD, model CT2000X9SSD9, is a portable SSD option worth comparing.
- Crucial says you need a suitable USB-C-to-USB-C cable and a USB 3.2 Gen 2 host to get the highest speeds.
- Formatting and the host’s capabilities can affect compatibility. This is manufacturer information, not an independent test.
Joybuy products
These Joybuy products are portable HDDs and SSDs for storing and transferring design files. Compare the capacity and connection of the exact variant with your group’s archive and computers.
No image available
SanDisk Portable SSD 1TB
A portable SSD option for design files that your group wants to store or transfer between workstations. The product name lists a storage capacity of 1 TB.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD My Passport 6TB White
This portable HDD suits an archive where extra space matters. The product listing states a capacity of 6 TB and password protection.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Toshiba Canvio Ready 4TB Black
A portable HDD option for a growing archive that moves between workstations. The product name lists a capacity of 4 TB, a Micro-USB B connection and USB 3.2 Gen 1. Check that the connection is compatible with your computer and cable.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Samsung Portable SSD T9 4TB Black (MU-PG4T0B)
A portable SSD option for a design archive that needs extra storage space. The product name lists a capacity of 4 TB. Compare this variant’s connection with your group’s computers.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Samsung MU-PE2T0R 2TB Blue
This portable SSD is an option for transferring design files between workstations. The product name lists a capacity of 2 TB and USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2. An IP65 rating doesn’t mean the drive can be submerged.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is one external drive enough to keep all design drafts safe?
No, not if it’s the only copy of irreplaceable files. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends keeping important data in multiple versions, on different media, with one copy in another location. You should also test that you can restore your files.
Can a drive formatted for Windows be used as a Time Machine drive without any changes?
No. Apple says a drive with a Windows file system may need to be reformatted for Time Machine, which erases any existing data. Apple lists APFS or APFS (Encrypted) as formats for a new Time Machine backup drive.
Who can help if the drive you bought breaks sooner than expected?
For a consumer purchase, the seller is responsible for the Dutch statutory guarantee if a product doesn’t meet what you could reasonably expect under normal use. The Netherlands Authority for Consumers and Markets says there is no fixed period for the statutory guarantee; a manufacturer’s guarantee is separate.
Does the group need to buy a specific encrypted drive model because of the GDPR?
Not simply because it’s a community group. If the group processes personal data, the Dutch Data Protection Authority says it must choose appropriate security measures based on the processing and the risks involved. Identifiable people in photos may count as personal data. The right measures depend on what the archive contains and who needs access.