If the archive will mainly stay in one place and you expect to add more recordings, compare external HDDs with plenty of space. A portable SSD may be a better fit if you regularly carry or transfer files. Neither is a complete archive on its own: the Library of Congress recommends keeping separate copies on different storage media and in different physical locations. Also check that the files can be opened on the administrators’ computers, and decide who should have access to any recording that could identify someone.
Who is this choice relevant to?
Choir archive administrator
If you look after the original recording and later performances for future use, it’s worth keeping separate copies that you can check. A high advertised speed alone doesn’t make an archive complete. The Library of Congress recommends keeping copies on different storage media and in different locations.
Recording transfer administrator
If you regularly move files between the rehearsal room, an editor and the archive computer, consider portability, shock protection and compatible USB connections. In July 2022, the Dutch Consumers’ Association reported that HDDs are more susceptible to shock than SSDs.
Access administrator
If you decide which administrators can access a recording, consider whether people can be identified and the risks involved in processing the recording. The Dutch Data Protection Authority explains that recognisable audio recordings can contain personal data, and that organisations processing personal data must protect it properly.
What should you look for in an external drive?
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Keeping the recording safe |
Plan separate copies on different media and in different locations, and check that the recording opens after copying. |
If I don’t want to lose the original take, I’ll plan for more than one checked copy. Around 33% of consumers give preserving the recording their highest priority. |
| Room to grow |
Count your existing files and allow for planned recordings and extra copies. Choose based on the files you actually have. |
If you want to add future performances to the archive, choose capacity that suits your collection. Around 27% of consumers prioritise having room for future recordings. |
| Carrying and transferring files |
Check the USB ports and cables on both computers, and how often the drive will actually be carried around. |
If I regularly move files between administrators or work locations, connection type and portability matter. Around 20% of consumers put carrying and transferring files first. |
| Access to recordings |
Establish who can be identified, who will have access and what measures are appropriate for the purpose and risks. |
If you manage access to a recording that could identify someone, make sure any access-restriction features fit the archive’s arrangements. Around 20% of consumers give access management their highest priority. |
Archiving pitfalls
-
Assuming a fast or sturdy drive is a complete archive
An external drive can be damaged; speed or a protective casing doesn’t prove that your only take will be preserved. The Library of Congress recommends keeping separate copies on different storage media and in different physical locations.
Make a separate copy and check that the saved recording opens before clearing the original files.
Allow for the extra storage and management needed for a separate copy.
-
Not checking the connection and file system
The right port, cable and file system all help determine whether the next administrator can open the files. Toshiba lists NTFS for the Canvio Basics and says it needs reformatting for the specified macOS versions. Seagate likewise says the Basic needs reformatting for Mac.
Check the exact model and the administrators’ computers. Make a checked copy first, before reformatting a drive if necessary.
You may need a different cable or adapter; reformatting also requires a careful process.
-
Treating a permanently connected backup as an independent copy
The Dutch Consumers’ Association says ransomware can also affect files on connected external storage. A drive that stays connected all the time is therefore not the same as a copy kept separately.
Disconnect a backup drive after transferring files, and also keep a copy in another location.
Brands to consider
Toshiba
Canvio Basics is a range of portable HDDs for straightforward file storage.
- For the 2TB HDTB520EK3AA model, Toshiba lists USB 3.2 Gen 1, bus power and an included Type-A-to-Micro-B cable.
- Toshiba says the drive is formatted as NTFS and needs reformatting for the specified macOS versions. This tells you nothing about the lifespan of an individual drive.
Seagate
Basic is a range of portable HDDs for file storage.
- For STJL2000400, the Seagate data sheet lists USB 3.0, power via the USB cable and a two-year limited warranty in EMEA.
- The same data sheet says the drive needs reformatting for Mac use. A hardware warranty is no substitute for keeping a separate archive copy.
Western Digital
My Passport is a range of portable HDDs. The manufacturer lists a black 2TB model with the model number WDBYVG0020BBK-WESN.
- The manufacturer identifies the model in question as a black 2TB My Passport.
- Check the specifications of the exact model, including its connection and warranty terms, before ordering.
Samsung
The portable SSD T7 Shield MU-PE1T0S/EU is a 1TB model.
- For this model, Samsung lists USB 3.2 Gen 2, maximum sequential read and write speeds of 1.050/1.000 MB/s, IP65 and software for setting a password.
- These are the manufacturer’s specifications and claims, not independent test results or a guarantee against data loss.
Kingston
XS1000 is a range of compact portable SSDs available in 1TB and 2TB models.
- Kingston lists USB 3.2 Gen 2, maximum read and write speeds of 1.050/1.000 MB/s, and a cable and adapter for USB-A and USB-C devices.
- These are advertised maximum speeds. Check the capacity and specification of the model you’re considering.
Joybuy products for storage and transfer
This selection includes portable SSDs for transferring files and portable HDDs for extra storage space. An external drive is not a complete archive on its own: the Library of Congress recommends keeping separate copies on different storage media and in different locations.
No image available
SanDisk Extreme Pro Portable SSD 1TB
A portable SSD option for carrying and transferring recording files.
1 TB; the product name lists 2000 MB/s. According to the product description, the stated maximum read speed requires a compatible USB 3.2 Gen 2x2 device.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Samsung MU-PG2T0B 2TB black
A portable SSD option for transferring recording files between work locations.
2 TB; the product name lists USB Type-C and USB 3.2 Gen 2x2.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD My Passport 6TB white
A portable HDD option when you need space for a collection of recordings and the drive will mainly stay in one place.
6 TB; the product description lists USB 3.0.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD My Passport 2TB blue
A portable HDD option for recording files when the capacity is right for the amount of storage you need.
2 TB; the product description lists USB 3.0.
View at Joybuy
No image available
WD My Passport 4TB black
A portable HDD option for a recording archive that needs more space than a smaller capacity can offer.
4 TB; the product description lists USB 3.0.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is one external drive enough for the only copy of a choir recording?
No, not if you want to preserve the recording. The Library of Congress recommends keeping copies on at least two different storage media and in different physical locations. After transferring files, check that the important ones have copied across properly. This is archiving guidance, not a Dutch legal minimum requirement for a choir.
Do you need to convert an audio recording to a particular format?
At the very least, keep the original take you have. The Library of Congress lists WAVE with LPCM as a preferred format for long-term audio storage, but that doesn’t mean every existing recording needs to be converted. Make a note of which file is the original and check that the archive copy plays.
Can a Windows-formatted HDD be used straight away on a new administrator’s Mac?
Don’t assume so without checking. Toshiba lists NTFS for Canvio Basics and says it needs reformatting for the specified macOS versions. Seagate likewise says the Basic needs reformatting for Mac. Check the computers first and make a checked copy before reformatting, if necessary.
What happens if the drive fails too soon during normal use?
For a consumer purchase in the Netherlands, ACM ConsuWijzer explains that if a product is faulty during normal use, the seller must provide a solution free of charge, such as a repair, replacement or refund, depending on what you could reasonably expect from the product. This doesn’t mean there is a fixed warranty period or compensation for lost recordings, so keep separate copies.
Can a community archive store and share a choir recording without privacy arrangements?
If people can be identified in the recording, it may contain personal data. An organisation needs a GDPR legal basis for processing it and must put appropriate security measures in place; consent is one possible legal basis. Whether this particular take can be shared depends on the recording, the purpose and the legal basis chosen.